Lonerbox makes 2 unsupportable assertions. 1. Rittenhouse's reason for being there is unconnected to white nationalist attacks on BLM/the Left. 2. That Rittenhouse was pushed from larper to killer in the instant he was "attacked." He had already menaced protesters with his gun. ImageImageImage
And these are the same transparently stupid and ahistorical arguments used by white nationalists/fascists/MAGA for the last five years. "How can the Proud Boys be white nationalists when they have Black members?" and so on.
If you need to decontextualize everything down to the two and a half minutes of footage starting with Rittenhouse running from the people he provoked, you're not making a good faith argument.
Also, this is the standard Lee Fang type argument that the actions of the Left necessitate the far right to defend themselves, or drive people to become extreme Right wingers. Lonerbox claims Rittenhouse only moves from larper to killer in the moment someone tried to disarm him.
That's why people are correct to call out lonerbox using the term larper in the first place, and to notice this has been a way that the "dirtbag" (centrist/Berniecrat/left wing of the Democratic Party) Left downplay the threat of rising global fascist movements.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Josiah Walrus

Josiah Walrus Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Josiah_Walrus

15 Nov
Bottom line: Even if you want to strip away all political context, Rittenhouse running around pointing his gun at people provoked the first shooting incident. Everything that followed was people trying to disarm an active shooter. Provoking/causing means no self-defense claim.
And watching the video over and over of Rittenhouse pumping four shots into Rosenbaum, continuing to shoot as he crumples and even after he's down is very chilling. Kid thinks he's Seal Team Six killing al Qaeda. Doesn't look like self defense though.
"The kill shot is the one to the back."
Read 9 tweets
15 Nov
Finished Ministry for the Future. It portrays a utopian outcome to a multi-tactic struggle against capitalist eco destruction. In a way the "shadow government" reminded me of Bakunin's "invisible pilots" similar to Leninist vanguardism, a cadre of professional revolutionaries.
Robinson also can't seem to imagine a world without nation states, and waged labor and money are all part of the future. But the book presents one possible route to a "revolutionary" outcome brought about by different forces than past revolutions. Interesting to think about
The book addresses the question of what to do about intransigent ruling class power that could prevent the needed steps to decarbonize society in time to save the planet. It seems realistic that some form of organized violence would be necessary to give the revolution leverage.
Read 6 tweets
26 Aug
Nagle's latest centers nationalism as "anti-imperialist" + cites the "COSMOPOLITAN journalist class" shaking in their boots at the Hungarian nationalist Eden Tucker visited + Trump's "rebel nationalism" challenge to the "Open Society" (Soros/Jews/Liberalism) of the decaying West.
Nagle also blames cultural rot of once worthy empires, citing the teaching of "critical gender studies" art classes on Duchampn, + Lee Smith on the CIA giving viagra to warlords to rape boys, proving how out of touch elites are with _real_ Western values and white US workers.
The list of sources Nagle utilizes is 80% comically right wing. Malcom Kyeyune, The Spectator, Lee Smith (Tablet Mag), Phillip Cunliffe of Aufhebunga bunga writing for Spiked.
Read 4 tweets
24 Jun
This guy Heartfield is an anti-masker Covid Denialist who's been demanding full capitalist reopening for almost a year, promotes ruling class development, Right Libertarianism, and Nigel Farage, but CRT is bad because it's an attack on the working class. Predictable. Absurd.
Anyone who's taught history knows curriculum/textbooks are not going to have your exact take on class analysis. Teachers supplement lessons with their own expertise. The post-left and Right hate the 1619 Project, but Marxists like Gerald Horne and Eric Foner generally like it.
Heartfield consistently promotes Thatcher's ownership scheme and capitalist market housing development as socialist. He's a Brexit xenophobe who pretends to be a defender of migrants. Just a sick fucker.
Read 4 tweets
12 Apr
3 documentaries that add up to a damning picture of the Trump regime and the Right in the US.

1. The Brink:Steve Bannon's world tour organizing dictators and fascists into a coordinated global force. They failed electorally but the xenophobic program gained ground.
Q: Into the Storm: The three 8chan operators manipulate people to act on manufactured extreme Right conspiracies. They are presented as irony bro pranksters until you see the very real danger their tactics present on a large scale.
Totally Under Control: Trump sabotages the Covid response for political gain killing hundreds of thousands. Some of the insider interviews are extremely damning. Trump is unquestionably a mass murderer.
Read 4 tweets
10 Apr
How to assimilate Marxism and make it serve reactionary, nationalist, bigoted, exclusionary, and anti-working class politics. A 9 part thread with pictures. Image
1. Dig up ideologies developed by shady ex-Leninists who’ve embraced Right-Libertarianism, nationalism, class collaboration, xenophobia, reformist capitalism, and use anti-”PC” rhetoric to base-build with reactionaries and far right parties, but pretend it’s Marxist. Image
2. Find convincing thought leaders to promote this ideology while hammering at the liberal left. Lump together cartoonish neoliberal left views with anarchists, libcoms, and all other socialists outside the group while bolstering far right politics as “working class” and normal. Image
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(