Kai E. Iliev Profile picture
Dec 5, 2021 30 tweets 15 min read Read on X
Real Betis – F.C Barcelona: First defeat under Xavi: What went wrong, how to use Barcelona's weaknesses & interesting substitutions.

#JdPExplains

[THREAD]
1/ Real Betis cut off access to Busquets by playing two forwards between Araujo/Lenglet & Sergio. Full-backs were also man-marked, leaving Barcelona w/ the following question:
"How do we advance from there?"

They found the answer after a while: Patience to move Betis.
2/Barcelona exploited the principle of "Pass in front->receive->pass back-> advance", which resulted in a good occupation of space Real Betis left open, but the efficiency in the last few actions still lacks, unfortunately.

Time is given, and space is created.
Barcelona come in advanced positions w/ positional advantage – w/ correct structure (&stretch the pitch), but wrong decisions:
-Wrong communication (Abde received while backing out instead of advancing, w/ negative body orientation)
& space in the wings is not well-used.
Abde doesn't seem to be interested into furthermore exploiting the wide free spaces (& prefers to drift inside where Betis defend the best, instead of wide weaker areas). Easy for Betis to defend, limiting options & forcing Barcelona back (gives time to reorganize!).
Memphis receives in advantage w/ time after a body feint to received between the lines, but the team nor him are ready for the next move: Forced to go back. No proper options & he doesn't know what to do w/ the ball => Easy to defend against despite the holes of Real Betis.
3/Barcelona failed to complete its intended overloads. Those attacks of space have to be accurate, and Coutinho as well as others are not accurate in their positioning – they run every now and then, but a proper sequence lacked – without accuracy, overloads aren't as productive.
Coutinho received in the right space at the right time and had indeed scanned his environments prior to reception, yet fails to register the information of the Betis player marking him – his movement is slow & loses possession where it could have been progression.
Barcelona's back-line relied on anticipation (as expected!) but failed to implement it, through miscommunication and lack of interpretation. Real Betis' forward accelerate faster than Barcelona and take advantage of space behind their backs.
Massive improvement needed.
Barcelona's based structure remained similar in possession and that is not necessarily negative. However Barcelona failed to sync after stretching the pitch as the full-back's reception was followed w/ inaccurate movement, often remain still too far as passing outlets.
What's curious is that there were 1v1 situation Coutinho found himself where he could get passed his marker despite not being his main asset, but he often, like Depay, failed to release the ball at the right time, to the right teammate. Overcomplication is a big issue for both.
Barcelona did find situation in the left-flank where they had space + time but sub-optimal decision-making (on&off-the-ball) failed to convert the positional advantage.
It is not an issue of the individual, but an issue of a team not synced.

Alba's run is ignored.
Some could blame Coutinho (criticism deserved!) but I've also highlighted Abde who earlier did the exact same double error (drifting in where it's the most compact & ignoring the wide run off the ball of the respect full-back in Alba & Dest).

These are awareness issues.
Though Coutinho is much older than his teammate Abde, both lack equally so in their maturity (Abde deserves softer criticism for his younger age, but the point stands). That both found more advantage in drifting in where Betis were focused is incomprehensible.
With that said, Coutinho's shot here is amazing & horrible at the same time. He feints through a fake shot to send his rival sleeping, but he also made the ball reception harder for him (once again, lack of information despite scannning!) & of course the shot..off-target.
Barcelona's press was difficult to understand: A willingness to press high by some, but not by others. Losing men + energy quickly here, Xavi will want to fix it. Press is important here as it would avoid most of Barcelona's consequential defensive transitional issues.
Emphasis on body reception: It is not only Coutinho. Several other players lacked awareness/responsibility yesterday. And these few details can give extra seconds that change the situation in its entirety. Xavi will have to work on maturing his players in this aspect for sure.
Fortunately for Barcelona, Real Betis also replicated the mistake of unconvinced & non-sequential press, which bought Barcelona time & tired Betis & eliminated the forward lines w/ very little action.

Real Betis might want to fix that: Accuracy & dedication is primordial.
Many like to repeat that Dest does not receive the ball in favourable conditions (& they're not wrong!) but a case should be made for Dest failing to make himself available. He needs to be ready to receive the ball & dare to run more – only then will he receive well.
Real Betis continued to give Barcelona the midfield, which is incredible. It gave Barcelona a lot of time to configure their next action w/ time & therefore created space is easily. Prop to Memphis who did well in body feints to drop deep to receive the ball & continue play.
Though Barcelona did not make it as difficult for Abde as seen in prior matches, yesterday was a moment where Abde often received in horrific situations. Nico still needs to make himself available after passing instead of standing like a goal post (reminds me of Arthur!).
Many on here used to blame Araujo for his lack of progression in-possession, but rare are those that point out how often he's making himself available as first progressor to Ter Stegen. And that says a lot, and he was splendid, sprinting back to help Mats progress.
It seemed as Real Betis had already given up on pressing Barcelona correctly. Busquets is given his favourite context, that of receiving the ball, turning & eliminating opponents & find a direct outlet in Gavi who helped the team travel an immense distance.
Something I struggle to understand w/ the persistence to continue through the left is that while it optimizes the situation for Gavi, it's also a waste to not use how Nico Gonzalez moves w/ the ball to unbalance the opposition (weak in the right-space), combine w/ Dest & Abde.
Here's another instance where Barcelona used more feints w/ body orientation, allowing to confused Betis & giving total space in wide areas, & Coutinho's shot is almost in – it's part of the thing that cannot be controlled, where it goes or it doesn't.
Unfortunate.
Problems in transition began when Barcelona failed to anticipate (i.e Depay, who sees his reception intercepted) & Barcelona don't register the information of where to block & end up confused & Betis have clear lanes of attack – too many runners to handle.
Barcelona managed to tilt the game in its favour through the substitutions of Dembélé & FdJ – key difference makers & unfortunately a goal didn't arrive, but Barcelona used Betis' weaknesses much better to my sense. With that said, massive improvement are needed.
The back-line needs to sync with the rest of the team, just like any other area, both offensively and defensively. It failed to intercept key targets in the middle of Betis' counter-attacks (& pressing inaccurate – big difference-maker!) & it failed to communicate.
The midfield was mostly rightly used in the left, but the right remains a ghosted outlet despite the presence of Abde & Nico – which is hardly understandable. I hope to see more of it in the future, as I believe it would be key to do so.
A lot of improvement is not only needed collectively, but also individually. Many players do mistakes that are easily fixed (w.r.t body orientation, or simple sync) & would only demand little work. It's mostly syncing that will prevent & create chances on a bigger scale.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Kai E. Iliev

Kai E. Iliev Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @jdeposicion

Mar 8, 2023
Manuel Pellegrini:
“City’s success made new demands of United. Traditionally they were bigger but it’s changing; kids tend to support winning teams. English football changed but respects tradition. When I came in 1988 it was about getting the ball into the area quickly.
Some of that essence is maintained. A team that’s 1‑0 up wants a second and a third.”

From the dirty, muddy pitches with crowds wanting transitions to the patient build-up, through Silva, KdB to Rodri. Or to other players, like Elliott, Kanté and Scholes.
On England's football as a whole:
“The spectacle matters and there’s strength. City, United, Arsenal, Liverpool, Chelsea, Tottenham, now Newcastle, could all compete for the league. The distribution of money is better, the amount generated. In Spain the gap is significant.”
Read 10 tweets
Jan 16, 2023
F.C Barcelona - Real Madrid: Winners of the Spanish Super Cup, Xavismo continued.

[THREAD]

#JdPExplains
A primordial game, though insignificant on paper. The Spanish Super Cup used to be a final game between the league & Copa Del Rey winners, but the format recently has changed. After Valencia and Betis were booted out by the archrivals, here they were to meet again.
A Clásico.
This is mentioned not out of pride, but out of necessity. A Clásico will always be of epic proportions, no matter how one tries to minimize its impact, even when it is in Saudi Arabia following Rubiales' great aspirations.
It's a potential turning point in Xavismo, first trophy.
Read 21 tweets
Jan 15, 2023
Oscar Hernández's experience on his first days with Mascherano's Argentinian U20 NT:

"With Mascherano, we introduced a more fundamental positional play. They discovered that many of the stereotypes people had over it [JdP] were erroneous. We noted that JdP doesn't restrict...
...But that there are zones that must be occupied, but that it doesn't have to be occupied by the "assigned player." The fullback can occupy the zone of the winger, the winger the one[zone] of the interior...the player has total freedom of movement to receive the ball".
"What we're searching for with all of this is an understanding of the environment, which is different from understanding the game. The game isn't understood, it is played. Understanding the environment allows progression: How to find [numerical] superiority,
Read 7 tweets
Dec 2, 2022
Germany's exit explained – as requested – #JdPMiniThread
I. Background

Since the 2014 World Cup Trophy, Germany's legacy has become forgettable. The 2016 Euros didn't convince many, and 2018 became the last straw for Joachim Löw – losing against South Korea in the process.

The Old Guard had to retire, change was coming.
After the Champions League victory with Bayern, Hansi Flick was hired by the DFB as the national team coach.
His job? Ensure the transition be smooth, with new talents with likes of Kai Havertz, Jamal Musiala, Bella-Kotchap, Joshua Kimmich and Sané + Gnabry making their names.
Read 12 tweets
Nov 29, 2022
Find the argument interesting, but I don't think I necessarily agree.

For one, I don't think John (or for the record, a majority of “us” — those that enjoy positionism”) suggest/ed “This is the perfect way football should be played.”

Instead, it's rather an ideal.
There's a concept, an ideal.
And there's a reality.

Those two a different. When me, John or any “positionist” for instance has watched a structurally similar space distribution on the basis of a passmap, and called it perfect, it doesn't mean it's infallible. In no way.
Instead, it means perfect with regards to our/my ideal — space occupation.

It's indeed true it leads to an ideation of ideas that might seemed rigid to me, for some, over-rationalized.

Let's compare it to another common situation. Scripts.

Are scripts restrictive?
Read 12 tweets
Sep 6, 2022
Matthias Jaissle:

On philosophy.

“I think it’s important that every club has a philosophy about the way they want to play. But what is also important for me as a coach: Here in Salzburg are guardrails – but within these guardrails, each coach can bring his own signature.”
We often forget to differentiate club culture from individual coaching philosophy. With clubs that focus on home-grown talents, it's important that certain basics remain visible across all categories — but with different footprints from each manager to have player learning.
On the different ways to press the opponent:

“I prefer the ball-oriented pressing in a swarm. Because I believe that you can achieve more when everyone from the team is involved. The goal is to create a surplus near the ball very fast.
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(