READ THIS: An NYC public defender's brilliant oped in Teen Vogue. Grappling w/ why even those who oppose mass criminalization keep believing in it. "Weve been educated by the same popular culture — taught to accept the same cruelty." A Law & Order mindset. teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
NYC Public Defender & movement lawyer, Olayemi Olurin (@msolurin) starts w/ this upsetting observation: The crisis on Rikers every one was talking about just a month ago has already "faded from headlines." This is a "familiar pattern." But she doesn't stop there. She asks *why.
Familiar pattern: "Extreme events of injustice generate public outrage & awareness. Then stories fade, everyone forgets, & the status quo prevails. It’s as if this crisis isn’t happening." And the very systems that caused & created these injustices continue to expand. Again: Why?
Why does a legal system *we know* fails & harms keep expanding? "The relationship between our country’s comfort w/ mass caging & its depiction in popular culture seems more than coincidental. Media consumption is what we all have in common." 100% right: teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
One amazing part of this public defender's commentary are the real life examples of interactions w/ people in & outside the system. Across the spectrum of ideologies. Her mom to Queens DA. "Progressive" friends to court officers. How they all seem to agree.teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
Powerful: "I think about one of many times I was misidentified as a defendant in court. When a court officer screamed at me to get out of the first row where attorneys sit. Ultimately said: 'My bad. I thought you were a defendant.' He thought that was a reasonable explanation."
"In his mind, it was acceptable to scream at a person accused of a crime. That even I, a criminal defense attorney, wouldn’t object. When I replied, “It would’ve been unacceptable even if I were one,” he looked confused. I think about that confusion…" teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
"I think about the Queens district attorney, Melinda Katz, who declined to charge an officer who kneeled on the neck of my client, SirCarlyle Arnold, despite stating that she “supported" an end to the NYPD’s use of illegal choke holds & neck restraints." nbcnewyork.com/news/local/que…
"I think about how self-proclaimed progressives have asked me how I sleep at night representing guilty people. Not thinking about how people are profiled, arrested, & incarcerated for crimes that wouldn’t be crimes if they weren’t poor people of color."
nytimes.com/2017/07/21/nyr…
"I think about allies protesting police brutality tweeting about how no innocent person would not talk to police & only guilty people get a lawyer. We’re taught to fear & dislike those caught in the system, rather than a system that inflicts pain on them." teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
We all learn to worship police & incarceration early. "We are taught there are bad people who were just born bad, who do bad things, & that the only way to keep the good people safe is for police to do whatever they can to lock the bad people away."teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
"Law & Order has run for over 30 years, showing all manner of police violence, coerced confessions, & blatant violations of the law & a suspect’s rights. People not only watch faithfully, but root for the police & the prosecutor." It's so deeply engrained. teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
"We need to move away from the Law & Order mindset, which taught us to root for prosecutors & despise defendants. Assume anyone accused is guilty. See those who break the law as evil or cruel, rather than the society that accepts poverty & inequality."teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
THIS ALL DAY AND NIGHT: "It may sound daunting to reconceptualize & reevaluate our views of the criminal legal system & the people it targets & abuses in answer to an immediate crisis, but that work is critical for the greater task of systemic change." teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…
"Until our most basic intuitions about the criminal legal system change, the system itself will never change."

So how do we do this? The author of the above important commentary, Olayemi Olurin (@msolurin) offers some solutions.

First: read.
"Until our most basic intuitions about the criminal legal system change, the system itself will never change."

So how do we do this? "Scrutinize media coverage of the “justice” system & became more discerning consumers of "justice" news & culture. thenation.com/article/societ…
"Until our most basic intuitions about the criminal legal system change, the system itself will never change."

So how do we do this?

"Attending court & watching proceedings that are open to the public is critical for the greater task of systemic change."washingtonpost.com/local/public-s…
"Thousands of individuals — fathers, sisters, husbands, community members — are still languishing in Rikers’ cages because that is our societal status quo. For that to change, we must change first." Stop watching Law & Order now & forever & read this: teenvogue.com/story/law-and-…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Scott Hechinger

Scott Hechinger Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ScottHech

9 Dec
Right now there are 157 people infected w/ Covid in Chicago jail. A growing outbreak. Last year, a man died despite his wife calling 132 times. The spillover to communities esp Black & brown harms everyone. And beloved “progressive” sheriff Tom Dart calls this “success.” Outrage:
Meet Cassandra Greer-Lee. Public school teacher. Fierce advocate. Her husband called terrified of COVID outbreak in Chicago jail. “Is anyone surviving this?” She called *132 times* to try to get help. No response. Beloved sheriff Tom Dart calls his jail a “success.” More:
Nickolas Lee was unable to social distance in Cook County Jail in Chicago, like so many others throughout the country. Denied even basic sanitary precautions like soap and a mask, and caged in large groups with others who were symptomatic. His story:
Read 4 tweets
2 Dec
THREAD: This is about Compton, CA. About the choices we make as taxpayers. Whether to invest in families, in community, in health & safety. Or continue to throw billions away at police & incarceration that only harms. This thread is also about what you can do right now. Read on:
Compton, CA is an American cultural capital. And a city where glaring social inequities overlap. 30% of residents are Black, 68% are Latino. And incredibly, 1 in 5 are below the poverty line. Not enough money for medication, groceries, school, transportation, housing. The basics.
As families, children, & elderly struggle to survive, Compton taxpayers pay more per resident per geographic area to the Sheriff than any city in LA County. $22 million. All despite the harm of Compton Executioners: 1 of the Sheriff's violent deputy gangs.knock-la.com/lasd-gangs-lit…
Read 12 tweets
1 Dec
Right now, in real time, the top cop in Los Angeles (@LACoSheriff) is live & lying about “crime” being “up” when it’s down, police being “defunded” when their outrageously high budget has increased, & truth not mattering at all even when data is right there to prove him a liar.
Here is the Los Angeles top cop *lying* that police are being “defunded.” Again: that’s a lie. “The budget has continued to increase.” Did I mention the top LA cop is brazenly lying? And every knows it? Why isn’t this national news?
Here is the top cop in LA (@LACoSheriff) admitting there are *two* upcoming academies for new cops despite minutes earlier claiming that he’s been forced into a hiring freeze & he’s also being defunded. The lies are so brazen. He doesn’t care. He’ll get away with them.
Read 5 tweets
30 Nov
Thread: More problematic “crime” reporting. This time from @NPR. The very premise—man charged in Wisconsin parade killings is “poster boy for backlash against bail reform”—is only bc outlets like NPR promote the lie. Nothing to do w/ “bail reform.” More:npr.org/2021/11/25/105…
I ache for the victims in Wisconsin. Committed to finding solutions to avoid future tragedies like this one. Thats why I want to set record straight: There is no “bail reform” in Wisconsin. No significant change to bail laws in Wisconsin in a decade. Bail was set in this case.
NPR (& other outlets) even mentioning “bail reform” in context of deaths in Wisconsin is enough to generate the fear & anger to incentivize judges & prosecutors to cage way more at expense of law/reason. Lawmakers to pass harsher laws. Real bail stories:
Read 19 tweets
27 Nov
This is a breathless, sensationalist lie from a NYT reporter. NYPD has never come close to “solving” 90% of anything. And violent crime didn’t “spike.” All major crimes, save for homicides (still at historic lows), continued their 30+ year decline. Why are you doing this, Ali?
More on the story in the NYT in this important thread.
Look at the “spike” in violent crime Ali claims—contrary to all evidence & a simple Google search—exists.
Read 6 tweets
21 Nov
As a public defender, I represented literally hundreds of Black men & women accused of doing this. Most literally couldn’t afford $2.75 subway fare. Difference between eating/not. Arrested, caged, forced to plea to the crime of “theft of services.” But when you’re white & proud:
This year, NYC hired *500 more subway cops.* There were already 4000 NYPD in subway. $245 million/yr. They mostly target Black people for jumping the turnstile & attack. Fail to prevent crime. Instead of investing in free/affordable public transportation. gothamist.com/news/500-more-…
This is what subway policing normally looks like. NYPD surround woman selling churros. Crying. Telling her she stops or get arrested. Trying to talk to them in Spanish. Rolling their eyes. Lead out in cuffs. Cart taken away. This is police violence.
Read 20 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(