Keep Current with Robin Enochs

Robin Enochs Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @RobinEnochs

Apr 3
From Grok
Let’s dive into exploring food assistance programs that might allow immigrants to use a barcode on their phone to access groceries without the need for scanning individual items at checkout, as observed in Naomi Wolf’s X post.
1. Understanding the Context of Food Assistance for Immigrants in NYC
New York City has a large immigrant population, including many from Central America, and a robust network of food assistance programs. Immigrants, especially recent arrivals, often face barriers to accessing traditional programs like SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) due to eligibility restrictions, language barriers, or documentation requirements.
As a result, local governments, nonprofits, and community organizations often create alternative programs to fill these gaps, some of which may use innovative technology like mobile barcodes to streamline access.

The web results provided offer some context:
- **SNAP Eligibility for Non-Citizens (web:0)**: While SNAP typically uses EBT cards, some non-citizens are ineligible or face waiting periods (e.g., five years of residency or 40 qualifying work quarters). However, states can offer alternative nutrition programs for non-eligible non-citizens, sometimes using electronic systems like barcodes or apps.

- **Community Food Connection – ACCESS NYC (web:2)**: This resource notes that everyone in NYC, regardless of immigration status, is eligible for food assistance through pantries and community kitchens.
While this doesn’t directly mention barcodes, it highlights the city’s commitment to accessible food programs, which could extend to innovative distribution methods.

### 2. Potential Food Assistance Programs Using Barcodes
Let’s explore programs or systems that might fit the description of using a phone barcode without requiring item scanning:

A. Local Nonprofit or Community-Based Programs
Nonprofits in NYC often partner with grocery stores to provide food assistance to vulnerable populations, including immigrants. Some may use digital voucher systems to simplify the process:
- **New York Immigration Coalition (NYIC) and Partners**:
The NYIC collaborates with community organizations to provide emergency food assistance to immigrants.
While they typically distribute physical vouchers or EBT-like cards, some programs have shifted to digital solutions. For example, a nonprofit might issue a digital voucher in the form of a barcode or QR code that a recipient shows at a participating store.

The store might have a pre-arranged agreement to bill the nonprofit directly for the purchases, bypassing the need to scan individual items.

- **How It Might Work**: The barcode could represent a pre-approved credit or allowance (e.g., $200 for groceries). The cashier verifies the barcode, confirms the customer’s identity or eligibility, and allows the purchase without scanning items, as the total is charged to the program’s account.

- **Relevance to Immigrants**: Many NYIC programs target undocumented or recent immigrants who are ineligible for SNAP, aligning with the Central American immigrant in Wolf’s post.
- **Food Bank for New York City**:
This organization operates programs like the Community Food Connection, which partners with local stores to provide food access.

While they typically focus on pantry distribution, they’ve experimented with mobile technology in the past, such as apps for scheduling pantry visits. A pilot program could involve a barcode system where recipients are pre-approved to shop at specific stores, and the store reconciles the purchases with the food bank later.
- **No Scanning?**: If the barcode represents a fixed credit or a pre-approved shopping list, the cashier might only need to verify the code, not scan each item, especially if the store has a bulk billing arrangement with the food bank.
Pt2

B. City or State Pilot Programs for Immigrants
New York City and State have a history of piloting innovative food assistance programs, especially for migrants and undocumented individuals:
- **NYC Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs (MOIA)**:
MOIA often coordinates with local organizations to provide emergency food assistance. In response to the migrant influx in recent years (e.g., over 170,000 migrants arriving in NYC since 2022, per city data), the city has launched temporary programs to address food insecurity. One such program could involve a mobile app with a barcode system, especially after the debit card voucher program ended in November 2024 (web:1).
- **Possible Mechanism**: The city might contract with supermarkets in immigrant-heavy neighborhoods like Brooklyn to accept a digital barcode as payment. The barcode could link to a city-funded account, allowing the recipient to shop up to a certain limit. The cashier might not need to scan items if the store uses a point-of-sale system that automatically charges the city’s account for the total, or if the program allows for manual verification.
- **Why No Receipt?**: If the transaction is processed as a bulk payment to the city or a third party, the customer might not receive a traditional receipt, as the purchase isn’t tied to a personal payment method.
- **HRA (Human Resources Administration) Emergency Food Assistance**:
NYC’s HRA oversees food programs for low-income residents, including some tailored for immigrants. While HRA typically administers SNAP, they also manage emergency food initiatives that might use alternative distribution methods. A pilot program could involve a mobile app where eligible immigrants receive a monthly barcode to use at designated stores.
- **Brooklyn Context**: In lower-income neighborhoods, stores might participate in such programs to serve the community, especially if they have a large immigrant customer base. The cashier’s familiarity with the process (and shared background with the customer) could explain the lack of formal scanning.

#### C. Store-Specific Initiatives
Some supermarkets in NYC, especially in immigrant-heavy areas, partner directly with community organizations or create their own programs to support customers:
- **Key Food, Associated Supermarkets, or Similar Chains in Brooklyn**:
These smaller chains are common in Brooklyn and often serve immigrant communities. They might have agreements with local nonprofits or city programs to accept digital barcodes for food assistance. For example, a store could allow pre-approved customers to shop using a barcode, with the store later invoicing the program for the total amount.
- **No Scanning Process**: If the barcode represents a pre-set allowance (e.g., $150 per month), the cashier might only need to verify the code and ensure the total doesn’t exceed the limit, without scanning each item. The store could track purchases internally and bill the program in bulk.
- **Cultural Connection**: The cashier and customer being from the same region might mean the cashier is familiar with the program and trusts the process, leading to a more informal interaction (e.g., waving the customer through).

#### D. Tech-Driven Food Assistance Apps
Some food assistance programs have adopted mobile technology to streamline distribution, especially for hard-to-reach populations:
- **Fresh EBT or Similar Apps**:
While Fresh EBT (now called Providers) is primarily for SNAP users to check balances, some nonprofits have developed similar apps for their own programs. A local organization in NYC might use an app to issue digital vouchers as barcodes, which recipients show at checkout.
- **How It Fits**: The app could generate a unique barcode for each shopping trip, linked to a specific store or program. The cashier verifies the barcode, and the store processes the payment through the app’s backend, potentially bypassing item scanning if the system is designed for bulk billing.
Pt 3

- **World Food Programme (WFP) or UNHCR-Style Systems**:
Internationally, organizations like the WFP use mobile-based voucher systems for refugees, often in partnership with local retailers. While less common in the U.S., a similar model could be piloted in NYC for migrants or refugees, especially given the influx of Central American and Afghan migrants in recent years (web:0 mentions Afghan parolees). A barcode system could allow recipients to shop without scanning, as the store reconciles the total with the program later.

### 3. Why No Scanning or Receipt?

The lack of scanning and receipt in Wolf’s observation is a key detail. Here’s how this might happen in a
legitimate program:
- **Bulk Billing Agreements**: If the store has a contract with a program (e.g., a nonprofit, city agency, or food bank), they might not need to scan items at the point of sale.

Instead, the store tracks purchases and bills the program in bulk, either daily or monthly.

The barcode could simply identify the customer as eligible, and the cashier ensures the purchase aligns with program rules (e.g., no alcohol or non-food items).

- **Pre-Approved Limits**: The barcode might represent a fixed credit (e.g., $200).

The cashier verifies the code and allows the purchase as long as the total is within the limit, without needing to scan each item.

- **No Receipt for Non-Personal Transactions**: If the payment isn’t coming from the customer’s personal funds but from a third party (e.g., a city program), the customer might not receive a receipt, as the transaction is logged on the program’s end, not the customer’s.

4. Challenges and Gaps in Identifying Such Programs
- **Lack of Public Documentation**: Many pilot programs, especially those for undocumented immigrants, are not widely publicized to avoid scrutiny or misuse. This makes it hard to find specific examples of barcode-based systems in NYC as of April 2025.

- **Discontinuation of Similar Programs**: The NYC debit card program for migrants (web:1) ended in November 2024, but it shows the city’s willingness to experiment with alternative methods. A barcode system could have been a replacement or a concurrent pilot.

- **Store-Level Discretion**: The process Wolf observed might be specific to that supermarket, possibly an informal arrangement or a misunderstanding of a program’s rules by the cashier. Without more details (e.g., the store’s name or the program’s branding on the barcode), it’s hard to pinpoint the exact system.

5. Hypothetical Example of How This Might Work
Let’s imagine a plausible program that fits Wolf’s description:

- **Program**: The Brooklyn Immigrant Food Access Initiative (fictional, for illustrative purposes), funded by a combination of city grants and private donations, partners with local supermarkets to provide food assistance to recent immigrants.

- **Process**:
1. Eligible immigrants (e.g., those with Temporary Protected Status or recent arrivals) register with the program through a community center.

2. They receive a mobile app that generates a monthly barcode, representing a $150 food credit at participating stores.

3. At the store, the customer shows the barcode to the cashier, who verifies it through a store portal or simply recognizes the program’s logo.

4. The cashier allows the customer to take the groceries without scanning, as the store will bill the program for the total later.

5. No receipt is issued to the customer, as the transaction is recorded on the program’s end.

- **Why It Fits**: This setup explains the lack of scanning (bulk billing), the absence of a receipt (third-party payment), and the focus on immigrants (targeted eligibility).

6. Conclusion
While I couldn’t identify a specific, documented program in NYC as of April 2025 that uses a phone barcode without item scanning for immigrants, the scenario is plausible given the city’s history of innovative food assistance initiatives.
Read 4 tweets
Oct 18, 2022
DIRECT LINK-tell them NO

Comments must be received on or before October 20, 2022!

Submit comments,
identified by Docket No. “CDC-2022-0111 and CDC”
Read 6 tweets
Mar 3, 2022
🧵 on World food crisis - shipping decisions and the swift move to the 2030 Agenda
End of Shipping for zero carbon
Full video
Read 6 tweets
Mar 2, 2022
Short 🧵 How I think I’ll look skiing on Spring Break ⛷vs How I actually look
Read 5 tweets
Sep 23, 2021
.@JesseKellyDC have you seen this? says “this is Chinese propaganda..it’s divide & conquer…do you think this is going to go away? This is never gonna go away until we the people stop them!”

Everyone needs to be like THIS
Take action, she even gives the guy courage to help her
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(