0/ We've seen a lot of activity around the private market "exchange" race w/ $NDAQ spinning out NPM (alongside $SIVB, $C, $GS, & $MS) @cartainc launching CartaX, the @Forge_Global / @sharespost merger, etc

Forge is going public providing the first glimpse at #s in the ecosystem
1/ They quote $10B in volume inception to date across 19,000 trades (avg trade size of $526K) with 639 institutions, 123K accredited investors & ~399K registered users.

As of June they did $3.0B LTM, with $1.8B in '20 & $1.7B in '19 with a net take rate of 3.1% LTM
2/ They provide some good data about the private market landscape:
-Median age of tech co at IPO 4 years in '99 to 12 in '20
-Median valuation up from $493M in '99 to $4.3B in '20
-There are 762 "unicorns" with $2.4T in "market cap"
-Private market AuM is now at $13T
3/ They highlight the discrepancy between private company share turnover vs. public equity turnover (0.2% vs. 126%)
4/ From a trading perspective @Forge_Global offers single "primary" & "secondary" transactions (matching buyers & sellers, w/ company ROFR process), non-tender offer programs, tender offers, etc...
5/ In June over the LTM ~51% of their volume was institutional vs. 49% individuals. This skews higher than $COIN retail volume % which was 31% last Q.

Their take rate of ~3.1% vs. $COIN blended of 0.42%
6/ Forge also offers a custody product w/ $14B in AuC including $600M of cash across 1.9M customer & "partner customer" accounts.

They generate $497 per account.
7/ The deal values the co at a $2.0B market cap / $1.6B EV on $72M in '20A revenue / $123M in '21E revenue.

Big delta in a business like this vs. $COIN and other crypto exchanges that likely come public in the next 6-12 months.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with John Street Capital

John Street Capital Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JohnStCapital

15 Sep
0/ $AFRM CFO Michael Linford on $V: "You can't look to V & say V is a loser here: (i) We ride V rail for a meaningful number of our transactions, and (ii) We receive repayment for 45-50% of our transactions on debit card anyway so they are recapturing that"
1/ "The networks are critical partners for us today. The virtual card product runs on $V, all that virtual card revenue is our cut of a V transaction."

The $AFRM network isn't exclusively reliant on theirs nor is it independent of theirs.
2/ On their view of underwriting. They are focused on their Variable Profit # (Rev-Transaction Cost); they can handle a lot more losses if there's more revenue & vice-versa. "$PTON users are generally higher credit quality but don't confuse credit with income as it's not as high
Read 11 tweets
10 Sep
0/ Yesterday was $AFRM's 3rd earnings call as a public co but @mlevchin treated it like Day 1 articulating the vision for AFRM to "unbundle the credit card," discussing TAM, product roadmap, the 10-year+ vision, & recent trends / consolidation

Worth a listen given BNPL debates.
1/ For FY21 $AFRM facilitated 16M+ transactions & $8B+ in GMV for 7M users with merchants +5x YoY

Initial FY22 guidance of $12.75B of GMV vs. high-end Street at ~$12B (doesn't include $AMZN, or Debit+, modelling $PTON (-30-35%) YoY vs. Street +, $SHOP is implied at ~$600M-$1.0B.
2/ He spent a lot of time talking about the @Returnly acquisition & looking at other ways to add value for their merchants.

He highlighted their merchant marketplace (~1/3 of FY21 tx's occurred here)
Read 12 tweets
8 Sep
0/ @Adyen's Head of Group Finance spoke w/ UBS about all things Adyen. Growth YTD has been driven predominantly from existing merchants (he called out marketplaces & vertical software companies specifically) while noting some take rate decline due to their tiered pricing model
1/ No surprise & we're seeing this in all the spending data but two areas where the pandemic affected their merchants negatively:
(i) Travel
(ii) In-Store Retail / In-Store Volumes in general
2/ He spoke a lot about their issuing initiatives & what he believes differentiates the Adyen platform:
(i) Issuing in a global nature- clients can issue in Europe, NA, etc... on the same tech stack vs. most competitors building one region at a time
Read 7 tweets
1 Sep
0/ August was another good month for risk assets across the board w/ $SPY +2.9% (7th straight month of + performance, 8 straight months has happened in 14 calendar years), $QQQ +4.0%, $34B in VC funding, $BTC +13% , $ETH +34.9%, $SOL +304.3% & NFT's (punks, rocks, degen apes) +∞
1/ Over the past 10 years September has been the worst month of the year for $SPY (1 of 3 avg negative months w/ avg / median performance of (0.92%) / (0.18%) w/ 50% negativity. Looking at skew the mkt pricing in some fear:

SPY 5% OTM Oct Call 9.7 vol
SPY 5% OTM Oct Put 18.0 vol
2/ Looking at $BTC Sept is the only negative month of the year (Bbg has an avg return of (6.62%) actual avg return closer to (6.1%)) / median of (6.5%) with just 40% positivity.

There hasn't been a positive Sept for $BTC since 2016.
Read 7 tweets
31 Aug
0/ The $TOST S1 is showing the way for other Vertical SaaS companies focused on embedded payments.

Looking at revenue & gross profit contribution payments is actually the lion share today, with subscription revenue of ~10%, while hardware & prof services are loss leaders re: GP
1/ Their net take rate for 1H21 is 55bps (up from 48bps in 1H20); this despite gross take rate down slightly.

This isn't unique to $TOST & we've seen a similar phenomenon with $SQ's #s showing take rates trend higher YoY & vs. '19 w/ more debit usage & online / CNP transactions
2/ Despite the pandemic if we look at their GPV on a quarterly basis its largely grown QoQ every Q except for 1Q & 2Q20.

We're also seeing GPV / ARR per location trend higher.
Read 11 tweets
31 Aug
0/ @patrick_oshag had former Notre Dame CIO Scott Malpass on the pod, Malpass took ND's endowment from a 3 person team (a priest, a receptionist & himself) & $425M in 1989 to ~$14.0B when he stepped aside last year w/ endowment spending going from $19.5M to $425.7M over that time
1/ He became CIO at 26 w/ 2 years of work experience & is one of the more underappreciated capital allocators of the last 3 decades.

Malpass was one of the first CIO's to embrace the Endowment Model having a greater equity allocation, diversification, & investing into alts.
2/ He thinks there are maybe ~40-50 institutions in the world that can implement this model successfully (which is why most endowments underperform) as it requires significant resources, access, continuity of the team, buy-in from the capital base, etc...
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!