I’ve been trying not to wade into this much bc I hate being reactive to foolishness, but it’s annoying as hell being a Black woman lawyer taught by a number of preeminent Critical Race Theory pioneers and see it butchered like this, from every end of the ideological spectrum.
Critical Race Theory is a form of legal scholarship that responded to a pervasive ideology that the law/legal decisions were colorblind. This should not be controversial in 2021.
Other fields then applied certain CRT tenants to their studies.
Critical Race Theory is not “diversity & inclusion” programs. It’s not even primarily about mandating an accurate reframing of history (though it can include that).
Its founders are legal scholars who felt it necessary to apply a racial lens to understanding US laws.
It spun off from leftist Critical Legal Studies, which was premised on the idea that law could enforce and perpetuate injustice, instead of being some neutral, apolitical science.
But many CRT scholars felt analysis of race and the role of white supremacy in the development of US law & legal decisions was severely lacking.
CRT came in to fill in a gap in legal scholarship to explain our legal system; not to be an overarching explanation of all the things in the world.
Still, leading CRT scholars often examine the role of class, gender, and other social statuses & their relationship with the law.
So no it’s not taught in grade school & it shouldn’t be!
No one is teaching 2nd graders organic chemistry or calculus.
Think of this similarly & respect Black scholarship.
Studying case law & policy is hard AF (umm that’s why law schools exist) & that’s what CRT scholars focus on.
So if by CRT you just mean “history,” just say that.
But these are two separate fields.
And if you’re a mainstream media outlet trying to explain CRT without consulting or interviewing any of the current living, breathing scholars— from Kendall Thomas to Patricia Williams to Kimberle Williams Crenshaw, what are you really doing?
It’s not even about responding to the right at this point, it’s just good journalism, cuz too many damn people out here confused & it’s taken every ounce of my patience not to respond to every single person perpetuating falsehoods, from liberals, to right wingers, to “leftists.”
*tenets
CRT has been living rent-free in these people’s minds so forgive the freudian slip
and by separate I don’t mean they’re in a vacuum. they obviously interact. but in academic settings, they’re simply not the same
And y’all know I love a good resource. Folks may recommend “Critical Race Theory: The Key Writings That Formed the Movement,” (L) but it’s really an academic text, bc it was meant for this world of legal scholarship. I’d suggest “Critical Race Theory: An Introduction) (R)
You can also just read Cornel West’s foreword in the book on the left, if you want something quick and/or just read the “Scholarship” section of Derrick Bell’s wiki
I’ll add the caveat that principles proposed by & derived from CRT are helpful learning tools for most any age.
For example, the idea that racism is a tool to maintain power relations and less about individual encounters, something taught in CRT, is not just for grad students.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
It’s not lost on me that after the largest demonstration against police violence in the US, we gained a pro-police administration in 2020. After possibly the biggest movement for Palestinian liberation we have witnessed while seeing the depths of America’s imperialist violence, patriotism is being whipped into a frenzy.
We are reminded that America is indeed an empire. Its leaders will always serve that function, whatever the party, whatever the race. For leftists who wish to see a different world, it’s important not to despair.
The masses are not radical. They are simply human. They want comfort, not revolution. Hopeful words give people comfort. “Representation” gives people comfort. Even if their material needs will never be properly met by our major political parties, feelings often trump facts.
So @NPR has a cutsey photo spread of MAGA supporters at the RNC in Milwaukee. I live here. Nothing about their presence and this convention should be normalized.
The last few days have felt dystopian. Cops were shipped from out of state to beef up security. Some of them are trigger happy. Some of them shot and killed a Black Milwaukee man who was nearly a mile away from the venue.
What elected officials tried to paint as a boon for the city feels like collective punishment. Many residents stayed home and some businesses closed for the week *precisely* to avoid the kind of conflict that comes from a regime that glorifies state and vigilante violence, repression and racism
There were security barriers on top of security barriers. Cops sweeping every pocket of downtown on horseback, on bikes, in patrol cars. It mostly felt lifeless and somber. I felt like a wake.
Hope and possibilities feel dead for a lot of people. And all I could think about this past week is how these two major political parties got us to this point.
Many of us use the term “criminal legal system” instead of “criminal justice,” because what is legal is not the same as what is just.
People can debate legal nuances of a few seconds in the Rittenhouse case, and they likely will for the weeks, months, or years ahead.
But I’ve seen firsthand how folks in Wisconsin have continuously been at the mercy of injustice for decades.
I was in Kenosha the night of the killings and witnessed Philando Castile’s girlfriend have to relive the trauma of gun wielding men who argued about the priority of their abstract rights, while the man she loved was killed for exercising them.
As a (semi-retired) public policy attorney, who wrote laws for legislative government for about 7 years, I see there are a number of misconceptions about the new eviction moratorium.
First, it’s not an extension. It’s an entirely new ban, which the CDC had to craft to account for a change in the pandemic from when Trump’s CDC first issued an order.
This is important bc the new ban had to use language that could avoid it potentially being invalidated by the Supreme Court (which Kavanaugh’s concurring opinion threatened with respect to the Trump ban)
Folks on here spent days belittling Cori Bush’s protest as a sleepover photo op. But she may have singlehandedly facilitated a ban on evictions for 2 more months.
Being a keyboard warrior is cute, but some officials are actually fighting to get things done.
2. In June, along with Rep. Ayanna Pressley, organizing her colleagues to extend the moratorium after the district court decision to end the moratorium