Jury selection in two of the most high-profile murder trials in the country, the Kyle Rittenhouse and Ahmaud Arbery cases, resulted in mostly-white juries.

Legal experts told Insider how this happened, and why the jury selection system is imperfect. ⚖️

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou…
White teenager Kyle Rittenhouse faces homicide charges after killing two people and injuring a third during unrest tied to the shooting of a Black man in Kenosha, Wisconsin, last summer.

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou…
Meanwhile, three white men in Georgia are facing murder charges in connection with the shooting of Ahmaud Arbery, a Black man whose family says he was out for a jog.

insider.com/why-ahmaud-arb…
Jury selection for the Arbery case was a nearly two-and-a-half-week-long process, while the Rittenhouse jury was seated in just a day.

But they both ended with the same result: a mostly white jury with the exception of one person of color.

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou…
The defense and prosecution each get a limited amount of peremptory strikes, and that number varies from state to state.

Vanderbilt law professor Chris Slobogin said the number of peremptory strikes can be adjusted by the judge.

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou… Text graphic reads: Voire dire. / vwahr-deer /. Noun. The ju
According to the @timesenterprise, the judge in the Arbery case allowed the defense 24 challenges and the prosecution 12 challenges.

The defense having twice as many peremptory challenges gave them more power to shape the jury, Slobogin said.

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou…
A pool of 48 potential jurors initially was considered for the Arbery case, 36 of which were white and 12 of which were Black — reflecting the racial makeup of Glynn County.

All but one of those Black jurors was eliminated from the final jury.

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou…
Peremptory strikes are allowed to be called into question to protect from racial discrimination.

However in the Arbery case, the judge accepted the defense's explanations for why they struck 11 Black jurors, and the case was allowed to proceed.

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou…
The Rittenhouse jury makeup is less surprising to Wisconsin-based defense attorney Julius Kim.

In Kenosha County, where Kim has argued cases, 87% of residents are white and 7% are Black.

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou…
However, DMV records often are used to find people for jury duty, and Kim said that could mean some races that are more likely to have a driver's license could be overrepresented.

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou… Text-graphic shows a quote from  Wisconsin-based defense att
Both Kim and Slobogin said it still doesn't look good that the juries in the Rittenhouse and Arbery cases ended up being overwhelmingly white, with Kim saying the makeup of the Arbery jury makes him more "nervous."

insider.com/kyle-rittenhou… Text-graphic shows a quote from Vanderbilt law professor Chr
Closing arguments for Rittenhouse’s trial are expected to begin next week as both sides have rested their case.

For more coverage on the Arbery and Rittenhouse cases, follow @thisisinsider.

insider.com/witnesses-sugg…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Insider News

Insider News Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @InsiderNews

15 Oct
The largest reservoir in the US is drying up. The water there has dropped more than 140 feet in the last two decades.

But the US isn’t the only country experiencing abnormally dry weather conditions.

All around the world, severe droughts are happening 1.7 times more often than in 1850-1900.

So what’s causing this drought, and what could be the long-term damage?

It has to do more with temperature than less rainfall. Even though precipitation was actually above average in many parts of the US this summer, record rain can’t stop high temperatures from evaporating more water.

Read 11 tweets
20 Sep
The disappearance of Gabby Petito in Wyoming has caused a national outcry.

However, missing and murdered Indigenous people get less media coverage.

In the same state, 710 Indigenous people were reported missing from 2011 to 2020, a report found. ⬇️

insider.com/710-indigenous…
According to a report by Wyoming’s Missing and Murdered Indigenous People Task Force, most of the Indigenous people reported missing were girls.

Missing and murdered Indigenous people have not been met with the same nonstop media coverage as Petito.

insider.com/710-indigenous… A graphic reads: Of the 710 indigenous people missing from 2
When the murders of Indigenous people were covered, the news reports were "overly graphic" compared to white people, Wyoming Survey and Analysis Research Scientist Emily Grant, who worked on the report, told @WPR.

insider.com/710-indigenous… A graphic reads: Only 30% of Indigenous homicide victims mad
Read 9 tweets
24 Aug
Mina Sohail opened Simple Cafe in Kabul to give women a safe space to mingle. But since the Taliban took control of Afghanistan again, women say they're no more protected today than in 2001.

We followed Mina for a day before the Taliban retook Kabul.
Mina designed Simple Cafe in the heart of Kabul to give women a safe space to go with no restrictions. That means no required head covering and the freedom to come alone and mingle with men.
Mina never would have been able to own her own business under Taliban rule.

Half of Mina's employees are female. She knows how hard it is for them to find work in Afghanistan, where only 22% of women have jobs — one of the lowest rates in the world. Photo depicting Afghan women sitting at a cafe with the quot
Read 9 tweets
20 Aug
MMA fighters in Afghanistan were already getting death threats before the Taliban took back power in the country. We followed two star fighters as they continued training in midsummer even as the Taliban approached Kabul.
Since the US first announced it would withdraw from Afghanistan, targeted killings of journalists, activists, and religious minorities have been on the rise. And now, there’s fear that athletes could be next.
businessinsider.com/resurgent-tali…
During the Taliban's rule, between 1996 and 2001, the armed group allowed some sports, but with heavy regulations on attire and with breaks for prayer. businessinsider.com/resurgent-tali… Photo depicting Zaki Rasuli...
Read 13 tweets
24 Jul
NYC sent non-police teams to respond to mental health calls for a month.

Data shows that more people got help and fewer were hospitalized.

Here’s what happened.

insider.com/nyc-mental-hea… Image shows a New York City police officer talking to an act
The B-HEARD program — which stands for Behavioral Health Emergency Assistance Response Division — launched in part of Harlem last month.

It sent teams of three unarmed, behavioral health specialists to respond to 911 calls.

insider.com/nyc-mental-hea…
NYC's pilot program allowed for officers to be dispatched to a mental health emergency if there was a threat of violence or a weapon involved.

insider.com/nyc-mental-hea… Image shows study attribution card with text overlaid that r
Read 8 tweets
23 Jul
Many of America's most infamous gangsters were creatures of New York.

For this project, photographer Andrew Litchenstein set out to see what has become of some of the most notorious settings for wise guy activity in the city. ⬇️
businessinsider.com/made-men-a-pho…
Every neighborhood has layers of that history, buried beneath the newest construction project or the renamed, gentrified neighborhood.

Insider created an interactive map so you can see what mafia activity may have occurred in your neighborhood. 📍

businessinsider.com/made-men-a-pho… A graphic showing a map of New York metropolitan area, with
St. John’s Cemetery, Middle Village, Queens 📍

The mausoleum of Charles "Lucky" Luciano — architect of the American Mafia — sits in this cemetery.

In the 1930's Luciano and Meyer Lanksy set up the Commission, a governing body for the American mafia.

businessinsider.com/made-men-a-pho… A graphic that shows an image of Charles “Lucky” Luciano
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(