Thread with excerpts from “The Archaeology of South Asia: From the Indus to Asoka” by Robin Coningham and Ruth Young
Cultures of prehistoric Indian subcontinent by time & place 6000 BC to 0 AD
Sources of Ganges, Brahmaputra, & Indus Rivers are in Himalayas & Tibetan Plateau.
India gets two monsoons - the southwest monsoon from June through September, & the northeast monsoon from October through December. 8000-6000 BC there was a change in monsoons that led to warmer & wetter India, sparking development of animal domestication & sedentary lifestyles.
Nilgiri Highlands in Tamil Nadu were wetter and warmer in last Ice Age. Region has gotten dryer since 8000 BC.
Indo-Gangetic Plain was a savannah with scattered forests. Farming developed in the Plain between 7000-6500 BC. Also possible abortive neolithic around 11,000 BC in Horton Plains of Central Sri Lanka.
Authors description of what makes a society a Neolithic society: farming, use of domesticated animals, sedentary lifestyles, pottery, & relatively advanced stone tools with no metal.
Earliest finds of cotton in world were found in Mehrgarh archaeological site
Use of red ochre in earliest Mehrgarh burials is interesting example of cultural convergence. Proto-Indo-Europeans in Ukraine, Iron Age Berbers in Libya, Toharian people from Kroraina, & Mayans in Yucatán all used red ochre for burials, & clearly were not in contact.
Loebanr III & Kalako-deray sites in Swat Valley (~1700 BC) had jade beads & harvesters, artifacts characteristic of the Yangshao culture of Yellow River basin in China.
Neolithic civilization in Ganges River basin in eastern India, Nepal, Burma, & Bengal that derived from previous mesolithic hunter-gatherers. The civilization isn’t well dated, only good radiocarbon date from a site from the civilization is 2000 BC. They had stone axes & rice.
Domestic sheep near Kothari River in Rajasthan in 5th millennium BC. 3rd millennium BC Gujarat & Rajasthan had farming & herding - disputed if it was due to settlers from Indus River Valley Civilization or local hunter-gatherers who adopted that lifestyle from the west.
Karnataka by 2300-2200 BC had domesticated several local plants for farming. Then numerous sites there were abandoned in that period, many cattle stockades were burned in enormous fires, & new pastoral practices appeared in Karnataka with new settlements.
Possible Neolithic farming society in Sri Lanka collapsed or reverted to hunting & gathering after climate change ruined agriculture after 5500 BC. Agriculture was reintroduced & metalworking was introduced after settlers from the subcontinent arrived after 900 BC.
Gradual rather than sudden development of urban societies in Indian Subcontinent 6000 - 2000 BC. Some pottery shards show graffiti from proto-writing which was very different from the Indus Valley Civilization script.
Baluchistan 4300-3500 BC had growing settlements made of mud bricks, & featured granaries & stores. Lapis lazuli, steatite, turquoise, carnelian, & seashells were all worked with pottery in specialized workshops. Glass was made at same time as Egypt & Mesopotamia.
Baluchistan 3500-3000 shows signs of earliest irrigation channels in subcontinent, though debated. 3000-2600 population seems to have grown & social complexity increased. Monumental platforms (pyramids?) were built, & trade as far as Afghanistan & western India was conducted.
Late 4th millennium BC Kandahar was linked by trade to Elam. Proto-Elamite writing on tablets has been found in Kandahar.
3200-2600 BC Kot Dijian tradition emerged as unified pottery type across Indus River Valley & into Haryana & Rajasthan. They built walls around their settlements that were 6 m thick & 5 m tall. They had carts, bull figurines, & large brick platforms. Bricks were uniform in size.
2800-2600 BC several Indus River Valley Civilization settlements were burned, & almost all were abandoned. Invaders from Baluchistan mixed with their predecessors & kept much of their material culture. After invasion, almost all settlements were built in virgin lands, not ruins.
Harappa had about 30,000 residents. Mohenjo-Daro had 30,000-40,000.
Indus River Valley Civilization’s “Era of Integration” 2600-1900 BC featured rise of large urban areas & cultural homogenization. IVC at the time was 20x size of Egypt & 10x size of Mesopotamia. Over 1000 known settlements from Era of Integration are known.
Indus Valley Civilization built even their small settlements with drains.
Nomadic pastoral groups roamed the marginal parts of the IVC, but were economically integrated, probably bringing raw materials to the permanent settlements, then leaving with manufactured goods.
Baluchistan coast under under influence of Indus Valley Civilization, but rest of Baluchistan remained culturally distinctive as the Kulli Culture 2500-2000 BC.
Sumerians called Bahrain “Dilmun”. It was a center of trade in 3rd millennium BC for Mesopotamia, Iran, Oman, & the Indus Valley. 150k tumuli tombs were built there. Sumerians viewed it as very wealthy.
Little evidence for sea trade in 4th millennium BC in Arabian Sea & Persian Gulf. 3rd millennium did have sea trade though. Indus Valley Civilization artifacts & writing found in Oman, Bahrain, Khuzestan & UAE. IVC weights for trade measurements indicate extensive contacts.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Thread with excerpts from "Government by Judiciary: The Transformation of the Fourteenth Amendment" by Raoul Berger
Description is not prescription, but in constitutional law it is close enough that this book damaged the reputation of the author. Arguments by author drove Justices Marshall & Brennan to assert that words & intentions of founders were less relevant than constitutional spirit.
The Fourteenth Amendment was passed during the 39th Congress. The discussions surrounding it were fully stenographed, and leave no ambiguity as to the meaning of the amendment by its writers.
Greenland was not colonized by the Amerindians or their predecessors. It was only discovered in the mid-to-late 3rd millennium BC nemets.substack.com/p/greenland
The Belkachi people migrated across the Bering Strait in the early 3rd millennium BC. They expanded across Alaska and the American Arctic. Their descendants reached Greenland towards the end of the millennium, forming the Independence I and Saqqaq cultures.
The climate shift which led to the Bronze Age Collapse in Eurasia also afflicted the Arctic, reducing the Saqqaq to a refuge in southwestern Greenland by beginning of the first millennium BC. They were overrun by their Dorset relatives from continent in mid-1st millennium BC.
Nicole Parker from FBI's Miami office chalks many of the bureau's problems to its post-9/11 shift under Mueller away from crime fighting & towards intelligence collection. New class of program managers (TDYs) in DC gained power gained authority over regional office bosses (SACs)
the kinds of women who joined the FBI in 2010, immediately before enactment of Obama's 2011-2 DEI policies: Coast Guardette, two financiers, Air Force lawyer, accountant, hotel directoress, two engineers. Two were single mothers.
Authoress claims a minority of FBI agents do most work, a phenomenon reinforced by lack of performance pay. 60 statistics were kept for agents, & their nature drove agents to focus on simple crimes & those which afflicted celebrities. Complex financial cases were neglected.
Brzezinski in 1997 on how the most dangerous future scenario for the United States would be one where Iran, Russia, & China coalesce into a counter-hegemonic bloc led by China.
Decline of European vitality, de facto status of European states as USian protectorates, lukewarm sentiment for a united Europe, & declining state legislation were all noticeable in 1997.
The reluctance of Russians to embrace ethnic nationalism & how the development of such a nationalism would undermine the imperial pretensions of the Russian state.
apparently it was more dangerous to be a polemicist in 1870s Kansas than in the South
persecution of innocent poasters by hack judges & sinister feds is sadly an old American tradition
a hundred years before the founding of the Cannonball Run, Americans had the New Orleans to Saint Louis steamboat race. The race took a similar amount of time.
Thread with excerpts from "The Other Quiet Revolution: National Identities in English Canada, 1945-71" by Jose Igartua
Author argues national identity among English-speaking Canadians died entirely in mid-20th century, and was replaced by a broader civic identity. Nonetheless there is still an English-Canadian nation that can be seen sociologically through shared culture.
90% of Canadians read at least one newspaper in 1969, compared to only 68% watching television news. Spread of opinion polling ended up restricting range of public discussion.