There are a lot of good threads out there explaining why #ColumbusDay is offensive - but I want to add the perspective of an Italian born and raised in Italy on y celebrating #ChristopherColumbus as connected to Italian heritage (?) makes NEGATIVE SENSE. So, let me explain... 1/?
Christopher Columbus was, indeed, born in the Republic of Genoa - one of the many political entities in which the Italian peninsula was divided before the unification (which won't happen till like... 200+ years after CC's birth. There was no country of Italy at his time!) 2/?
However, the journey that led him to TOTALLY BY CHANCE sail to the American continent was not financed by the Genoese, but by Spain. CC had the goal of finding a shortcut to the East by sailing through the Atlantic, he pitched the idea to dozens of poweful families 3/?
who refused because it was the stupidest idea ever, until Isabel of Castille - who was filthy rich - was like... why not? Let's throw some money at this silly little man and see how it goes. 4/?
He sailed sporting Spanish banners. He is buried in Seville. The only connection with Genoa was his birth. Which shouldn't come as a surprise, since the shift of trade from the Mediterranean to the Atlantic caused the slow decline of Italy as an economic power 5/?
While the countries with Atlantic harbours got rich off the exploitation of the American continent, Italy began a slow but steady decline. So it's particularly ironic that in the US CC is painted as an Italian hero, the dude kinda caused the economic collapse of the place 😂 6/?
Columbus Day is NOT an Italian festivity. We... don't have it here. Berlusconi tried to make it a thing for reasons unkown in 2006 (iirc) but it never really stuck, because we don't care much about CC...? Actually, there's this strange phenomenon taking place nowadays... 7/?
in which Italian alt-right goons would argue about the importance of CC because it has became an alt-right talking point in the US 😬 The absurdity of it: a 100% USian festivity fabricated an 'Italian hero' we didn't have which has now been embraced by Italian far right 8/?
But what about the Italian-American community? Would it make sense to celebrate Columbus Day for them? Well... do you know why the festivity was created in the first place? 9/?
In 1890, when Italian immigrants in the US still didn't have white status, more than a hundred Italian immigrants were arrested as retaliation for the murder of the police chief of New Orleans 10/?
When nine of them were aquitted, an angry mob of WASPs broke into the prison to massacre the Italian prisoners. Eleven of them were lynched, and the perpetrators never prosecuted 11/?
Tensions excalated between Italy and the US in the wake of this, so the president of the United States - Benjamin Harrison - was like damn, I need to appease these people. 12/?
In typical USian fashion, instead of - you know - actually prosecute the lynchers, he decided to 'celebrate the contribution of Italian to US society' by creating, in 1892, Columbus Day. 13/?
Most Italian-Americans, at the time, were desperate to climb the 'race ladder' in the US, so instead of rejecting this ridiculous proposal, pushed for making it a federal holiday. Instead of demanding justice for their children killed by white supremacists... 14/?
...most of them were content in getting absorbed in that very same system. Which is why, to me, it appears so ridiculous that many Italo-Americans proudly celebrate Columbus Day. First, because it has nothing to do with Italian culture, and second, because it's a festivity 15/?
born as a sop, a distraction when justice should have been delivered.
Seriously, with all the cool Italian festivities out there, you want to celebrate one that celebrates a genocidal maniac and was created to hide a lynching? 16/?
It is particularly annoying to see how everyone is speaking about CC as an Italian hero and Columbus Day as an Italian festivity when... they are not. 17/?
So I beg nth-generation Italian-Americans to stop clinging onto this festivity and begin reconnecting with their true heritage, which their ancestors traded for a place on the WhitePeopleTM table. Today we shall celebrate #IndigenousPeoplesDay2021 and, always, #LandBack 18/18
Addendum on this! This one's for the history nerds and those of my followers who remember my posts about the unification of Italy and the movement of the Risorgimento. During the Risorgimento (prior the unification) many Italians sought to create a sense of unity by +
basically celebrating any big name who could be connected to Italy. CC was one of these. You can find a statue of him in Genoa which was built in 1850ish, in the middle of the Risorgimento, for this reason. It's quite fascinating because +
it kinda testifies how the dream of a united Italy never kind of came to be. The people who built that statue, like ones who built the Savonarola statue in Ferrara (WHY WOULD YOU EVEN BUILT THAT OMG), wanted to create a connection from a fragmented past to a unified future +
but most Italians of the time didn't know who those people were. Because Italy was a poor country with low literacy and strong regional identities. Which is why CC - like Savonarola, and the others - never became part of Italian heritage the way Columbus Day make it seems to be +
Hell, to the average Italian, Padre Pio is 100000% times the 'Italian hero' CC would ever be 😂 /end
anyway if you came this far what about RTing this thread? I'm trying to spread awareness on fascism resurgence in Italy which idk why is not making international news

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Francesca Tacchi 🫒

Francesca Tacchi 🫒 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @jackdaw_writes

11 Oct
in this house we believe in capra e fagioli and violino di capra supremacy
Also adding that sheep meat is DELICIOUS as well. Nothing beats arrosticini during summer! A symbol of Abruzzo 👌
Read 4 tweets
10 Oct
Oof guys the situation in Italy is depressing AF. I'm doing my #ItalianThread after all, I had one programmed and at least it will take my mind off the fascists for a bit! Stay here to learn about...


Italy has been inhabited since the stone age. The first traces of humans in the peninsula date back to 850000 years ago! But of course, ancient Italic civilisations had no way of knowing this. So, they made up myths to justify their existence 2/?
These origin myths are varied and interesting. Often, there is more than one for a single society! I will gather some of them in this thread. So, let's begin... 3/?
Read 17 tweets
9 Oct
I had an #ItalianThread in mind for today, but my country is facing a horrifying political scandal involving far right parties Fratelli d'Italia and Lega. It didn't make international news, though, and it infuriates me. So I will explain the situation instead.

The news outlet @fanpage discovered, after years of infiltration, tangible proof of Fratelli d'Italia and Lega receiving money and support from neonazi and fascist groups, Russian diplomats, 'ndrangheta personalities and other shady people 2/?
What is especially troubling is that they give them, in turn, political positions. In particular, Lega, Matteo Salvini's party, is unoficially allied with the proclaimed neonazi group Lealtà e Nazione (...) and they admitted on record to put memebers of the group in political 3/?
Read 14 tweets
14 Aug
It's saturday! Which means it's time for my #ItalianThread. Today, it will be food-themed, as I will talk about...


one for each region! 1/?
Cheese is an important food in Italian cuisine and tradition, as talian society, before industrialisation, was mainly pastoral (transhumance is still a big event in some regions to this day) 2/?
Because of this, Italy has thousands of types of cheese to offer! I will list one per region, but I'll live out the most popular ones (fontina, parmigiano, mozzarella etc) to focus on types of cheese you may have not heard about - but you'd want to taste! 3/?
Read 25 tweets
13 Aug
Actually the fact I have expressed myself badly on the proselitysm thing still buggers me so... impromptu thread on proselitysm and catholic tradition, from my point of view of an Italian agnostic 1/?
proselytism is a form of forced conversion, which is practiced by many christian confessions, especially Evangelicals. In particular, it is associated with the belief that by forcing people to convert you are helping them and are acting as a 'good christian' 2/?
In modern days, the Catholic Church had distanced itself from proselitysm, branding it as an 'freedom-killing practice' because conversion should not be forced but inspired by the Holy Spirit. 3/?
Read 8 tweets
27 Jan
CW: holocaust

Today is #HolocaustRemembranceDay and I want to share this picture. Many of you will probably be familiar with this, it's a photo of the Nazis working at Auschwitz. Why am I sharing this? To make an important point about the mechanisms of the holocaust 1/?
We think about the Nazis as some creatures of pure evil, and by doing that we ignore the fact that they were bakers, husbands, wives, florists. They weren't nazguls. They were people like you and me. Which means you should HOLD YOURSELF ACCOUNTABLE. 2/?
By thinking of the Nazis as some evil parenthesis of history we ignore the hate that led them there. The antisemitism, the xenophobia, the racism, the homophobia. The same hate that is festering in modern society. 3/?
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!