WhiskeyJack Profile picture
Aug 25, 2021 23 tweets 13 min read Read on X
A brilliant thematic conclusion

Thread on Attack on Titan’s additional pages

#aotmangaspoilers
Written about certain aspects of this already, but this will be a more comprehensive thread all in one place, looking at the pages in their entirety and how they tie to the themes. +
The additional pages start with the confirmation that mikasa’s choice allowed ymir to ‘see’ that serving the king was born from her twisted concept of love/connection, and that she wished she had realised her love was for her family (children) earlier. +
Her eyes being open symbolises this clarity in outlook and change in perspective, much like eren originally opened her eyes to the fact that she was nothing other than a normal person. +
Her search for connection had culminated in mikasa, which had been hinted at multiple times. Her tragic life had led to the birth of the one who could eventually free her, a girl who managed to overcome the trauma that shackled ymir for 2000 years. +
This connects perfectly as AoT characters are in many ways a representation of their trauma/world. This is primarily showcased through the MC, the vehicle for the narrative. Eren’s hate for titans is what his entire character originally revolves around. +
The same thing is shown again from the opposite perspective through his mirror gabi and her hatred. Grisha x Kruger’s hatred also stems from their childhood trauma and it’s what fuels their patriotism and actions throughout life. +
Reiner (‘the other mc’) desired to be a hero and an honorary marleyan, a byproduct of his need for affirmation stemming from his childhood. Him ‘saving’ humanity is tied symbolically to uprooting a tree, tying into CotF which i’ll explain next. +
‘Children of the Forest’ is one of the central themes. Mr Braus is a mouthpiece for Isayama, and presents the idea that we must do our best to not affect the next generation in our cycles of hatred, or it will never end. To not create more Erens, Ymirs, Reiners etc +
The most prominent example of this is AoT’s ultimate antagonist, Zeke Yeager. A child who grew up to believe life itself was worthless: his anti-natalism and worldview a product of his own trauma. His ties to the ‘forest’ are explicit. +
Levi brings him to a forest which he claims is a suitable home, Zeke ironically wants to bring other children into the same forest, he attempts to escape to solve the cycle of hatred but is unable to do so, and finally his beast titan is literally a monkey. +
His conclusion of seeing a beautiful day is him symbolically leaving the forest as he can now see the clear sky for what it has always been. The world didn’t change, instead his warped perspective on it did. +
This is why Mikasa, who grew past her trauma, saving ymir, who couldn’t, and ending the titan cycle is such an incredible and powerful message to conclude this theme. Just save one child, and the world will become a better place for it. +
Ymir choosing Mikasa is further strengthened in the next page. Y was shacked to the memory of the king’s wishes for 2000 years, however M remembers eren out of her own volition in direct opposition to his wishes. +
The exact details of her life aren’t explained because it’s just not important, the story isn’t about that & turning it into a shipping war is borderline embarrassing. It’s a representation of one of the ‘long lives’ eren wished his friends might have. +
The final pages are steeped in the realism and ambiguity that first made me fall in love with the story, but an undeniable spark of optimism beyond that. Decades after M’s death, a modern Paradis is embroiled in war. +
The reasons are unexplained because they are again unimportant, this is just a commentary on human nature. Erwin’s words ring true as the cycle of conflict continues onto further generations. OfC Eren’s actions didn’t solve world peace forever & that wasn’t even his goal. +
Saying eren may aswell have done nothing is also just as ridiculous. Were Alexander the Great’s achievements meaningless because his empire collapsed upon his death? Is all of humanity meaningless because the sun will one day explode? It’s redundant +
It’s a complaint steeped in emotional attachment to an unrealistic outcome, it’s just not who humans are and it’s not how life works. The cycle can’t be solved in general, but definitely not by a child formed in the image of that very cycle. +
We see hundreds of years pass as eren becomes ‘fuel’ for another forest, very valid to assume isayama intended it to be 2000 years given the symbolism and his love for those details. The source of all living matter remains. +
A child heads into the forest (reference overt) of their own accord, pushing their own back into ‘hell’, in order to solve a problem that the generations before couldn’t solve. Conflict is inherent to human nature, but the desire to solve that will never go away. +
The source is a metaphor for ‘power’ in whichever shape that comes. For ymir it was the representation of her need for strength (undying body) and connection (link to all eldians) but for the child it will be a representation of their desires. +
The cycle of humanity goes on. Ymir was too submissive due to her trauma, while eren was the opposite due to his and neither capitulation nor genocide was a solution. This child of the forest will attempt their own way and it’s beautiful.

The end 🤍

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with WhiskeyJack

WhiskeyJack Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @cactuzz4nf

Nov 6, 2023
‘I still don’t know what mikasa did’

thread exploring mikasa, eren, and what ‘love’ can mean in attack on titan Image
firstly, the functional reasons why he doesn’t know. erens eyes are closed in the mouth of his titan, he opens them when mikasa enters and he only sees her (eye reflection) once his head was severed. just like when he didn’t know how he entered paths after gabi shot him
Image
Image
this lack of knowledge is important because it ties into how his memories work. when he talks to zeke in marley he states that he didn't just see memories, he ‘felt' them. essentially eren fully EXPERIENCES the memories he holds as if he himself lived them Image
Read 20 tweets
Apr 12, 2022
AOT SPOILERS

actual ‘reaches’ (not foreshadowing btw wrong word):

-pg 13 only numbered page in aot (links to long dream, 9 pages long)
-ymir + zeke from page they got powers to page of death = 13 pages
-eren wakes up pg 45 in yr 845, dies ch138 pg 45
- 139 = end of a cycle ImageImageImageImage
sigh i meant wakes up in page 13 of year 845, while dying in page 45 of chapter 138
why can’t u edit tweets bro
Read 4 tweets
Apr 3, 2022
‘everything… is still ahead’

complete breakdown of eren’s psyche, mikasa’s role, and the battle between free will and determinism in attack on titan ep87: ‘the dawn of humanity’ Image
this episode is the first real look into eren’s psyche since the timeskip and it’s centred on two main concepts: his determination and his self loathing. his venture into the outside world changes his perspective but it doesn’t stop him from following through. + ImageImage
for this it’s important to note that his coldness in his conversations with floch and historia is BEFORE he crosses the ocean. he can still view them all as enemies who he is fighting but he’s forced to accept the reality that they’re ‘all the same’ once he sees them for himself+ ImageImage
Read 24 tweets
Feb 20, 2022
an exploration of human selfishness

thread looking at annie, floch, armin, mikasa and the rise of the yeagerists

attack on titan episode 82: ‘sunset’
the episode opens with the ruins of stohess. this is a call back to s1 where erwins plan led to the capture of annie with lots of civilian casualties at the same place. erwin was later revealed to be led by his ‘selfish’ dream, and this selfishness is what allowed him to +
sacrifice others. his burden and guilt gives rise to questions concerning eren’s own mind. he said he was doing the rumbling to protect paradis but his actions have led to the titanisation of paradisians along with civilian casualties. it’s aligned with another important +
Read 23 tweets
Feb 19, 2022
yoriichi & kokushibo: the sun & the moon

demon slayer thread
the second noble truth in buddhism teaches us that because we believe we are a permanent and unchanging self we fall into clinging and craving, jealousy and hate, and all other poisons that cause unhappiness. this is kokushibo and his search for the ‘self’. +
yoriichi and kokushibo present two opposing halves, much like other siblings have throughout demon slayer. one was given the rights to the house, education, clothes etc while the other was ‘blessed’ with talent. kokushibo’s journey stems from egotism. +
Read 13 tweets
Feb 19, 2022
akaza’s backstory and conclusion made him a lot better than i thought he’d be

thoughts below #shashds
it was mostly emphasis on the fact the desire to be strong is borne from insecurity (weakness) or past failures. it was the same for uzui, tanjiro and the other demons. demons are humans who gave into the desperation of their weaknesses and through that lost their humanity. +
the hatred akaza felt was just an extension of self loathing, the weakness he abhorred in himself. this is when muzan plays in. the process of becoming a demon is what removes the memories of the past, they become lost in their anguish and are reborn into suffering (samsara). +
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(