On 19 September 1918, General Allenby launched an offensive to break through Ottoman lines in northern Palestine, the Battle of Megiddo.
He was inspired by Thutmose III's conquest of Canaan, in which the pharaoh attacked from an unexpected direction in a battle of the same name.
The Jezreel Valley is a broad, fertile plain that runs through modern Israel, connected at the northwest via the Kishon River to the sea, and in the southeast to the Jordan. In ancient times, it sustained a large population and was an important center of political power.
In 1457 BC, Thutmose III marched out to quell a revolt by his Syrian and Canaanite vassals. They had massed their forces in the Jezreel, protected from the coastal plain to the south by the Mount Carmel range.
The rebels had concentrated around the strong hillfort of Megiddo, which guarded the southwestern edge of the valley. But they also sent out detachments to block the main approaches through the mountains.
There were two principal routes into the Jezreel. The easiest route ran east into the southern end of the valley; a more difficult route ran to the north.
But there was also a third route, wide enough for only one man to pass at a time, which led straight to Megiddo itself.
Thutmose’s scouts informed him that the central route was unguarded, so he took a gamble and took the more direct but more hazardous approach. He took the rebels completely by surprise, routed their army, stormed Megiddo, and subdued the region.
Thirty-four centuries later, Edmund Allenby found himself in a similar position as he pushed up from Egypt into Ottoman Palestine.
Geography is unchanging, and presents the same military difficulties across the ages. In this case: how to break through the Mount Carmel range.
Allenby realized that the key to success was cutting off the two defending armies from their headquarters at Nazareth. But the mountains of Palestine posed the same problem as the trenches of the Western Front: how to exploit the initial assault to break through?
The key to Nazareth lay in reaching the Jezreel Valley as quickly as possible. So as soon as the initial British assault broke through the Ottoman forces in the coastal plain, Allenby sent his cavalry through the same valley Thutmose took near Megiddo.
It was a brilliant success, and collapsed the entire Ottoman lines. The Seventh Army under Mustafa Kemal—the future Ataturk—was in an untenable position around Nablus and withdrew, yielding the entire Jordan Valley to the British and opening the road to Damascus.
There was very little fighting around Megiddo itself, but Allenby named the battle after that location because it played such an important role in his ultimate success. There was also another reason, however....
Geography is a constant throughout history, and the same factors that made Megiddo important to Thutmose III and Edmund Allenby have made it important to many others—there have been several battles of Megiddo. The battlefield was so important, in fact….
....that it was prophesied to be the site of the final apocalyptic battle in the Book of Revelations, where it is called Armageddon—“Har-Megiddo”. Allenby, not shy about burnishing his reputation, chose the name for its Biblical overtones.
A great discussion of Megiddo in the Bronze Age with @digkabri, the excavator of the site, in which he mentions Thutmose's influence on Allenby: pod.co/experts-in-his…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Years ago I ran into a friend in Helmand Province who was on an advisory team supporting the ANP. He told me about how one of the police chiefs was widely known to rape prisoners during interrogations. Been thinking a lot about the look on his face as he told me that.
His helplessness was understandable. Two years earlier a Green Beret beat the shit out of his Afghan counterpart for keeping a 12-year-old dancing boy chained to his bed...
....and he was almost kicked out of the Army for it. We were tacitly giving our moral endorsement to the worst people in Afghanistan. theolympian.com/news/local/mil…
How crop failures in the Soviet Union helped clean up the Great Lakes
In the early 1970s, Russia and the Ukraine had a series of bad harvests, putting the entire USSR at risk of famine. In 1972 the US government agreed to subsidize $300 million in sales of grain.
Soviet cargo ships sailed up the St. Lawrence waterway and into Lake Michigan, where they docked at Port of Indiana, a major transshipment point for Midwestern grain. This trade continued through the 70s and into the 80s.
At the time, the Great Lakes suffered from large algal blooms, owing to the nitrogen in agricultural runoff from the surrounding farmlands.
In 1182, Saladin launched a daring attack by land and sea on Beirut.
It was a sharp break from his usual raids into enemy territory and skirmishes with the Crusaders. But at a deeper level, it was part of a consistent strategy that ultimately brought him victory.
Thread
Beirut stands on a broad triangular promontory, which in Saladin’s time was covered with fields and orchards. The medieval city stood on its northern edge and was endowed with one of the finest harbors in the Levant.
Beirut was obviously an attractive target, but this was uncharacteristically bold for Saladin. This was not just a raid: it was an attempt to seize and hold ground in the middle of Crusader territory.
Why was the Hagia Sophia such an achievement? Not least because it was the world’s largest domed basilica for 1000 years.
Domes in turn helped deal with a very ancient problem in the Mediterranean: earthquakes.
Thread
Earthquakes have always been a fact of life in the seismically-active Mediterranean, occasionally collapsing buildings or even entire cities. Three of the Seven Wonders of the World, for instance, were destroyed by earthquakes.
Civilizations adapted: the Mycenaeans used large rough-hewn stones to construct their palaces—so-called Cyclopean architecture—which might have had an anti-earthquake function: gaps dampened the shock waves, and large stones could shift without the entire structure collapsing.
The First Thanksgiving in 1621 celebrated both the Pilgrims’ survival & their friendship with the Wampanoag Indians.
One Mayflower passenger was especially close to the Indians, and was one of only two to have visited the New World before: Stephen Hopkins.
In 1609, Hopkins was on the fateful Sea Venture expedition to the newly-founded Jamestown colony in Virginia to provide supplies and deliver a new governor. They hit a bad storm (possibly a hurricane) en route and were shipwrecked on Bermuda.
All aboard were saved and the island had plenty of food. The governor took charge and set the men to work gathering food, building shelters, and constructing pinnaces to sail to Virginia, where the other ships of the expedition had safely arrived.
Only the Ferrarese came remotely close, able to hold their own in extremely adverse circumstances and maintain their independence. Not least because they invested heavily in defenses and were great artillery innovators: