Masculine nationalism was not limited to the 19/20th ce Bengali men, but was also propagated by prominent women of the Bengali society. One such woman was Sarala Debi, who comes from the Tagore family, a Brahmo family that has been constantly accused of promoting effeteness.
+
Sarala Debi Ghosal was Gurudev's niece and had close ties with Swami Vivekananda. She was introduced to militant nationalism through Bankim Chandra Chatterjee's Anandamath & Aurobindo Ghosh. She felt that the Bengali society needed to regain manhood through martial training
+
She oft quoted, "battles of England are fought & won in the fields of Eton." which credits public schools of Eton that promoted careers in military, civil services & church for the martial success of England. She believed only muscular nationalism could revive the civilization.
+
In 1902, Manilal Ganguly, nephew of Satish Chandra Mukherjee, editor of Dawn, invited her to run a literary society. Instead she requested him to conduct Pratapaditya Utsav to commemorate his coronation as the ruler of Jessore after defeating the Mughals.
+
Manilal organised the first Pratapaditya Utsav in 1903. She addressed a gathering of Bhowanipur, Kalighat, Ballygunge & Bagbazar Boy's Ass. to celebrate the first Pratapaditya Utsob. This was the 1st time that someone placed Bengalis on the same plane as heroic martial races.
+
The program included the reading of Pratapaditya's biography, display of indigenous martial arts like wrestling, boxing, fencing, stick fighting etc. by Bengali youth. The famous family of wrestlers, the Guhos of Masjidbari actively participated in the event.
+
Boxers like Sailen Bose, nephew of Bhupen Bose also graced the event. It was noted that the event was one of a kind where a woman presided over a predominantly men's function & promoted masculinity. The event hugely promoted martial arts amongst young Bengali men.
+
In 1904, Sarala Debi organised Birashtami Utsav on the 8th day of Durga Puja to celebrate martial prowess. Men vowed to Durga Ma in the name of Hindu martial heroes like Krishna, Bhishm, Shivaji, Pratapaditya, et al to dedicate their lives to building a strong & manly nation.
+
Another festival popularised by Sarala Debi was Raksha Bandhan. She used the event to promote national fraternity where women and men would tie Rakhis to men and urge them to join the battle for independence through Hindu revivalism.
+
Apart from addressing events, she was also a fiery writer. She suggested (The Bengalee '03) that sword should be the symbol of new national self consciousness. Her journal Bharati carried many articles on Bengali Hindu heroes incl. Senapati Kali, general of Pratapaditya's army.
+
She believed that the only way to answer back to aspersions of effeminacy cast by the British on Bengali character was through reviving old traditions and re inventing rituals. She was well conscious of the humiliation and indignity attached to such blatant stereotypes.
+
Sarala Debi, a mere footnote in the history of Bengal's Hindu revivalism must be celebrated for promoting "martial heroism within the limits of Hindu ritualistic practice." and for using Hindu martial heroes of the past to reinvigorate a new generation of Bengali Hindus.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Have a few thoughts on this.
There's no denying the fact that Ray expected his audience to be "intelligent" - intelligent here does not imply high education or cultural background, but the ability to comprehend objectively.
What he deserved was an intelligent audience that would watch his art or atleast an engage in constructive criticism. He often got none from the masses beyond Bengal but received plenty from the masses in Bengal & globally. Other parts of India, was majorly averse to his art.
People shitting on Ray for calling the Indian audience backward have happily consumed brain dead movies that were produced in Bollywood (exceptions being those movies directed by Bengali exports) for decades now.
Lots of people hating on Bose for his alleged Nazi connections.
In J.H. Voigt's (noted German writer) words, Netaji made a distinction between the Nazi regime and the German nation. His joining hands with Hitler was not an expression of his support of the Nazi ideology.
+
"It was nothing but the abortive attempt to rally German support, and later also Japanese, to gain independence for India."
He specifically mentions that Bose was impressed with the German military success but unhappy about Hitler's policy.
+
Voigt observed that the only cause which Bose had was India's independence. Thus, he had to overcome his strong inhibitions to Nazi ideology & threw in his lot with Hitler. He was prepared to do nothing for Germany but anything including harnessing German interests for India.
+
Read about another Bengali wrestler of the colonial period. Bhabendra Mohan Saha, better known as Bheem Bhabani for his wrestling prowess, was connected to the akhada of another eminent wrestler family of his time, the Gohos of North Calcutta.
+
A physically weak child, Saha was often bullied by other kids. Moreover, he contracted malaria frequently causing his physical strength to deteriorate. This is when he decided to join akhada and build his body.
+
He initially joined Atindrakrishna Basu's akhada, where he learnt the basics of wrestling. He gained prominence after defeating senior wrestlers of his time by employing superior tact and speed. He next moved to Kheticharan Goho's akhada (relative of the great Gobor Goho).
+
This year marks the completion of Satyajit Ray's centenary, yet the ghosts of poverty porn & exoticization allegations have not stopped lurking around. Routinely attacked by the Indian RW, here's why some of his most criticized works have little to do with these allegations.
+
Ray's 1st & India's 1st film that received international acclaim, was more of Bibhutibhushan Bandapadhyay's creation than Ray's. It was a bildungsroman novel set in rural Bengal, an emerging genre then, where the author traces the moral and psychological growth of a character.
+
Coming to "romanticizing poverty", it must be noted that Panther Panchali was Bibhutibhushan's partly autobiographical work, greatly influenced by his own childhood. Calling this poverty porn is the denial of a man's experiences and more importantly Bengal's rural history.
+
Colonial Bengal's muscular nationalism gave rise to the wrestling and akhada culture in Bengal, which in turn, placed India on the globe's wrestling map. The Guho family and their disciples are credited for establishing & popularizing the art of wrestling in Bengal.
+
Starting with Gobor Guho (Jatindra Charan Guho), born into the family of wrestlers, he is the best known wrestler of his time from Bengal or even India. On reaching adulthood, he was 6'1" and weighed around 130 kgs. His expanded chest measured 48 inches.
+
Born to Ramcharan Guho, son of great wrestler Ambika Charan, Gobor learnt the art of wrestling under the tutelage of his uncle Khetracharan & grandfather Ambika. The latter set up an akhada near Hatibagan, that became a breeding ground for revolutionary nationalist activities.
+