First of all, reservation is about representation, not economic upliftment. It exists all around the world where minorities have been historically oppressed. In India, lower castes who are 77% only have 11% & 1% seats reserved in education & jobs
This is because for 3,000 years Dalits were forbidden from receiving education & forced to clean dead animals & gutters, tie pots to their neck & brooms to their back so they don't pollute the upper castes, not allowed to drink water in public, suffered from untouchability, etc.
Many of these things still happen. Dalits are still cleaning your gutters, climbing in manholes, jumping into your sewage, cleaning your garbage, burying your dead bodies, etc. Nowhere else in the world are humans forced to climb into your shit. 100% reservation for Dalits here
Dalits are forced to do caste occupations. Look at the caste of the people in fields without reservation. Bollywood, judiciary, media, academia, corporate business, etc are all UC dominated. These all have heavy nepotism because of caste privilege. Reservation counters nepotism
Each year there are over 40,000 crimes committed against Dalits. In 2019 alone 46,000 crimes against Dalits. Between 2006-2016, more than 5,00,000 crimes were committed against Dalits & Adivasis. Each day 10 Dalit women are raped. Every 15 minutes a crime happens against a Dalit.
Dalits are brutally killed for the most basic reasons. Google Dalit killed & auto-suggest will show Dalit killed for riding a horse, growing a mustache, watching garba, entering a temple, dating an UC girl ,eating in front of UCs, etc. Who commits these crimes? "General category"
You're not responsible for the crimes your upper-caste ancestors & kins do, but you continue to reap the benefits of the caste system in the form of your caste privilege, socio-economic status, social capital, family connections, financial backing, access to vast resources, etc
Speaking of reservation, only 22% are govt colleges, the rest are pvt colleges which don't have reservation. Therefore only 11% seats are reserved for 77% of lower caste students. Dalits still face brutal discrimination & harassment by UCs. Read about Rohith Vemula & Payal Tadvi
Coming to jobs, 90% jobs are in unorganised sector, which have no reservation. In the organised sector, only 3% jobs are in govt sector. Out of this, half are reserved. So only 1.5% jobs are reserved for lower castes, many of which aren't even filled. 77% population has 1.5% jobs
UCs are only crying about OBC reservation, not EWS reservation. OBCs are 52% of the population but only have 27% reservation. Moreover, "economically weaker" reservation is specifically for upper castes, as SC/ST/OBCs who are the real poor are barred from EWS reservation
Even in 10% EWS reservation for UCs, the income limit is 8 lakhs. 10% Indians living in extreme poverty earn 50,000 per annum. So the EWS reservation with an income limit of 8 lakhs is clearly only for rich UCs. What happened to merit? No protest against upper caste reservation?
Even if reservation was on economic basis, remember: Top 10% upper-caste households own 60% of the country's wealth. Brahmins earns 48% more than the national average, upper-castes earns 45% more national average. Dalits & Adivasis earn 21% & 34% less than the national average
The biggest oppression an upper caste faces is not getting seat in govt college. The biggest oppression a Dalit faces is being killed by upper castes for things like riding a horse or growing a moustache. Caste based discrimination is a systematic oppression against Dalits by UCs
Now please start acknowledging your privilege & stop harassing us. You have created enough problems for us as it is. Use your caste privilege to stop the caste atrocities that happen everyday instead of crying online about how you're being oppressed by Bahujans getting educated
Also, students from reserved categories aren't any less meritorious. They too have to write exams for 3/4 years & pass all of them. There is no lower cutoff in graduation. And reservation for never meant for 10 years. Ambedkar would slap you for spreading lies in his name
There was once a study conducted by Sukhdeo Thorat where people with upper castes, Muslim & Dalit surnames with the same educational qualifications applied for jobs. The UC surnames overwhelmingly got selected over Dalit and Muslim surnames. This is how caste privilege works
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
On this #AmbedkarJayanti here's a a list of his achievements and why Ambedkar was the greatest Indian to have ever been born: a thread
Ambedkar was not allowed to sit inside his classroom or drink the water at school by upper castes because he was a Dalit. Despite all this, he passed his school & became the first-ever Mahar to go to college at a time when no Dalits were even allowed to enter or study in schools
Ambedkar earned 9 degrees in his life. A B.A, two M.As, MSc, DSc, a PhD, LLD, D.Litt and Bar-at-Law. He studied at Columbia & LSE, the first Indian to study Economics abroad. He returned to India to become a professor but faced untouchability from UC professors
On September 24, 1932, the Poona Pact was signed between Gandhi, who represented the upper-caste Hindu leaders and Dr Ambedkar, who represented the Dalits, in Yerawada Jail. This pact put an end to separate electorates for Dalits which was the biggest mistake of Babasaheb's life
Separate electorates meant that seats were reserved for minorities, in which only those minorities would vote to elect their own representatives. In 1909, the separate electorates were first introduced for Muslims & extended to Sikhs, Christians, Anglo-Indians & Europeans in 1919
Thread explaining how Cristiano Ronaldo is a rapist, paid his victim $400k to silence her, admitted to rape on record & used his money & power to get away with rape:
All the info is from reputed German mag Der Spiegel. If you don't trust them, other leading media have shared it
Ronaldo raped Kathryn Mayorga in 2009 in a hotel. "She said no & stop several times. She said no don't do it. I'm not like others. I entered her from behind. It was rude. She said she didn't want to, but made herself available." This is what Ronaldo himself admitted on the record
"If she was raped why didn't she report in 2009. Why wait for 10 years to destroy Ronaldo's image?"
She reported it in 2009, the day after it happened. There is a call recording of her call to police where she reported she was raped & later went to the hospital & took a rape kit
Reservation were not an immediate fix, nor were they introduced in 1880s & implemented in 1900s for SC/ST. They were introduced nationally in 1932 after the Poona Pact. We wanted separate electorates, not reservation. But Gandhi threatened s word
The report was submitted in 1980. The reservation in colleges was introduced in 2006 & in jobs in 1992, both with creamy layer. While some small kingdoms like Kolhapur had some reservation before, this wasn't on a national level
"Reservation has existed for 100+ years"
India got freedom 74 years ago. OBC reservation came 15 years ago. Reservations don't have an exit mechanism because caste doesn't have an exit mechanism. Reservations are not helping because they are only 11% in education & 1% in jobs
Me: Reservation is not & never was a poverty alleviation scheme
UC: But what about rich Dalits?
Me: Again, reservation is not made to solve poverty. It is to ensure representation of lower castes
UC: But rich Dalits are stealing the seats of poor Dalits!
Me: Dalits & Adivasis are 25% of the Indian population, we get 22.5% reservation. Therefore no one's stealing anyone's seat. All of us are meant to get reservation & all of us will. If you're so worried give up your seat
UC: Oh look how much you hate merit. I have achieved everything through hard work
Me: What you have achieved is a direct result of your caste privilege & generational wealth. Hard work is also done by Dalits working as labourers, farmers, workers, etc who have built this country
Thread: All the covid resources in Pune can be found in the thread below, including vaccination centres, beds, ambulance, emergency helpline, free meals, remdesivir, testing centres, etc. All info is verified but a while, please double check again to be sure