10/01/1981: 40 years ago TODAY: Massive car bomb explodes in front of PLO offices in Beirut. 83 are killed. The street is mangled with body parts. Other bombs are defused. A mysterious group called the Front for the Liberation of Lebanon from Foreigners claims responsibility 1/
This is just the latest in series of extraordinarily deadly car bombings that started 2 weeks earlier. Hundreds of Palestinian & Lebanese civilians are killed. At the time, it is the deadliest car bombing campaign in history. All are claimed by that mysterious group, the FLLF 2/
At the time, Palestinians & many Lebanese people insist that Israel is behind FLLF, that it is a fictitious group created by Israel to hide its role in this #terrorist campaign. Media often report these accusations. Israel insists this is a form fo "Arab on Arab" violence 3/
In 2018, @ronenbergman publishes "Rise & Kill First." There, he reveals that Palestinians were right all along: senior Israeli officials did indeed create the FLLF to "sow chaos" in Lebanon. And Def Min Ariel Sharon personally conducted the Sept-Oct 1981 car bombing campaign! 4/
Remarkably, since 2018 not a single US media outlet has reported on Bergman's revelations. Not a single US media outlet has considered revelations that very senior Israeli officials conducted a terrorist car bombing campaign that killed hundreds of civilians to be newsworthy 5/
At the time of the FLLF car bombing campaign, Israeli officials repeatedly insisted that they were at war with the "evil Palestinian terrorists." Begin, Sharon & others would justify the invasion of Lebanon in 1982 as justified self defense vs the "evil Palestinian terrorists" 6/
In 1981, 2 Israeli journalists investigated & found out that senior IDF officers were behind the FLLF bombings. The Israeli military censor killed their story. And the bombs continued to kill. This, too, has been deemed NOT newsworthy by the US media:
And so, the 40th Anniversary of Ariel Sharon's / the FLLF's #terrorist car bombing campaign is not marked in the US. It is not commemorated. Rather, it has been systematically erased. "We" are never terrorists. Only "they" can be
A few months after he personally conducted this terrorist campaign, Ariel Sharon wrote a whole Opinion piece for the @nytimes devoted to contrasting the inhuman, savage Palestinian terrorists & Israel's "moral conduct" in Lebanon. Just incredible...:
Between the Sept-Oct 1981 terrorist campaign and the invasion of Lebanon, Sharon also planned to use the FLLF to bomb Beirut's stadium. This plan was canceled at the last minute. But the FLLF would continue to bomb, kill & maim for many more months:
As several media outlets noted at the time, in 1980 the FLLF claimed responsibility for assassination attempt v Gunther Dean, US Ambassador to Lebanon. Dean believed that Israel was behind this attempt on his life. We now know that Israel created the FLLF:
In the 1980s, @tomfriedman covered several FLLF car bombings. And yet since 2018 he has remained SILENT about Bergman (his colleague at the Times!) 's revelations that Israel was behind these terrorist bombings:
This matters so much because calling someone a terrorist means that we grant ourselves the right to kill him, bomb him, surveil him, torture him. But of course we would NEVER accept this logic if it were applied to us, to "our terrorists":
One last point: Bergman's book was reviewed everywhere. It is an international bestseller. He works for Yediot & the Times. Yet media has remained silent about his revelations, which come from Israeli officials who were involved in or knew about the FLLF operation at the time
When I write about this, I am often accused of antisemitism. When I point out that these revelations come directly from Bergman, I am told that it doesn't matter because I chose to publish my articles in @Mondoweiss , which is supposedly an anti-semitic publication
But of course, only @mondoweiss ( and @OrientXXI in France) was willing to publish my articles about this Israeli campaign of terrorism. And that's precisely the point! This topic is one that other media outlets simply will. Not. Touch. See:
Note: Riedel, former CIA, has this interesting piece today about how the assassination of Sadat, making Mubarak president, convinced Sharon that Egypt would not react if Israel invaded Lebanon... brookings.edu/blog/order-fro…
In that article, word "terrorist" is used to talk about those ("Islamist terrorists") who assassinated Sadat. Of course Riedel is fully SILENT about Sharon's role, exactly at the same time, in the FLLF car bombing campaign that killed hundreds of civilians in Lebanon. Typical...
Again: The discourse on terrorism has NOTHING to do with terrorism. Nothing to do with the kind of methods specific actors use. The rule is simple: "we" are NEVER terrorists: even when we use car bombs that kill hundreds of civilians. Only "they" can be terrorists.
On Wednesday Bergman will be interviewed by @KimZetter about Rise & Kill First. Kim asked for questions people would like her to ask Bergman. I suggested she asks about the FLLF. If she does, she will be FIRST to do so since book was published in 2018:
A few days ago @benjaminwittes for @lawfareblog
interviewed Bergman & unsurprisingly "forgot" (like every journalist since 2018) to ask Bergman about revelations on FLLF & focusing instead on assassinations of nuclear scientists & other such actions: lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcas…
This interview took place on the 40th Anniversary of the car bombing terrorist campaign conducted by Sharon!!! And yet, NOT A WORD about these revelations in the podcast, a podcast where Wittes claims to ask prodding questions about international law....
Discussion of Rise & Kill First starts at minute 27. Wittes sounds like he is asking "tough questions," pointing out that assassinations of nuclear scientists might be international crimes. But why the silence about the FLLF, a clearcut case of terrorism? play.acast.com/s/lawfare/rone…
More news coverage of the FLLF / Ariel Sharon's car bombing terrorist campaign: UPI and the New York Times (on its Front Page!!!) on October 2, 1981, 40 years ago today:
40 years ago today. Sept 29, 1981. The Washington Post: "Another Car Bomb Explosion in Lebanon Kills 15." It is the latest explosion in a deadly terrorist campaign that started 2 weeks earlier. A mysterious group, the FLLF, has being claiming responsibility for these attacks 1/
In 1980, the FLLF claimed responsibility for an assassination attempt vs the US Ambassador in Lebanon. Palestinians and others in Lebanon insist that the FLLF is merely a cover for Israeli agents acting covertly. Western intelligence sources aren't sure. 2/
In 2018, Ronen Bergman (journo for @nytimes & @YediotAhronot ) confirmed that the Palestinians had been right all along: senior IDF officers did indeed create & run the FLLF. Since 2018 US media has remained completely SILENT about these revelations:
@bungarsargon@JoinPersuasion@Yascha_Mounk@TomRachman This is probably true: "critical race theory is the perfect ideology for affluent progressive whites who want nothing to change—but who still want to feel like the heroes of a story about social justice." But COUNTLESS progressives are not affluent/white & DO want real change
@bungarsargon@JoinPersuasion@Yascha_Mounk@TomRachman Also: you caricature the 1776 Project: its authors say "we should consider whether..." & the entire note u link to is devoted to how this idea was phrased & rephrased, is about nuance. In your version leftists speak in absolutes: "it must be that," "cannot be," "it is proof that"
@bungarsargon@JoinPersuasion@Yascha_Mounk@TomRachman & there is this (insulting?) caricature of the social justice mvt. Do u truly believe that everyone in this broad, diverse mvt follows just one theory? Thinks only in terms of power & only as it applies to race? That they all agree? Never talk, debate, fight over these issues?
It's been 49 days. 49 busy days. And yet somehow the Biden administration still has NOT reversed Trump's Executive Order that threatens sanctions, monetary penalties & imprisonment on persons who assist the ICC!
This is shameful. And so revealing.
One way to think of terrorism is that it is the peacetime equivalent of war crimes. Opposing the ICC (as Israel does, as the US has done: see the Hague Invasion Act!!!) is a clear indication that "we" are NOT opposed to terrorism at all: we want impunity for "our terrorists" 2/
The car bombing described below was conducted by the CIA, Great Britain, Saudi Arabia & Israel. It killed 80 civilians in March, 1985. There has of course never been any accountability for this crime. Nor any acknowledgement of our responsibility!!! 3/
March 8, 1985: Massive car bomb kills 80 people (mostly women & children) in Beirut. The target: Mohammed Fadlallah, a Shia cleric. A few weeks later, Bob Woodward writes that the CIA was behind the bombing. The war on terrorism is, & always has been, pure propaganda 1/
May 12, 1985: Woodward writes that the CIA played a role in the bombing. Note the headline: "Anti-Terrorist Unit Blamed in Beirut Bombing." What "we" do is NEVER "terrorism." It is always "anti-terrorism." The "terrorists" are always the "others" 2/ latimes.com/archives/la-xp…
In his 1987 biography of CIA Director Casey, Woodward would write that the DCI, on his death bed, confirmed to him that the CIA was indeed involved in this massive car bombing: chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-19… 3/
A review of US counterterrorism policies is under way. We must find a way out of deadly cycle of "terrorism" & "counter-terrorism." Only way we will do so is by ending silence about "our" (US, ISR, France etc) "terrorism" & by realizing that the DISCOURSE on "T" is pure ideology
Here is perfect illustration: in Feb 2018 Ronen Bergman published "Rise & Kill First," book on history of Israel's "targeted killings" in its fight v "the terrorists." It COULD have led to intelligent, constructive public discussion about morality or legality of use of force v T
After all, this book contained a STUNNING revelation: in early 1980s, very senior Israeli officials (Sharon, Dagan, Eitan, Ben-Gal) conducted a huge car bombing "terrorist" campaign that killed hundreds of civilians in Lebanon.
Dec 31, 1981: Tomorrow Beirut stadium will be bombed, PLO leadership decimated, Arafat dead. Along w/ countless civilians
This is the story of the kind of #terrorism we never hear about: where Palestinians are victims, not perpetrators. Israelis perpetrators, not victims
THREAD
On Jan 1, PLO would celebrate anniversary of its founding. Defense Minister Ariel Sharon saw opportunity to get rid of whole leadership in one fell swoop. In late Dec., agents recruited by Meir Dagan placed remotely controlled explosive devices in stadium. But that was not all
A secret Israeli unit had also prepared “three vehicles - a truck loaded with a ton and a half of explosives and two Mercedes sedans with 550 pounds each.” On Jan 1, members of the FLLF would drive & park the vehicles in front of the stadium.