My new interim report on what we currently know about the Benin collections of the University of Oxford has just been published online - read it here >> prm.ox.ac.uk/benin-bronzes
the 229-page report summarises
- 145 objects which provenance research suggests were looted in the Benin 1897 attack
- 15 further objects possibly from that attack
- more items taken in other expeditions in what's today Nigeria
- further Benin objects exported in the 20th century
here are some of those @Pitt_Rivers objects in a thread
1/ Carved ivory tusk burnt in the fires during the desecration of Benin city
2/ another sacred royal carved ivory tusk looted from Benin in 1897
3/ Ivory ladle with inlaid bronze and a bronze human figure on the handle
4/ Ivory Benin commemorative head with eyes inlaid with bronze
5/ Ivory pedestal bowl inlaid with bronze
6/ Ivory lid
7/ Brass relief plaque depicting three figures, the central on holding a ceremonial box
8/ Ivory carved figure, probably broken from a ceremonial staff or flywhisk
9/ Bronze ring-shaped container with incised decoration depicting a fish
10/ Bronze altar-piece base
11/ Gilded bronze cone-shaped hip ornament
12/ Bronze armlet
13/ Bronze armlet
14/ Bronze armlet
15/ Gilded bronze armlet
16/ Ivory armlet with inlaid bronze
17/ ceremonial sword in a red coralwork sheath
18/ Bronze altarpiece with figures of the Queen Mother with six attendants
19/ Ivory armlet inlaid with brass
20/ Ivory double armlet with carved openwork decoration
21/ Ivory side-blown trumpet (fragment)
22/ Bronze armlet
23/ Bronze armlet
24/ Bronze armlet
25/ Bronze armlet with inset coral
26/ wooden painted altar-piece igbile mask with a canework base
27/ Brass powder cylinder
28/ Bronze plaque fragmnt with the image of a serpent
29/ Brass relief plaque
30/ Brass plaque with an image of a mudfish
31/ Brass sculpture or altar-piece in the form of a morion-shaped helmet
32/ Brass ceremonial casket with a cover and chain for suspension with relief decoration and chased work
33/ Brass ceremonial staff with a figure of a bird
34/ Bronze hip-ornament mask
35/ Bronze hip-ornament mask depicting a ram’s head
36/ Bronze hip-ornament mask depicting a crocodile’s head
37/ another bronze hip-ornament mask depicting a crocodile’s head
38/ Bronze altar bell
39/ Bronze armlet with open-work decoration
40/ another bronze armlet with open-work decoration
41/ copper armlet with bronze decoration depicting two faces
42/ Bronze penannular leg-ring or armlet
43/ Copper armlet
44/ Iron armlet
45/ Ivory armlet
46/ Ivory hip-ornament mask depicting a leopard
47/ Ivory door-bolt from the Royal Palace*
* yes they even looted the door bolts
48/ Brass ceremonial fan with repoussé decoration
49/ wooden lidded bowl or casket overlaid with brass, in the form of an animal’s head
50/ wooden figure of a horse-rider, broken from a ceremonial staff
51/ Brass plaque with relief decoration depicting three human figures
okay to see all 145 @Pitt_Rivers objects, and to read the discussion of the other objects that may be from the 1897 Benin attack, and its aftermath - and items from elsewhere in Nigeria taken during military expeditions, download the report here >> prm.ox.ac.uk/benin-bronzes
oh yes we also have some remarkable primary documentation of the purchase of recently-looted Benin material by Augustus @Pitt_Rivers in 1898 and 1899
each of which we can match with objects in the collection today
one more for you @uwagbale_ - A Carved wooden stool looted from Benin City in 1897 by Lieutenant Reginald Kerr Granville
for those in a hurry, from the appendices of the report here are the pictures of the @Pitt_Rivers objects discussed and the historic photographs from the Benin 1897 attack, in 1 minute and 48 seconds
1/16
It’s a strange calling, to get your hands dirty with the detritus of the past, to crouch with a trowel in a muddy trench, to trace the delicate contours of earth works in rainy fields, to run soil through a sieve, to ink letters and numbers onto potsherds and ziplock bags,
2/ to perhaps put what some you found on display to the public and to deposit the vast majority of it in box after box in a museum store room, all in the name of excavating ghosts, waking the dead, reading a past that was not written down but just left behind.
1/14 this announcement by the Smithsonian is another sign that we are witnessing a fundamental global shift in the ethics of museum curation
in the past a self-selected handful of the richest and most powerful institutions has sought to control, dominate and close down the debate
2/ but since the 1990s restitution has become a mainstream part of professional practice in the very different historical circumstances of returning Nazi loot or ancestral human remains to Indigenous people around the world.
every now and then working at a museum like the @Pitt_Rivers means that you experience a moment of sheer terror and shock
I had one of those moments, a truly M.R. James winter night kind of moment of revelation, while working yesterday evening
(THREAD)
I was working through some historic photographs of museum curators to send to a colleague as part of a current artist collaboration
Most of the photographs were from the first decade of the 20th century, shared with a designer we're working with for details of dress
for example I sent her this photo taken “on the occasion of the first practical examination in anthropology in 1908″, showing Beatrice Blackwood, Sir Francis Knowles, 5th Baronet, James Harley, and their tutor the curator Henry Balfour
it's been a very busy week for the return of looted objects from France to Bénin 🇧🇯 and from the UK to Benin City, Nigeria🇳🇬
here's a summary of what's been going on (THREAD) 👇
1/ a "farewell exhibition" is being held at the @quaibranly
displaying the 26 items of the Trésor de Béhanzin, looted from the Abomey Palace in the Kingdom of Dahomey in 1892—which will be returned to Cotonou next month
The exhibit is open till Sunday quaibranly.fr/fr/expositions…
2/ a major conference was held to mark this landmark return, with speeches from many of the key players including Prof @FelwineSarr and Prof Bénédicte Savoy @KuK_TUBerlin — who compared this watershed moment to the fall of the Berlin Wall: "there was before, and there was after"
the Trésor de Béhanzin—looted by General Alfred Dodds in November 1892 from the Palace of Abomey, and donated by him to the French state—is being returned from Paris to Bénin
here’s a shortlist thread of some of the 26 items involved:
just catching up with the Policy Exchange “History Matters Principles for Change” culture war manifesto, and 60 seconds in my first observation is that “the UK’s leading think tank” appears not to understand the difference between English Heritage and Historic England
also direct contravention of @MuseumsAssoc ethical guidelines on donors and curatorial integrity here
it will also surprise Oxbridge Governing Bodies that Policy Exchange think that the university’s Vice Chancellor might be a “stakeholder” in their decision-making — while evidently elected student bodies, alumni, unions, the wider public, etc may not be