BREAKING - THANKS BE TO GOD, WE OBTAINED A MAJOR VICTORY AT THE 9TH CIRCUIT FOR OUR CLIENTS IN THE SDUSD VACCINE MANDATE LITIGATION.
Here is the decision issued tonight: thomasmoresociety.org/.../9-circuit-….... The Court's full ruling will follow shortly.
We are very pleased with the Ninth Circuit’s grant of the rare remedy of emergency injunctive relief pending appeal, which prevents the San Diego Unified School District’s vaccine mandate – one of the harshest in the nation – from going into operation on November 29, 2021.
Although the case is still in its early stages, this is a significant victory. SDUSD should promptly revise its policy to include religious exemptions for students.
Otherwise, we are confident that we will fully vindicate our clients’ rights either in the Ninth Circuit or in the U.S. Supreme Court, if necessary.
As Judge Ikuta rightly observes: "any unvaccinated student attending in-person classes poses the same risk to the school district’s interest in ensuring a safe school environment” as students seeking religious exemptions, who are barred at the schoolhouse door.
Under the Free Exercise Clause, SDUSD cannot treat students better if they seek exemption from vaccination for secular as opposed to religious reasons. The COVID regime of secular favorites but religious outcasts must end. There is no vaccine exception to the Free Exercise Clause
Until that truth becomes the law of the land, the battle for religious freedom from state-coerced vaccination—while secular exemptees are given a pass—will not be over.
He stood firm in the face of fines, threats of imprisonment, massive civil litigation, a contempt proceeding, and a retaliatory attempt to revoke his church’s 45 year old parking lot lease. His crime?
Exercising his God-given and constitutionally protected right to practice his faith and hold church services without arbitrary interference from the state. He had faith in God and courage (and some good lawyers I might add 😀), and he emerged VICTORIOUS
— and now the County of LA and State of CA are paying him $800,000 to cover his attorneys’ fees and settle his case.
It’s been an honor and privilege to represent Pastor John MacArthur with @JennaEllisEsq. This is an incredible story of faith, perseverance, and courage.
Yes, there are judges in CA that understand the Constitution and are willing to take bold action to uphold it. Some notable quotes from Judge Chalfant when he correctly ruled last Friday that LA County had not met its burden to single out churches and ban indoor services at GCC:
"THE GOVERNOR CAN'T JUST ISSUE POLICIES WITHOUT A RATIONAL BASIS TO DO SO. TO MY KNOWLEDGE HE NEVER HAS DEVELOPED A RATIONAL BASIS TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN BUSINESSES. THIS IS ALL SORT
OF SHOOTING FROM THE HIP. WHICH IS UNDERSTANDABLE AT THE BEGINNING OF AN EMERGENCY ...
AND LESS UNDERSTANDABLE AS TIME GOES ON. THAT'S POINT ONE..."
"ALTHOUGH THE MOVING PAPER PURPORTS TO TREAT CHURCHES THE SAME AS OTHER BUSINESSES, THAT IS
CONSTITUTIONALLY WRONG. THEY'RE ENTITLED TO HEIGHTENED PROTECTION, NOT TO BE TREATED LIKE A HAIR SALON."