Jamie Scott Profile picture
Sep 22, 2021 19 tweets 6 min read Read on X
📌 Manchester United's Foundations in Possession: West Ham vs Man Utd [THREAD]:

- Varane carrying centrally
- McTominay dropping in right half space
- Fred semi-dropping
- Midfield/Forward line rotations to receive
- United access between the lines consistently early on
United’s nominal formation is presented below:
1) Varane’s in build up:

When Varane had no vertical passing option, he often shuttled diagonally towards the centre of the pitch. This gave time for United’s Mid/Forwards to rotate and create an option, plus Varane’s carries prevented him from stagnating United’s possession.
Such a sequence is shown below, where Varane ultimately did not get a vertical option, thus could switch to the underloaded left, or play via Fred.
Again, we can see Varane move into the centre of the pitch on the ball, rather than merely carry in the half space. Varane could ultimately access Ronaldo between the lines with a vertical pass. Central progression is an ideal outcome from build-up.
A centreback carrying towards the centre of the pitch isn’t conventional, but as mentioned, it did give time for passing lanes to be opened by recipients, while Varane could still make (relatively) progressive carries into the 2nd phase.
Varane’s tendency to drift centrally was conducive of McTominay dropping into the back line to make a three. This is an example of an on the ball movement dictating the action of a teammate.
McTominay could access the front line, from the right half space, with vertical passes. The front line rotated well to receive in such scenarios.
Fred would also drop in a similar fashion to McTominay, but when Varane and Maguire remained split. With West Ham’s front two fairly man-oriented to United’s two CBs, Fred could semi-drop to receive, turn and progress.
United often progressed centrally, before playing out to either fullback. This is where limitations of United’s system occur – particularly in the lack of structure of the front four: Ronaldo, Greenwood, Pogba and Bruno.
We can see in this still frame, how United have great potential in this circumstance, with four options between the lines. Due to lack of rigid organisation, United often failed to open lanes into these players from this position.
On the left, it was a similar scenario, but Pogba offered an intermediate option for Shaw to play through to reach central zones. But ultimately, United struggled to consistently turn 2nd phase potential into final third penetration.
So what is the point of this thread, in the context of United's tactical and positional setup: with positives and limitations?
1) United have has good positional structure in build-up, for a substantial period of time under Ole.

United use the 3-1 to beat the first line of pressure, and are becoming better at dictating games from build-up. Varane's addition could help this, despite his limitations.
2) We all know United don't have the most rigid, disciplined framework in the attacking third. They're fluid and allow individuals to roam and create - mainly Bruno, but now also Pogba off the left.

This is fine, if the fluidity is balanced and functional.
The key point of this thread:

3) We are starting to see more evidence of United showing coached, methodical rotations from the midfield and forward line, to create options for vertical passes. United consistently showed this within phases of dominance vs West Ham.
3b) If United progress in this manner, and consistently show evidence of coached rotations, functional movements to receive and dictate the action of the passer in the 2nd phase, then the limitations of a fluid final third setup can be minimised...
In other words - we will have the framework in place to access the front line consistently enough, that they will produce in most games, despite a lack of rigid setup once they do receive.

More work is to be done to ensure their autonomy and freedom isn't detrimental.
It is a process, and hopefully, we will see more evidence of progress to mask our limitations.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jamie Scott

Jamie Scott Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JamiescottUV

Aug 15, 2023
📌⚽ Are Inverted Fullbacks Ineffective?

Analysing the Role of Inverted Fullbacks in the EPL this Weekend: [Thread]
Manchester United:
- Shaw - ineffective when inverted: 4/10
- Wan Bissaka - offered verticality from underlaps and created chances (plus the goal): 8/10 Image
Spurs:
- Udogie - inversion left Son isolated at times: 5/10
- Emerson Royal - scored, and gave rise to Skipp and Kulusevski's balance on the right wing: 6/10 Image
Read 6 tweets
Aug 2, 2023
Erik Ten Hag is revolutionising the way Manchester United play football. This isn’t without difficulty however – Ten Hag’s approach is risky and requires substantial change. This thread explores the topic of personnel and risk vs reward when considering ETH's principles. [Thread] Image
There are three key facets to consider in this discussion:
- The risky nature of Ten Hag’s principles
- The quality and implementation of coaching
- The players: in terms of individual profiles and team make-up
Further, some parameters to consider when evaluating the relative success/failure of Ten Hag’s approach:
- Time it takes to implement principles
- Limiting factors (player quality & profiles, execution of principles, luck)
- What is to be considered a success
Read 24 tweets
May 8, 2023
📌 How Erik ten Hag's Manchester United struggled against West Ham's mid-block - and what this means for the players and Ten Hag's principles of play [thread]. Image
Manchester United and West Ham lined up as such: ImageImage
West Ham sat in a 442 mid-block and looked to attack United in transitions - building attacks through hold up play and direct dribbling, before subsequent set-pieces.

United were matched player for player in build-up and progression, and struggled for inspiration. Image
Read 13 tweets
May 16, 2022
📌 Using Data to Identify Areas Where Erik ten Hag Can Improve Manchester United [thread]: Image
Before looking at areas at United that Erik ten Hag can improve at United, it could be worth reviewing the principles of play Ten Hag has implemented as a coach at Ajax recently:
Figure 1. Opposition Pressures in the Attacking Third and Opposition Pressure Success Percentage.

In other words – how often is a team pressed high up the pitch (in their defensive third), and how well can they cope with it? Image
Read 33 tweets
May 3, 2022
“The worst thing in football is doubt”

This is 100% true. Players who doubt, don’t have confidence or clarity. They’re susceptible to possession loss, they slow down play, they’re less likely to execute actions well.

For me, there are three main aspects to achieving clarity: Image
1) understanding of system and principles

2) understanding of what you’re going to do

3) coaching/instructions from teammates

Ultimately, a system or coaching in that vein (#1) alleviates the prerogative of a player to make a decision in each given circumstance (#2).
To achieve absolute clarity and confidence in your actions, in any given state of the game (with time on the ball or under pressure, when you have multiple options or when you have no options), you need that overarching set of principles.
Read 5 tweets
Apr 6, 2022
📌 The Titanic Battle Between Pep Guardiola and Diego Simeone [mini-thread]:
Atleti began in a 532 block, with City implementing their usual build-up strategies. Advantage City; over 90 minutes they would most likely have broken this block down; the progression angles are favourable and they had ultimate control in build-up. Image
City were able to build in their regular manner. They had an advantage over the front two, and could access most of the players in the progression chain easily, accessing their wingers.
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(