yajnadevam Profile picture
Oct 9, 2021 137 tweets 63 min read Read on X
Now that we have proven Indus scripts in Indo-European, we will proceed to decode symbols one by one.

We already know the symbol for gha in Brahmi, looking up all 2 syllable words that start with jaga or jagha, we find only one: jagat. The symbol looks like a rice field, possibly derived from गात्रा = earth/field

Image
Now that we
1. proved Indus is IE
2. symbol's first syllable is its sound

We can look up words with known symbols and one unknown symbol at a time, choosing the sound that is closest to what the symbol looks like.
Looking at the intersection of words for jar/vessel/urn etc with first syllable the same as last syllable for 2 syllable words staring with ja, the urn symbol must be one of pa, su, va, ma and van. Image
The next seal eliminates everything except su and an, since the only valid words अन्ध and सुधा exist in the above set that satisfy this seal. Image
su is a prefix syllable. There are very few words that end in su: अप्सु, वसु, वासु, असु, while there are thousands of words that end in -an and Indus seals that end in jar symbol. Due to the huge volume of signs that end in the jar sign, jar sign must be the -an suffix syllable.
This word seals the deal. Atasu is not a Sanskrit word, but अतन is roaming. So the jar symbol is -an/-van Image
words starting with adh:

adhi/adhy, adhas, adhaH, adhri, adhvan

Words meaning grain/wheat/barley that start with i/y, as, aH, ri, van

ya/yava = barley, possibly yavana = wheat

the grain symbol is therefore y/ya Image
Two y is likely to be long i, commonly written as ee ई.

This means that the two small marks on top can only be vi वि as no other word except भानवी is possible for this seal. Image
The only way to read this seal is मदना तावन् / intoxicating very much. This means that the single vertical bar symbol is अ or आ esp if multiple अ is used Image
Other seal readings confirm vertical bar is अ Image
Of the words that mean wheel, अक्ष, पाद, अरिन्, वृत्र, नभि, चक्र, दृम्भू, दल्भ, कटक, सुनाभ, मण्डल, रथपद, क and र are possible candidates for wheel sign for 1st seal. The second seal can only be read as अनारत since क wont create a proper word.
The wheel sign therefore is रथपद/रथ ImageImage
On the first seal, of the words that fit va_<fish>_na, only the words for fish that start with ca, ma and sha fit(vamana, vachana, vashana.) On the second seal, only ma gives a proper reading of मखान्न sacrificial food. Therefore the fish sign is म/मत्स्य ImageImage
Correction: vamana is from this seal. Image
The only word that fits Dha_<ya on stick>_na is धारयाण supporting/bearing. This variant of ya is therefore rya/raya Image
4 lines = cha चतुर् There is no other word for four except by implication. Example seal shown. Image
Reads well into many seals such as acharya Image
Since vi वि meaning two is used for sound vi and chatur चतुर् is used for sound cha, is it possible that many numbers represent their first syllable? It looks that way.

eka/ek/e is one line. Image
tri = 3 bars Image
See how tri is 3 short bars split on 2 lines to avoid confusion with ja, which uses 3 bars on the same line. Image
6 short bars on two lines is sha from षट्. Used for श as well, as in the following seal: शमनी धुर Burden/yoke of calmness. Image
Sharyaa शर्या night Image
Seven short bars = sa from

सवन = time/order/fire or
सावन = conclusion of fire sacrifice Image
ash = eight small bars from अष्ट

Seal shows आश्रय = shelter Image
There are not a lot of seals with this symbol, so its possible its using the alternate word for eight, vasu and the word is vasurya (night). Night seems to be a very common theme in the seals, so I take this as a very credible alternative.
five short bars = pa from पञ्च pancha

Seal shows पार्य = successful Image
Only way to read this seal meaningfully is गतमाय = without deceit. This gives fish sign = म/मत्स्य. (Previous derivation assumed symbol va, so this is better) Image
tongs sign = ash. This is the only syllable that fits this sign.

राराष्ण विमान = brightly shining flying machine Image
The double bar letter || can be read as "va" or "in" in the first seal. राधावन्/wealthy or रदनिन् /tusked one(rhino/elephant). Due to the picture I will leave it ambiguous for now || = va or ni. I'm departing from Sue's symbol here because of so many seals work for both. Image
On first seal, ti, sa, Ni can fill this word starting with chama where the first syllable is from a word that means arrow or point. Reusing our previous proving of sha, only Ni is possible in both seals.
Arrow sign therefore is Ni from आणि ImageImage
First seal can be read with st, jam, nag, dh, ka, m, ndh, nta, thi for the '/ symbol. ra_st_ra, ra_jam_ra, etc. Of these, second seal can only be read with nta.
Value of '/ symbol therefore is nta. ImageImage
If the line after the first ra is taken to be "eka" then there is only one way to read the first seal: रेखान्तर (longitude) otherwise रन्तृ (delighting in). Since the general mood of the seals is the latter, I've used a second seal to prove "nta"
First seal can be read with ta dha ya sa na for broken bar | symbol. The second symbol with y after it can only be read as namani. The broken | symbol therefore is na. ImageImage
The || sign can only be va (vana or vaana in this seal) since the other alternative ni wont create a suitable word

Image
Results of taking the 2nd syllable from all the words starting with ka, and intersect with words meaning curved starting with the letter: मन्थर कुब्ज पार्श्व तिर्यञ्च् वक्र विनत. The curved symbol )) must be ku from the other 3 seals: kuvani, kubha ImageImageImageImage
There is only one way to read this: manahan, mind destroyer. Fish with caret ^ on top (lizard) therefore is he Image
There is only one double consonant after both Cha (छन्न) and Sha (शन्न). The only word starting with na for filter is नुद. So the filter sign is nu नु ImageImage
Its possible nu is used as a laudatory suffix or prefix, also meaning "certainly" "praise" or "now"
Rake sign is used in the first seal can be read as yu or ya, but in the second seal (and most seals) can only be read as ya.
Rake sign therefore seems to be a composite of y and a giving y + a = ya. ImageImage
The only words that fits double rake composite sign are ययिन् riding/traveling/moving, ययु swift or ययी horse, recurring themes in the seals, but only ययु fits second seal: एकम् अथ ययु अशि/आशि One but swift and enduring/eater.
Double rake therefore is yayu ImageImage
The composite sign formed by ka and a form the sound ak or aKh as seen in this seal: भावि मखना worshipping with oblation Image
I have strengthened the hypothesis by removing assumption on Indus symbol shape. We now start with just 2 Brahmi symbols ta 𑀢 and dha 𑀥. These are identical in both systems. Both symbols are shown here together with the jar symbol ImageImage
Looking up Monier Williams dictionary, there is a set of 351 words that match __dha and set of 2823 words that match __ta. There are only 53 prefixes that match both.
Of these, only one prefix अन्/an can be tripled to match this seal. The jar symbol therefore is "an". Due to its high frequency as a terminal sign, it is possibly also used as अं or अन् nominative declension. Image
The first seal has dha ध followed by double human symbol. Only fit are धक्क्/ धट्ट् /धा. The second symbol can only accept अ, reading अतन् We prove that the human symbol is indeed the source of the Brahmi
𑀅/𑀆/अ/आ symbol by rotation. ImageImage
Only sh श​ satisfies three seals with this symbol: शनि शण् शद ImageImageImage
Chain so far from purely 2 Brahmi letters ta da:

ta da an a y sh

Pure exhaustive search. No assumptions on religion, meaning of symbols, etc.
The "𑀭" symbol in the first seal followed by "Ayana" is satisfied only by g ta pa pal pyA vA sA hA. The second seal requires this syllable to be doubled around "a" and y suffixed to create a legitimate word. This is possible only for "a" to give आइ = see.
"𑀭" symbol = a/अ ImageImage
Another derivation of sh: __-__-y and also to __-an-y works only for sh: Sani and SaSi ImageImageImage
Only अनन/अश्न fit this two seals. The root/bud symbol therefore is न ImageImage
since ba / 𑀩 is identical to Brahmi, we can pick it up here.

Only double syllable words are dada hihi huhu jaja kiki mama nana ruru tata. Of these only ja, ma fit __anDa. Of these only ja, fits __ai.
The ||| symbol therefore is ja ज ImageImageImage
Seals /a__rya/, /__an/ and /__rya/ /ana__an/ can only be satisfied with ca. |||| = च/छ ImageImageImageImage
After cha we can pick it up from here:

32 Symbols from 3 Brahmi so far: त ध ब इ अन् अ1 श अ2 न1 ई वि र र्य च एक त्रि पा ष स अश् म अश् व णि न्त न​1 कु हे नु य ययु अक्

Only ka fits these 3 seals: ranaka kanta vakra
The X symbol therefore is ka क ImageImageImage
Proving ka enables a pure provenance of ku from Brahmi
Reproving gat गत् without relying on symbol shape. Seals
जगत् and गोतमि can only be read if this symbol is gat गत्

ImageImage
U/ऊ is the only symbol that can satisfy these two seals:
ऊषर्यै and ऊहमना ImageImage
The mountaintop symbol is सा (from सानु mountaintop)

The only sound that fits seals /मसान्द्रन्/ /रविहेसान्/ /सामन्/

Note: This is a departure from Sue Sullivan. There are simply no dictionaries that have Selva. ImageImageImage
Note: ndra is not yet proven but not needed for proof of above
Only arya, ava, sa, pra fits /सामन्/ Of these, only sa fits The only sound that fits seals /सान्/ Ironically Aryan (and pran and avan) are not legitimate words.
Creeper lata = la/ल. Only ल fits the seals /लान्तमणि/ Indra's jewel and /रलर/ Wailer ImageImage
Only th fits the drum symbol from the seals /कान्तमतन्/ and /क एक अनन्त्/ ImageImage
A clearer mathan seal Image
The crystal symbol is /am/ /अम्/ the only syllable that fits both /अशम्__/ and /शमन्/ ImageImage
saa required am ... placing it here to correct order

The sound /ma/ /म/ is the only syllable that satisfies the following seals: /माङ्ख/ /मर/ /मरण/ /मणि/

The head on shoulders/मस्तक symbol is therefore म​२ ImageImageImageImage
The only words with जाव/जव prefix are /जावड/, /जावत्/ and /जावन्य/. Of these only /tha/ /त/ fits the second seal.

The warrior with sword and shield therefore is /त/ ImageImage
My personal preference is to read 5 short bars as pa (from pancha), so alternative derivation with 4 seals:
/तरण/ /तव/ /जातकन्/ /रवीति/ ImageImageImageImage
When you write the letter त know that it represents the two legs and sword of a warrior. The name of the letter is तन्त्रिन् = soldier
/nda/ /ण्ड/ is the only sound that fits the following seals: /अण्डनि/ /तण्डवतन्/ /वण्डलविमशन्/

The three triangle symbol therefore is /nda/ ImageImageImage
40 Indus symbols proven so far using purely exhaustive dictionary search starting with 3 symbols 𑀢 𑀥 𑀩 that are identical in both Indus and Brahmi

त ध ब अन् अ१ श अ२ न ई वि ॥
र र्य च एक त्रि पा ष स अश् म१ ॥
अश् व णि न्त न​२ हे नु य अक् क ॥
कु गत् ऊ ल त् अम् सा म​२ त​१ ण्ड ॥
The only way to read these two seals is /रविशर्यथा/ and /एककुक्कुट/ . This means that the punch marked coin symbol is /tha/ /ट/ /थ/ ImageImage
The thread and spool symbol is /shi/ /शि/. Only syllable that fits these seals /आशी/ and /हे आशी/ ImageImage
/pa/ /प/ is the only syllable that fits these seals:
/अमापन/ and /उषप/ ImageImage
/अक्ष/ /aksha/ is the only syllable that fits these 4 seals:

The circle/oval symbol therefore is अक्ष ImageImageImageImage
/भ्र/ /Bra/ fits the following seals for the furnace symbol. ImageImageImage
/na2/ /ना/ symbol representing well/नरोग is the only fit for these seals: /तातन/ and /चिन्त/ ImageImage
/nu/ /नु/ । /णु/ is the filter sign from नुद. Only syllable that can fit these seals
/अनुनु/ /जिष्णुनु/ /अशमतनु/ /नुवा/ ImageImageImageImage
/वी/ /vI/ from the following seals: /अनवीन/ /वीर्य/ /शिवीय/

square with line on top = वी ImageImageImage
/प्रि/ /परि/ from the following seals: /परिधर्य/ /परिणि/ /प्रियकन्/ ImageImageImage
/धु/ from धुर् yoke as the exclusive syllable that fits the following seals /धुधु धुन्त/ /धुन्तमणि/ /आधि/ ImageImageImage
50 symbols so far .... crossed halfway point!

त ध ब अन् अ१ श अ२ न ई वि ॥
र र्य च एक त्रि पा ष स अश् म१ ॥
अश् व णि न्त न​२ हे नु य अक् क ॥
कु गत् ऊ ल त् अम् सा म​२ त​१ ण्ड ॥
थ शि प अक्ष भ्र ना२ नु वी प्रि धु ॥
/ना/ from exclusive match the following seals:

/अशनायन/ hunger and /नान्दन/ paradise/pleasure garden

Triangle with line symbol is ना, from नाकु mountain ImageImage
/kan/ = mouse symbol from खनक, rat for /ख//क/

Exclusive match for these seals:

/ई कण्टकन्/ Oh! Horned one!
/एक कुभा खनि/ mine on a river ImageImage
/द​/ /da/ from दल bud, sprout. Resolving seals:

/दण्डन [अव]भ्र प्रिय/ Punisher of [abductors] of dear ones
/दधपार्य/ Holder of the beyond ImageImage
/a/ /अ/ Brahmi /o/ 𑀑 seems to be used as /अ/, perhaps a distinct sound that has merged with in later Sanskrit

/कनकन्/ gold
/जयक/ victorious
/पार्यकना/ The girl beyond ImageImageImage
/vA/ /वा/ for jar with water from वाह् carry

/वाहकन्/ Carrier
/दलविवाह/ new (bud) wedding
/रवि वह्न ध​/ Sun, made of fire ImageImageImage
/nya/ /न्य/ /ण्य​/ from /न्यक्ष/ buffalo or /न्यङ्कु/ antelope is the only syllable that fits these seals:

/अन्धुन्य/ roaring
/धुन्तनन्यन् गम/ roarer without equal
/तन्यथा/ roaring/thundering ImageImageImage
/li/ /लि/ from these two signs

/दालिमवि/ lover of pomegranate
/लिवि विपन्न/ author of destruction (lord of destruction)

(Both are obvious references to Lord Shiva) ImageImage
/tha/ /थ/ from the following seals

/धुन्त नाथ/ Roaring lord
/तन्यत/ Roaring

Rudra means roarer ImageImage
/dA/ /दा/ Intersecting circles symbol is दा This requires 5 seals to prove correctly

/विदालतृषणुनु/ Whirpool/fountain that removes thirst
/दाव/ fire
/दानमथनि/ gift of kindling
/तदाजवन​/ necessarily swift ImageImageImageImage
5th seal for /dA/

/आदाजव/ carry swiftly Image
/शु/ from शुभ rain

/अश् शिशु/ Obtain child
/शुनि/ dog
/वीरंश/ warrior's radiance
or possibly /विरंश/ departed soul's radiance ImageImageImage
/tra/ /tR/ /त्र/ /तृ/
Bird cleaving two lines is तृ/त्र from तृद् cleave or त्रद cleaver

Resolving seals:
/रात्रि/ Night
/धुन्तन् वीत तृषा/ Roarer free from desires.

60 letters so far: Last 10
ना द अ३ वाह् न्य/ण्य लि थ दा शु त्र ॥ ImageImage
/y/ /इ/ from these two seals

/अधि/ above
/इध्/ ignite ImageImage
/भा/ for betel-leaf symbol from भक्षपत्र

/भन्द/ worship
/तन् भिदा/ Worship the destroyer
/रवि वाहन ध || भाम/ Having Sun's vehicle || Sun
/तन् भङग विष हेम वीर्यन्/ Worship destroyer of poison, golden warrior ImageImageImageImage
/इन्/ from the following seals

/भषिन् कनकन्/ Speaker of golden words
/अशिन्/ Enduring
/इन्ध अयि/ Lighting ImageImageImage
/य/ /ya/ from the following seals.

/काय/ body
/त्रय/ threefold
/अङ्ग्य/ of the limbs

This is a departure from Sue Sullivans "yama" reading. /य/ is the only natural fit and dictionary match. This seal never occurs with the rake "ya", which may be a simplification of this. ImageImageImage
/भ/ always has a peaked tip as opposed to /ङ्ग/ which as tufted tips. However if the last seal is to be read as /भय/ then we need one more seal /हेय/ to arrive at /य/ ImageImage
/न्द्र/ /ndra/ from the following 4 seals:

/रविज मन्द्रय​/ Praise the son of Ravi (Saturn)
/मशुन्द्रन्/ Moves on dog (ie Shiva)
/सान्द्र/ Abundant / Robust
/वी अश्वि इन्द्रन्/ Moving horse of Indra ImageImageImageImage
/त/ from तरु tree

/भरण प्रीत दान द्रा/ Delighted nourisher, swift giver
/तय/ protector ImageImage
/ह/ /ha/ from हल water

/कान्त महान्/ Greatly Pleasing
/अशन् वहन/ Cloud (or rock) vehicle
/अमहन्/ Disease destroyer ImageImageImage
/स्था/ /sthA/ from

/आस्थान/ hall of audience
/अक्षणा विस्थान/ inopportune misplacement
/स्थान/ station ImageImageImage
68 syllables proven with pure exhaustive search!

त ध ब अन् अ१ इ श अ२ न ई ॥
वि र र्य च एक त्रि पा ष स अश् ॥
म१ अश् व णि न्त न​२ हे नु य अक् ॥
क कु गत् ऊ ल त् अम् सा म​२ त​१ ॥
ण्ड थ१ शि प अक्ष भ्र ना२ नु वी प्रि ॥
धु ना द अ३ वाह् न्य लि थ२ दा शु ॥
त्र भा इन् य​२ न्द्र त​२ ह स्था
/रु/ /ru/ or /रू/ /rU/ from रुण्ड, headless body

Resolving seals:

/रवि मदेरु/ Sun, worthy of praise
/रवि नरुण/, Sun, the leader ImageImage
Total 70 syllables proven purely from dictionary search. The rest of the syllables may not have enough instances for this kind of resolution. About 25 to go.

Most recent 10 syllables: शु त्र भा इन् य​२ न्द्र त​२ ह स्था रु
/ध्/ /dh/ from the following seals

/विध लड नथ​/ Lord's manner of play

/माध्वी दण्ड अशन | रन्त​/ offering of sweet food | delighted ImageImage
/उष्/ /ush/ composite from u + ash

/वीतुष्/ pervade complete tranquility

/उष्ट शिर/ burnt head (ref to Shiva burning Brahma's 5th head) ImageImage
/का/ /kA/ wrist watch symbol (departure from Sue's ri)

/अ कार्य​/ This action
/अकालि चर्य​/ Unexpected movement
/काकण रणक/ Disease fighter ImageImageImage
/क/ /ka/ The paint roller variant of /का/ seems to be /ka/

/अश् रा कक्ष रङ्ग कर/ Fee to Obtain access to performance arena

/रविनाकन्/ Sun sky

/इनु कवि सा भरण/ Inu, the poet is giving and supporting

/दाक अश् अन्त हे वर/ Giver of eating till satisfaction (end desire) ImageImageImageImage
/उ/ /u/ Square wrist watch symbol

/अज इनु/ Unborn (or driver) Inu

/उभ दल/ Bud above ImageImage
/म/ /ma/ modified fish sign (Sue's vahi)

/रवि वम वीर्यन्/ Sun exuding warrior
/मनाय/ Meditating/with devotion
/रवि मर्या/ Sun, the limit ImageImageImage
Although dictionary match was /म/ /ma/, there is a some chance that this symbol represents /मा/ /mA/ fish sign with a /आ/ /A/ under it.

/रवि वामा वीर्यन्/ Sun beautiful (fem) warrior
/मानाय/ For respect
/रवि मार्य/ Worthy of being killed by Sun

yet to be solved (ordered by count): sur, kam, pra, rna, ko, tva, ga, rta, mi, dra, chi, rma, dhva, al, adhi, pu, kar, bhru, har, naa2, krau, ti, ag, daj, ve, za

Many are attested once or twice and are unprovable some are probably variants.

Composites need to be explained.
Possible: sur, kam, pra, tva, ga, chi
Merge: rna, ko, mi, dra, rma, al, krau, ti, ag, daj, ve
Difficult: dhva, adhi, pu, kar, bhru, har, naa2, za
Net about 85 symbols plus composites. Fairly easy to memorize and read/write ... about double the symbols of abugida.
/सं/ from संदाय reins

/सन/ ancient
/सनाथ/ protected ImageImage
/क/ /ka/ from just one seal:

/रसन शशाङ्क/ Screaming moon (Shashank possibly also means Shiva) Image
/ग​/ /ga/ from the following seals

/गजान्य नवि वामाटु/ Another beautiful golden elephant

/गधालिम/ Weapon (mace) that ends time (possibly Shiva)

/गान/ Song

/रागस्थ/ With melody ImageImageImageImage
/शू/ /shU/ or /शु/ /shu/ from शूर्प, winnowing basket

Resolving seals:

/अशुष्य/ Voraciously eatable (ie delicious food)
/शूष्य/ Resounding
/पशु शिविर्य/ Animals that are residence worthy
/र एक अश्म शुषकन्/ Singular fire that dries up mountains ImageImageImageImage
90 symbols proven!

त ध ब अन् अ१ इ श अ२ न ई
वि र र्य च एक त्रि पा ष स अश्
म१ अश् व णि न्त न​२ हे नु य अक्
क कु गत् ऊ ल त् अम् सा म​२ त​१
ण्ड थ१ शि प अक्ष भ्र ना२ नु वी प्रि
धु ना कण् द अ३ वाह् न्य।ण्य लि थ२ दा
शु त्र भा इन् य​२ न्द्र त​२ ह स्था रु
ध् उष् का क२ उ म​३ सं क३ ग शू
/प्र/ /pra/ from प्रजपति, butterfly

Resolving seals:
/प्रजय/ Victory

/प्रकरय एकार्य तत्र थ/ Respect is a noble & timely protector

/प्रपा आखन/ Dig the water feeder (for cattle)

/रविप्राण/ Sun (is) life ImageImageImageImage
/त्व/ /tva/ from त्वक्त्र​, armor

/मावत्वन्/ Worship like me Image
Was puzzled by several references to आखन / spade/digger ... seemed to be going off-theme. Turns out it also means hero.
So प्रपा आखन probably means "protector of cattle"

/न्य/ symbol also read as:
/न​/ /ना/ /ण/ /णा/ /na/ /nA/ /Na/ /NA/ from the following (Sue's RNa)

/सना दानन्/ Eternal giver

/नाकु विषन्/ Mountain poison

/वनन समन्/ Desires come to life (wish fulfillment prayer) ImageImageImage
/अ/ /a/ from the अज horn

From seals:
/अश्वी अमन् रय प/ Possessed with horses violently powerful after drinking from a stream

/आक्ष विष् नमन​/ worship the poison emanating from the eye (ref to Shiva)

/अनु प्रियक एक जगत्/ Follower/cherisher of one world

/अजर्य/ Forever young ImageImageImageImage
Reposting /र/ /ra/

/रण/ joy (also motion/war)
/आरवी/ howling/roaring
/अरज​/ Dustless (ie clean, perfect) ImageImageImage
A better /एक/ /eka/

/एका/ One (fem) Image
/म/ /ma/ from the following:

/मशन/ Sound
/मर्य/ Man
/चण्म/ Sound maker (rudra) ImageImageImage
/न/ /na/ from नव nine for nine strokes

/न तम/ Never dark Image
A compact derivation of yy = /ई/ /I/

/नी/ leader / guide Image
A simpler derivation of /अ/ /a/ /आ/ /A/ from the अज horn

/आचार्य/ Teacher
/अजर्य/ Forever young ImageImage
/य/ /ya/ from यव, barley or field of barley

/यत आयन/ controlled arrival
/यम इ/ Yama arrives (or possibly यमि, yama's twin sister)
/जय/ victory
/अजय/ Undefeated/Invincible ImageImageImageImage
/उ/ from उद्याम rope.

/उन्द शर विपर्य/ Moist reed (sugarcane) exchange. Reference to exchanging sugarcane during Sankranti festival. Still practiced in South India. Image
The single curved line is the same as the horn sign aja. This seal for example can only be read as आभास splendour Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with yajnadevam

yajnadevam Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @yajnadevam

Aug 21, 2024
Nation vs Civilizational states:

A state is a government of a bounded geography. A nation state is one where the citizens look, speak and act alike. Nation states promote the welfare of the nation. Competing interests guarantee that nation states end up in constant warfare
A nation state also finds it hard to expand its geography when its population grows. Its resources and influence, no matter how great are limited and will be found wanting in several areas. If the nation is small, then it will be easily pushed around, conquered and destroyed.
One way out of this has been the empire. A nation conquers their neighbors and expands its area, population, and access to resources. This invariably dilutes its national identity unless they can genocide the conquered nation and breed fast to replace them.
Read 10 tweets
Jan 26, 2024
The story of Indian haplogroup R*

Basal R M207 seems to have formed in the IranN population during the last glacial maximum(LGM). Most of Eurasia was covered under mile thick ice sheet. Rivers were frozen. There were only a few refugia in Eurasia India, SE Asia, S Europe, Japan Image
Image
R1a M420 begins at 16200 BCE during the Oldest Dryas cold period. South India and Georgian refugium sustained the R1a population. There are tiny and spotty samples in Europe. Image
By 8700 BCE, the ice age has receded for 3 millennia and R1a1a M512 has re-established over western India and western Iran. We see R1a1a percentages going above 1% in small spots in Europe, probably new migrant colonies. Image
Read 5 tweets
Feb 4, 2023
1. Societies evolve and devolve according to the pursharthas they focus on. Focus on kAma creates a decadent, warring and barbaric cultures where rewards are loot and women. Those focusing on artha become trading nations focused on hoarding wealth and showing off & corruption.
2. Those focusing on dharma become prosperous and righteous. Those focusing on moksha become ascetic and passive. Of these, only a dharma-focused civilization is durable against the onslaughts of the others.
3. kAma seeking societies are a natural result of impoverishment and inability to fulfill desires. The most barbarism is seen in the poorest countries. Its the successful saturation of desires that enable moving away from war and barbarism. Crime is the representational state.
Read 13 tweets
Feb 3, 2023
PT DU Inst of Archaelogy

Numerals can be trivially shown to be not numbers Image
Its basically language: Image
Image
Read 6 tweets
Feb 3, 2023
Any claim that Indus seals are accounting should explain why there is no '5 fish' in the entire corpus but plenty of other numbers. Also, whats the point in having 2 and 4 next to each other when you could just put the numeral for 6? Image
And what could this possibly represent! "1-2-1-12-wheel-wheel"! Are they buying wheels? How many? why write wheel twice? Just browsing the seals makes it clear that these "numerals" are not used in a numeric sense at all. Image
Is it a serious claim that this beautiful seal, which probably took days to carve, bake and polish just in case someone wants 7 fish? but none if they want 5 fish? Wouldnt it make sense to have separate '7' and 'fish' seals so you could press one and then the other in 600 yrs? Image
Read 4 tweets
Feb 3, 2023
My commentary thread on this video summarizing current thoughts on Indus script:👇
1. fish depicts star because meen = min = shine = star. This assumes IVC folks don't know how to draw this shape>⭐️ something that humans have done since they were cavemen and opted for 3 levels of indirection instead.

businessinsider.com/ancient-cave-d…
2. Indus seals represent some form of accounting, ie 3 loads of fish, 6 jars etc. Imagine creating detailed animal imagery for ONE entry in some account, baking and hardening it for hours! And oh, you want 5 fish? Sorry, there is no seal for 5 fish ever made! in 600 yrs!
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(