First up! Viking ghost lawsuits. This is a famous story from Eyrbyggja Saga, whose ghostly events are SUPER complicated. The relevant part is pretty simple: a fishing ship goes down at sea & everyone is drowned.
Then the drowned men come home.
Surprisingly, everyone is ok with this at first! It's good luck for dead people to drink their own funeral booze.
The problem is that they KEEP coming back. Night after night. Wet & dead & crowded round the fire.
Then a second group of ghosts starts coming (there is a COMPLICATED backstory that you don't really need to know). The two groups of ghosts start fighting and throwing mud. Every. Single. Night.
So the poor living people consult a wise man, who suggests that they have a Christian rite performed, they burn some bedding that one ghost is really attached to (LONG story), and that they sue the ghosts.
They perform a "door doom" in which they formally summon the ghosts to trial, charge them with trespassing and causing problems. There is a trial, then they are found guilty and sentenced (presumably to leave).
The ghosts grumpily leave, all complaining about it, but they never return.
Second lawsuit story! This is from Shuyi ji 述異記
[Records of Strange Things], by Zu Chongzhi 祖沖之 (429–500).
Basically Hu Bizhi & his family move into a house, & after a while, mysterious ghost things begin to happen. Phantom footsteps, etc.
Eventually, a new spirit appeared and spoke to them, sent on behalf of Bizhi's old deceased friend, Tao Jingxuan, who now worked as a censor in the heavens.
The spirit explained everything: their ghost was Sire Shen, the house's previous owner, who got mad at the foul language.
Shen was even angrier that they'd sent petitions to heaven about him, so that now he had charges brought against him there.
So, Shen countersued them with a serious greivance. They were instructed to recite sutras and keep precepts, & Shen would leave them alone.
[CW for third lawsuit: sexism, slavery, questionable consent]
[Third lawsuit] This is from Zhi guai 志怪 [Accounts of Anomalies], by Zu Taizhi 祖台之 (fl. ca. 376–410)
Xiahou Hong could see ghosts and intercede with them, leading to a number of adventures. In one, he tried to figure out why General Xie Shang could not have kids.
ANYWAY, ghost lawsuits. More common than you might think!
I don't know anything specific about the cultural backgrounds of these or whether anyone has written about them.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Why are we not talking about Sir William Neville & Sir John Clanvowe, the two gay English knights buried together in a tomb with marriage motifs???
Who were friends with Chaucer and possibly the inspiration for his The Knight's Tale?
And also maybe SPIES? #MedievalTwitter
So the above image is the tombstone of Sir William Neville & Sir John Clanvowe, who died in Galata (outside Constantinople) in 1391 within days of each other. Their shields are "impaled"; that is, their coats of arms are merged. This really only happens with married couples.
The article about their tombstone tries SO hard not to say gay.
I want to highlight an example of the whitewashing & erasure of the work of scholars of color--particularly Black & Indigenous ones--in the work of white medievalists. I came across it yesterday, & it's such a clear demonstration of how their work gets credited to white people.
This isn't a critique of the article's claim or its contribution to the field of race studies in Old English.
This is about how white medievalists who start publishing on medieval race draw on the work of scholars of color while obscuring them.
So this article came out recently in PMLA, a journal that has notably blocked work on race by premodernists of colors (medium.com/the-sundial-ac…)
That matters, since this article will be highly visible and cited in a way that the work of scholars of color won't.
🧵: So several scholars of color are pointing out the problems with racists mad about the new LoTR series. I did the same. My tweet got tepid responses, while the scholars of color faced vicious racism immediately *often from the same people*
[CW: racism, misogyny, homophobia, transphobia]
Most the people disagreeing with me didn't make it an issue of my identity & didn't insult me. These are among the meanest ones.
Easily a third of the responses to the scholars of color were hateful.
Dr. Ramírez got six comments on his main tweet and two of those were immediately vicious insults.
🧵The AHA president's "scholarship on race is ahistorical and presentist" blog isn't an outlier view or a brave take in the face of "the woke mob" or the "radical Left". It's been the party line among many senior scholars for decades.
Take medieval studies. (Really. Take it).
Look at basically any "state of the field" forum in medieval studies from the last few decades, especially in Old English studies. A lot of the big names--Allen Frantzen springs to mind--made careers out of slamming new approaches as presentist and ahistorical.
Here's Frantzen in 1990, complaining about "revisionists" (who he calls "Professors of Otherness") rewriting the teaching of history.