The weirdest part about people losing their shit over this entirely correct tweet is nowhere in it do I actually, as accused, blame Biden or the Democrats. I know they're hamstrung.
That, I would argue, is only adding to the tune out and fade away reaction among Democratic voters. If they vote in Democrats, but those Democrats are utterly helpless to make change even if they win, then it seems pretty pointless.
Republicans win when they win and win when they lose. Soon their power will be beyond even the already ineffectual efforts of the people to get rid of them. That's why I use the term "learned helplessness." It's what happens to people when nothing they do changes anything.
Trump organized a coup that culminated in a violent insurrection and the chance of him going to jail appears to be less than zero. Indeed, the odds are high that he'll being the next president in three years, even though he won't win fairly. No wonder people are giving up.
Through redistricting alone, Republicans will retake the House, even if every single Democrat who voted in 2020 votes again. And that's not even looking at voter suppression and election office takeovers.…
Trump will lose to Biden in 2024, but this time, McCarthy will be in charge of the House. Any state's electoral vote that Trump asks to be thrown out likely will be. Major democracy reform legislation could prevent that. But Manchin/Sinema took that off the table.
All this happens to be true, without you having to falsely declare that I'm bashing the Democrats as a whole. I know most of them see this situation for what it is, and would change it if they could. But they can't, not with Manchin/Sinema in the way.
But if Democratic leadership is helpless, imagine how ordinary people feel! So no wonder they're checking out. That's what learned helplessness is. Your actions don't matter, so you just....give up.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Amanda Marcotte

Amanda Marcotte Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @AmandaMarcotte

18 Nov
The Rittenhouse and McMichael-Bryan killings are the result of decades of NRA propaganda and lobbying that encourages white people, especially white men to think it's somehow "self-defense" to go out looking for fights.…
One thing is absolutely certain: If Rittenhouse, the McMichaels, and Bryan had acted like sensible people instead of indulging their cowboy fantasies of going out and looking for trouble, the men they shot would be alive today. Image
The law only addresses the "in the moment" concept of self-defense. But the larger cultural problem is right wing propaganda and the NRA encourage people to instigate or escalate violent conflict, even though the smart and moral thing to do would be to avoid it. Image
Read 9 tweets
17 Nov
Joe Manchin's latest excuse to try to kill Build Back Better is "inflation". But that's total nonsense, as the green energy provisions are one of the best tools we have to stabilize the economy and prevent inflation.…
What's driving inflation? Why it appears to be largely due to demand for oil dramatically outstripping supply. Gosh, if there was only a way to reduce demand for oil....oh wait, there is: Build Back Better.
Clean energy is inherently a more stable form of energy, and that means it's less likely to cause inflation shocks. Or, put more simply, if price swings at the gas pump are ruinous for you, an electric car might be the solution.
Read 4 tweets
17 Nov
I think this is right. People are checking out because they busted their ass to elect Democrats and the only real change they see is slightly less Trump in the news. It’s learned helplessness and it’s the best friend of fascism.…
I don’t blame people for checking out. Yes, fascism is on the march and consuming our democracy. But all options to stop that have been ruled out by Manchin and Sinema. So now it’s just about waiting to see if the coup organizes well enough to succeed or not.
“Three years we’ll know if we are as doomed or whether some miracle saves us, but in the meantime, no action you take can affect the outcome” is not the formula to get people engaged.
Read 13 tweets
16 Nov
More reflections on Rittenhouse, the "critical race theory" censorship campaign, and the Texas abortion ban: It's becoming quite clear that Republicans want a vigilante-driven American version of the Stasi.…
The misnamed group Moms for Liberty is offering a $500 bounty for those who snitch on teachers teaching "critical race theory" — which the group defines so broadly that it would forbid teaching kids about the March on Washington or Brown vs. Board of Education. Image
The reason Rittenhouse is a folk hero on the right is not mysterious. As with past movements like the KKK, it's all about using vigilante violence to cow people from speaking out against racism. Image
Read 6 tweets
12 Nov
In 2016 "grab 'em by the pussy" embarrassed Republicans. Now it's basically the party's motto, as evidenced by the murderer's row of abusers and pigs that are running for higher office.…
Trump-endorsed PA Senate candidate Sean Parnell is accused of strangling his wife and punching a door into his child's face. And on Fox Nation, he let loose with a misogynist rant that sounds an awful lot like justifying such behavior because of "high maintenance" women.
Indeed, Trump is backing multiple candidates accused of beating or threatening to kill women. No surprise, as he also reportedly nicknamed Steve Bannon "Bam Bam," in reference to Bannon's own domestic abuse allegations.
Read 6 tweets
8 Nov
Hawley is leaning on the old "submit to men, or they will abandon you" threat, of course. But such threats have lost their teeth now that being single, for women, no longer means being destitute or cast out of society.
The audience Hawley is trying to appeal to is not Men of Courage, but whiny babies who are so goddamn useless that they throw a fit if women expect them to make their own sandwiches. And I don't think such men are going to be keen on all his "responsibility" talk.
Nah, what Hawley is defending is sexism, and men who feel entitled to dominate, humiliate, and even hurt women. He's not here for the loving husband who supports his wife, but the shitty husband demanding he's waited on by a long-suffering wife.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!