1/ The Montana Attorney General has just released his opinion on critical race theory (CRT) instruction in that state's public schools, and it's reasonable, well-argued, and worth reading.

This thread summarizes it.

2/ "A school unlawfully discriminates on the basis of race if it has effectively caused, encouraged, accepted, tolerated or failed to correct a racially hostile environment."
3/ "Antiracism therefore assigns immutable negative characteristics to individuals solely based upon their race or ethnicity. And it manages to frame any philosophical disagreement or objection to this assignment as—you guessed it—racism."
4/ "The driving force behind CRT and antiracism is the total acceptance of a specific worldview... Being a so-called 'antiracist' requires individuals to accept these premises... Individuals who do not comply cannot truly be 'antiracist,' and are, therefore, considered racist."
5/ "Disagreement with any aspect becomes irrefutable evidence of its premises of systemic racism, bias, fragility, or white supremacy. In short, it is a conclusion in search of a methodology..."
6/ "Committing racial discrimination in the name of ending racial discrimination is both illogical and illegal."
7/ "[R]acial segregation, race stereotyping, and race scapegoating. These concepts violate civil rights laws because they constitute racial harassment and/or require authority figures to engage in activities that result in different treatment on the basis of race."
8/ "This opinion, therefore, should not be construed to limit a school or government entity’s ability to use, present, or discuss these materials, where appropriate."

[ANRC: This qualifier is important, necessary, and good.]
9/ "But the law will not tolerate schools, other government entities, or employers implementing CRT and antiracist programing in a way that treats individuals differently on the basis of race or that creates a hostile environment."
10/ "Government entities also may not engage in 'race scapegoating,'’ which means assigning fault, blame, or bias to a race or to members of a race because of their race."
11/ "[A] school that permits, promotes, or endorses curricula or pedagogical methods that tell an individual that he or she should feel discomfort, guilt, anguish... on account of his or her race, almost certainly creates a racially hostile environment."
12/ "A school may not advocate that students adopt specific beliefs based on their race, such as urging that white students be white without signing on to whiteness. Schools may not attempt to purge the idea of 'whiteness' (or any other race) from schools."
13/ "Nothing in this opinion shall be construed to restrict any expressive activities protected under the U.S. Constitution, including academic freedom or student political speech.'

[ANRC: CRT can be *discussed* in classes, but not taught normatively.]
14/ "The First Amendment prevents the government from restricting protected speech, but it also prevents compelled speech."
15/ "Trainings, exercises, or assignments which force students or employees to admit, accept, affirm, or support controversial concepts such as privilege, culpability, identity, or status, constitute compelled speech."
16/ "Schools or other entities that violate state or federal civil rights laws jeopardize their funding and may be liable for damages. There are a variety of legal avenues available for victims of discrimination."

The only weakness in the opinion — and it's not a major one — is that he over-cites Kendi and DiAngelo, both of whom are probably best viewed as popularizers of CRT ideas rather than established scholarly critical race theorists.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with A New Radical Centrism

A New Radical Centrism Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @a_centrism

27 May
The only people who claim that behavioral variation among people has nothing to do with their genes are ideologues: “pure blank slaters."

— Jerry Coyne

"We know that virtually all studies of traits that vary among individuals—be those traits morphological, physiological, or behavioral—show that some or even a lot of the variation in a population is based on variation in the genes of different individuals."
"For some traits, like adult IQ, number of sexual partners, alcohol dependence, autism spectrum placement, and schizophrenia, heritabilities are over 50%."
Read 4 tweets
26 May
Rufo handled this the way he needed to. As the guy leading the anti-CRT movement, he played it smart.

But if it had been me being asked the question, I wouldn't have hesitated in answering, "Western civilization."
"You know, basically 95% of all scientific advances of the past 500 years, most of the cultural advances, the spread of democracy, and historically-unprecedented prosperity. That iPhone in your pocket, that prescription drug that keeps you alive, the car that gets you to work..."
Western civilization is my culture. The greatest culture in the history of the world. That's what "I like about being white." That this civilization is my cultural lineage.
Read 4 tweets
25 May
Identity politics, whether you like it or not, is the future.

Fighting against it will be as futile as trying to reverse the direction of ocean tides.

It's peaking now, but will ebb slightly, and then return like a tsunami once whites become a majority minority around 2045.
The key is not to fight the inevitable, but to harness the power of your group to keep it from being inundated. It's going to be ugly and brutal.
The pill is black, but if you refuse to take it, you won't survive.
Read 4 tweets
23 May
Which era of film had the most memorable actors and actresses with the most star power and screen presence?

(See next few tweets for sample listings of prominent actors from each era.)
1930-1960: Cary Grant, Humphrey Bogart, Katherine Hepburn, John Wayne, Marilyn Monroe, Clark Gable, Bette Davis, James Stewart, Greta Garbo, Ingrid Bergman, Spencer Tracy, Lana Turner, Robert Mitchum, Henry Fonda...
1960-1990: Robert De Niro, Meryl Streep, Paul Newman, Sophia Loren, Robert Redford, Dustin Hoffman, Diane Keaton, Al Pacino, Sidney Poitier, Clint Eastwood, Steve McQueen, Jack Nicholson, Harrison Ford...
Read 7 tweets
22 May
Serious question: In all the hate crime video clips that have emerged over the last few weeks, have any shown a perpetrator who wasn't either a person of color or leftwing?
By "person of color" let's use the standard leftwing definition, which would include Arabs.
Personally, I think calling a Palestinian Arab a "person color" is dumb, but I'll indulge the left's definitions this time.
Read 4 tweets
21 May
1/ Republicans have apparently been instructed to publicly refer to all incidents of CRT-influenced weirdness as "Marxism," even though this is rarely accurate. It's every bit as laughable and transparent as Democrats referring to stuff they don't like as "white supremacy."
2/ The fact that some CRT ideas draw from Critical Theory ("Frankfurt School"), which was a neo-Marxist approach to society and culture, doesn't make CRT "Marxism."
3/ The route looks like this:

Marxism (economics and politics) ---> Critical Theory (neo-Marxist approach to society and culture) ---> Critical Race Theory (racialized variant of Critical Theory)
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!