EBL Profile picture
Nov 27, 2021 17 tweets 6 min read Read on X
In anticipation of Rangnick taking over as Manchester United manager for the remainder of the season, I decided to take a deep-dive into his practical managerial qualities. Lots have discussed his philosophy, but few have analysed it in practice. Below, I do just that.

THREAD!
Ralf Rangnick is a flexible coach who adapts his tactics & style of play to the opposition by playing a number of different tactical styles. Upon analysing some of his games in his most recent managerial stint, it's clear that his reputation as a high pressing coach is warranted.
Rangnick's philosophy and wisdom when speaking about football makes a lot of sense, but how does that translate to the practical world? Well, his managerial style matches up with his deep, intellectual analysis of the game. He prepares his team well & analyses the oppo thoroughly
Rangnick sticks to his set philosophy (pressing high and controlling the game with that pressing) before making adaptations to the opposition. For example, against Favre's Dortmund, he adapted his press to match Witsel dropping in between the two CB's when building play.
Rangnick's entire philosophy centres around creating defenders overloads on the byline i.e. using the byline as an extra defender. RBL shift across to match up on the sides here and the angles in which BVB can play at are limited. The byline is closed off & all players are marked
Rangnick's system against Dortmund essentially replicated Klopp's Liverpool in the sense that they pressed in a 3-3 offensive shape with the fullbacks pushing on aggressively to press the play to support the outside midfielders when shifting across too. Again, adaptable.
Ragnick similarly implemented the concept of defensive overloads on the byline against Bayer Leverkusen except in a 5-3-2 shape. Again, the concept remained the same - invite the opposition wide and collapse the play. This is a staple of play we can expect to see at United.
However, some problems did arise within the 5-3-2 block. Often times Ragnick's team attempted to collapse the play on the sides to create that defensive overload on the byline but the wide midfielders were left with too much space to cover after play was circulated.
The wide midfielders having a large amount of ground to cover resulted in Leverkusen's fullbacks having quite a lot of time on the ball. A combination of an incredibly aggressive high line and a player in a deep phase with time on the ball is disastrous. This will be punished.
If someone like Andy Robertson had the ball in that position he would hook the ball in beyond the last line to the willing runner in Mo Salah and Sadio Mané. The block would be completely pulled apart and they'd be free on goal. This is a relatively common theme for Ragnick.
At times, the defensive overloads on the byline are superb. However, on other occasions, the initial line of pressing can be passive when inviting the opposition to pass wide. Against the elite quality in the PL, Ragnick's pressing will need to be more consistently aggressive.
The staple philosophy, implementation and understanding of Ragnick's tactical principles are good, but the lack of aggression from the front line of pressing can see the block become passive and forced back/exploited. Often times they can be too hesitant when waiting for triggers
Alternatively, in possession, from a structural point of view, Ragnick's teams play a variety of different styles varying from the 3-1 build-up within the 5-3-2/diamond or a 2-2 build-up within a standard 4-2-3-1/4-4-2 shape.
Creatively, Ragnick's entire philosophy centres around pressing. The quality of the press determines how good the team are creatively and control-wise. However, because United have top players, they'll have settled possession too, and Ragnick likes fluid combination play.
Within the 4-4-2/4-2-3-1 Ragnick encourages his forward on the right to drift to the closest side to combine with the right back, right central midfielder, and right winger, and the same dynamic is seen on the left hand-side or in other systems (the diamond and 5-3-2).
So, within the 5-3-2 shape, the outside midfielders were required to drift high to combine on the sides. In the below images, play was circulated from the left to the right as the combination play wasn't possible to execute on the left, but it was on the right (overload).
Overall, it's clear that based on elite managers' appreciation of Ragnick, his track record in building clubs, his words, and his tactical ideas on the pitch that he is an elite football mind. However, to succeed in the PL, he might need to increase the aggression of his block.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with EBL

EBL Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @EBL2017

Dec 3
⚪️ Thomas Frank reminded everyone last night:

He is a top-level tactician.

Spurs weren’t perfect — but the ideas were exceptional.

If this version of Spurs becomes consistent, Thomas Frank can transform the club.

THREAD! 🚨Image
Thomas Frank reminded us all that he is a top tactician last night.

We just need to see it more often.

Roberto De Zerbi-esque build-up:

🔹 4-2-4,
🔹 Can play over to 1v1's on the top line,
🔹 Narrow positioning to land on 2nd balls,
🔹 Solutions to build vs man-to-man.

TOP 💯 Image
Image
Image
Image
Higher up, Porro inverted into the back 3, Bentancur and Sarr formed a double pivot, and Udogie inverted into the half space between the lines with Johnson holding the width.

3-2-5.

But Porro had license to make the shape a 2-3-5 when Newcastle only left 1 up in transition. Image
Image
Read 16 tweets
Nov 10
Pep Guardiola has found his latest Manchester City blueprint for success.

It is similar to Arne Slot methodology which saw Liverpool win the title last season.

Imperfect, but it works.

Here's why City can push Arsenal and compete for BOTH the PL & CL this season 🤯

THREAD! 🚨Image
Pep Guardiola & Manchester City latest stylistic iteration is most similar to Unai Emery & Aston Villa…

Zonal pressing from goal kicks & willing to sit off in a passive block whilst hitting teams on the counter but also still playing out from the back with positional play high. Image
Manchester City's and Pep's new identity has only become set in stone in recent weeks.

They tried to press in their Lijnders inspired zonal system and had success from goal kicks, but not in open play - they were killed.

Now, they ACCEPT being pinned back and can defend deep. Image
Read 16 tweets
Oct 28
The new iteration of Pep Guardiola's Manchester City have some clear issues:

💎 Despite being a top coach, Lijnders' defensive idea has not worked whatsoever with this group of players.
💎 Lack physicality to lead the press and win duels.
💎 Missing top-end quality in key areas. Image
In possession, nobody doubts the quality of Guardiola's structure.

The idea almost always makes total sense.

City build in a 4-3-3 (or a 4-2-4 if Bernardo drops deep) before morphing into a 3-2-5 with Stones inverted into midfield.

Structurally, absolutely no problems here… Image
Image
But compare the quality Pep had in his previous teams vs now:

Donnarumma is worse technically than Ederson.
Oscar Bobb is not as threatening as Mahrez.
Savinho is not as threatening as Grealish (the treble winning version).
Foden is not De Bruyne.

Output is no longer there.
Read 14 tweets
Oct 1
A SCATHING REVIEW of Enzo Maresca and Chelsea 🔵

“Respect defending or DIE!”

MEGA-THREAD! 🚨Image
Enzo Maresca may be unlucky in certain regards because the expectations at Chelsea are to compete with Liverpool and Arsenal when his squad is quite simply not on that level (the XI is, but the depth behind it is not), but he can't be excused for Chelsea's mid-block or mentality.
Chelsea dominate the ball in most games they play.

And they are incredibly well set-up tactically when they do have the ball.

For example, against José Mourinho's Benfica, Chelsea set up in a 2-3-5 shape with both fullbacks inverted

The idea made total sense against the 4-5-1. Image
Read 31 tweets
Sep 28
Arne Slot has one clear tactical flaw:

Defending against teams who use a box midfield or a 3-2 build-up shape in open play.

Liverpool only press with 4 against Palace's 5.

Good teams manipulate this to get time on the ball before playing vertically through Liverpool's block 👇 Image
Image
Image
Arne Slot's idea in this moment is to trap the opposition to one side whilst leaving the far-side opponent unmarked.

This can work, on occasion, and it often works from situations like goal kicks because Liverpool can position themselves where they want from restart moments. Image
But, in open play, the opposition can often use the overload to their advantage, even more so if they get the goalkeeper involved to create a 6v4.

Simple switches of play or short & sharp combination play amongst the 3-2 shape can get guys like Wharton facing forwards with time. Image
Image
Image
Read 5 tweets
Sep 22
Xabi Alonso has created the most tactically complete Real Madrid that I have ever seen.

4-2-4 build-up, 3-2-5 attack, man-to-man pressing from the goal kick, & most importantly Madrid are getting effective pressure on the ball in open play!

A breakdown of the new-look Madrid 👇 Image
Image
Image
Image
Alonso has implemented some 🔝 in-possession dynamics.

A positional idea but fluidity/freedom is encouraged within the framework.

For example, Tchouaméni (one of the most intelligent players alive) has taken up a Kroos-esque role in the left half space with Carreras pushing on. Image
With Tchouaméni dropping outside the shape, he becomes hard to pick up within the opposition's press but it also creates another number higher on the left hand-side of Madrid's attack.

So, instead of attacking with only 3 in a triangle, Tchouaméni makes it a quartet. Image
Image
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(