The Israeli narrative is deeply entrenched in mainstream discourse of the US. The analysis of the media coverage of Israel’s occupation over the last 50 years across five major American newspapers shows that there are “deep pockets” of Israeli lobby.

THREAD
Tho five newspapers include the Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times, The New York Times, The Washington Post and The Wall Street Journal.

1. The number of headlines citing Israel over the 50-year period is more than four times than that of headlines citing Palestine. Image
2. Israeli sources are near two and half times (250%) more likely to be quoted as Palestinian ones.
3. The mention of “Palestine
Refugees” has declined by 93% over the 50-year period.
4. Israeli headlines were statistically more significantly positive than Palestinian ones.
5. As per the UN report on Israel's Operation Protective Edge in Gaza back in 2014, 2,251 Palestinians died, including 1,460 civilians, 556 of whom were children. The number of Israeli officials brought to speak on @CNN were 20 compared to only four Palestinian.
6. Over the 50-year time period, there has been a near 85% decline in the instances of the word ‘occupation’ in Israel centric headlines. In the Palestine corpus, there has been a 65% decline in the word occupation.
7. The power imbalance between the military might of Israelis and Palestinians, who are often armed with nothing more than rocks and rockets, has been described as “enhanced fireworks”. No distinction is made between the occupier and the victim.
(Democracy Now, 2018)
8. Greg Shupak of the University of Guelph in Canada has done empirical study of US media's coverage in his book “The Wrong Story”. Shupak shows that in five editorials immediately before and those during IDF's Operation Protective Edge in Gaza back in 2014,
the New York Times mentions the blockade of Gaza by Israel only once. The blockade was a key factor in the lead up to the conflict (Shupak, 2018, p.15). Obscuring the
importance of the siege to Palestinians distorts the narrative of Protective Edge in Israel’s favor.
(p.15).
9. In another instance, Shupak cites a Times editorial published on July 25th during Protective Edge - in which the editors write that “the war is terrorizing innocent people on both sides of the Gaza border”.

While day prior to the publication of the editorial, a UN report..
claimed two Israeli civilians had been killed, while a staggering 538
Palestinian civilians (including 186 children) had died.

10. The continuing blockade of Gaza since 2006, one that has seen two major wars in the past decade, has been a significant factor.
But the unigram ‘blockade’ in the Palestine corpus is mentioned
a mere 30 times in the five newspapers. In contrast, unigrams mentioning Hamas over the same period was 394.

While the unigram ‘terror’ and its affiliated words appear over 1092 times in the Israeli corpus.
11. The word terror appear almost three times as much in the Palestinian dataset – 316 to be exact - compared to the word occupation.

12. The unigrams related to economic hardships faced by the Palestinians appeared only 122 times as identified in the Palestinian corpus.
Reference:
“50 Years of Occupation: Sentiment and N-Gram Analysis of US Mainstream Media Coverage of the Israeli Occupation of Palestine” by Usaid Siddiqui and Owais A. Zaheer

416labs.com/blog/2018/12/1…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Fidato

Fidato Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @tequieremos

25 Nov
Tipu Sultan's victory against the British at the Battle of Pollilur in 1790 is often described as ‘the severest blow that the British ever sustained in India’, and resonated for years in both Britain and Mysore. By the end of year, one in five if all the British soldiers in....
..India were held prisoner by Tipu In his sophisticated fortress of Seringapatam. For thirty years, first Haidar Ali, Tipu’s father, then Tipu himself, had been at the forefront of the British public’s consciousness. Tales of attacks on British forces appeared in the newspapers.
Tipu was the most feared ruler of his time in Britain. When he died there were jubilant celebrations. Authors and play writers were also a part of it. The siege and looting of Tipu’s capital at Srirangapattana is the opening scene of Wilkie Collins’ famous novel, The Moonstone.
Read 10 tweets
22 Nov
I think Abhinandan will muster up enough courage someday to admit that he did not shot down any F-16 and that he has been used as a political pawn to conceal the humiliating defeat of IAF in the dogfight against PAF in 2019.

Why I call it a ‘humiliating defeat' is because...
..Indian govt categorically said that Pakistan's actions on the morning of 27th Feb were an ‘act of war’.

With a three times larger force, India should have responded but it's military leadership was in a state of paralysis after Pakistan's swift response in broad day light...
..along with the killing of 6 IAF personnel including a senior officer in fratricide when a surface-to-air missile hit a Mi-17. It all happened on a day when IAF was on its highest alert levels.

Giving Abhinandan a gallantry award is a red herring against the military failures.
Read 4 tweets
17 Nov
The Islamic month of Rabi al-Thani marks the death anniversary of the rose of Baghdad, Hazrat Sheikh Abdul Qadir Jillani.

Someone asked what brought him to his high spiritual level, he said:

‘The truthfulness which I promised to my mother’. He related the following story:
“One day, on the eve of Eid al-Adhā, I went to my mother, who was then a widow and requested her, ‘Send me to the path of truth, give me permission to go to Baghdad to acquire knowledge, to be with the wise and those who are close to Allah”.
She cried, but she brought out 80 pieces of gold, which was all that my father had left as inheritance. She put aside forty pieces for my brother. Other forty she sewed into the armpit of my coat. Then she perimitted me to leave, but before she let me go she made me promise her..
Read 10 tweets
16 Nov
‘When Alexander and his forces marched through Balochistan in modern day Pakistan’

Arguably, the earliest account of Balochistan was written by Lucius Flavius Arrianus (Arrian) whose Anabasis of Alexander described Alexander’s campaigns and his epic march through the deserts...
...of Balochistan and the Makran coast on his way back to Greece. During the retreat in 325 BC, he was greatly harried by the Baloch. His biographer wrote, ‘I had never seen the Great Alexander so sad and dejected—filled with sorrow and uncertainty.…
The outcome of fighting with the Baloch people was disastrous for Alexander’s army and against himself.’ Alexander, in fact, had almost perished during the campaign that took the lives of almost three quarters of his army.
Read 5 tweets
15 Nov
Over 3,400 Muslims were killed in the violence triggered by L.K. Advani’s ‘Rath Yatra’ campaign in 1990 which brought BJP to the doorstep of power. In the 1984 elections, the BJP won only two Lok Sabha seats but in the 1991 general elections after the Rath Yatra, the BJP won...
..120 seats. Between April 1989 and April 1990, 262 people died in Gujarat, mostly were Muslims. In October 1990, days after Advani’s yatra began, 41 were killed in Ahmedabad. The same month, 52 were killed in Jaipur, 20 in Jodhpur, 33 in Lucknow, over 100 in Delhi, 37 in Assam,
18 in Patna and 165 in Hyderabad. Also in October, a pogrom against Muslims in Bhagalpur, Bihar, saw 960 killed in which 900 were Muslims. In November, 31 were killed in Agra, again mostly Muslim and 13 in Indore. In Dec, 60 were killed in Karnataka and 134 in Hyderabad.
Read 10 tweets
2 Nov
For those in Pakistan who think that India should be the least of our worries, here are some important facts:

1. As per the findings of @DisinfoEU report, Indian govt has been running 750 fake media outlets to undermine Pakistan across 119 countries from the last 15 years.
2. Despite losing 43,000 sq km of land equivalent to the area of Switzerland in the 1962 Sino-Indian war, Pakistan has remained the raison d'etre of Indian military. It has deployed 10 out of 14 corps exclusively for Pakistan along with 81% of Indian Air Force (IAF) bases.
3. India has amassed enough fissile material to make 2600 nuclear weapons.

4. As per the latest SIPRI report for 2020, India's defense spending is $72 billion out of which $18.52 billion has been allocated for buying equipment; more than total military spending of Pakistan.
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(