How fast it all happend. Dec 6, 1:25pm Weibo account with 39k followers posts this video. 11:01pm, Sanxing Township issues a statement on WeChat, which Dianshi News shares 1 hour later on Weibo. Other news agencies follow, lots of posts through the night. Haimen District
publishes its statement on Weibo at 5:15 on December 7, People's Daily Online reacts to this only 15 minutes later. Many posts yesterday, apparently there was another elderly sugarcane seller whose merchandise was seized. 200 citizens organised to help elderly sell sugarcane.
I am sure there is more to this fascinating story, which is also covered in a lot of traditional news outlets, often with interesting background information on the company and its relationship with the township government. I find this so fascinating because every day,
there are dozens of stories of grave injustice on Weibo, but it happens very, very seldom that they blow up like this.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
First of all, are 12345 hotlines, and their online counterpart, mayor's mailboxes, in principle, a good thing? Absolutely! Should we have them in Europe? Definitely! Are they in any way related to democracy? No. 2/n
Chinese citizens do not have a right to a 12345 hotlines. They are also not subject to public accountability. They are an offer the government can rescind at any time. And: consultation does not equal democracy. 3/n
Current developments have implications on China-related research that go far beyond the self-censorship debate that had people at their throats a couple of months ago. Then, the stakes were losing access to China. Now, the stakes are being detained, possibly for a very long time.
Of course, not many scholars have been detained so far (and not so many seem to have lost access, for that matter), but what matters are the signals and the precedents.
Maybe the CCP does not intend to systematically arrest scholars for what they say and write about China, but maybe it does, and it is this ambiguity that affects how we research China, and how our research will be interpreted by others.