Scott Hamilton RTM Profile picture
Dec 10, 2021 32 tweets 9 min read Read on X
1/32 Brenton Tarrant's murder of Christchurch Muslims is infamous, but the massacre at Surafend is little-known. 103 years ago today, Anzacs killed between 40 and 120 Muslims in that Palestinian village. ImageImage
2/32 By December 1918 the Great War was over. The troops camped outside Surafend were waiting to go home. Most of them were part of the Anzac Mounted Division, which had fought at Gallipoli, then captured Sinai & Palestine from the Ottoman Empire. Image
3/32 On the night of December the 9th a man entered the tent of NZ soldier Leslie Lowry. Lowry had been using his kitbag as a pillow. The intruder grabbed it & fled. Lowry chased the thief across the dunes that separated the Anzac camp from Surafend. Image
4/32 The thief turned & fired a pistol. Lowry died in a medical tent three hours later. The next morning Anzacs found Lowry's blood in the sand, & footprints that led from the stain towards Surafend. Image
5/32 Members of Lowry's Machine Gun Squadron, which had been serving alongside the Anzac Mounted Rifles, recruited NZers & Australians for a raid on the village. At seven o'clock that night about two hundred Anzacs entered Surafend. They carried bayonets & pick handles. Image
6/32 The massacre took half an hour. Surafend's old men, women, & children were held under guard in a field outside the village. They saw their homes burning, & heard their young men screaming & dying. Image
7/32 According to NZ soldier Ted Andrews the Muslims were castrated before they were killed. Some corpses were thrown down the village's well. Image
8/32 Australian Ted O'Brien was one of the killers. In a tape recording made in 1988, he said he & his comrades had 'had a good issue of rum' & 'done their blocks'. They 'all went for' the Arabs with 'the bayonet'. Image
9/32 After they'd destroyed Surafend, the Anzacs raided a nearby camp of nomadic Bedouin people. They burned the camp down. By nine o'clock they were back in their tents. Image
10/32 Six days after the massacre General Edmund Allenby, the overall commander of British Empire forces in the Middle East, ordered the Anzac Mounted Division to parade. He called them 'cowards & murderers'. But no Anzac was ever brought to justice. Image
11/32 In letters, diary entries, & memoirs, the men of the Mounted Division tried to justify what happened at Surafend. They characterised the village's inhabitants, & Arabs in general, as savages who stole & killed.
12/32 Arabs were accused of stealing from Anzac camps, & also of robbing from Anzac corpses. Ted O'Brien called Bedouin 'wicked'. For NZer Percy Doherty they were 'inhuman brutes'. NZer, Herbert Wilke called the inhabitants of Surafend 'thieves generally'.
13/32 But Anzacs were guilt of the behaviour they condemned Arabs for. Ted O'Brien said that he & his comrades often robbed Ottoman corpses. O'Brien described killing a badly wounded Turk so he could take the man's possessions. 'It was a rob the dead sort of business' he said. Image
14/33 Arabs had reason to resent the Anzacs' presence in their lands. During the fight for Sinai, Egyptians had been conscripted into work gangs, & forced to dig trenches & help build railways for the Anzacs. Image
15/32 The Anzacs had interned Sinai Bedouin. The nomads were taken prisoner, & marched to improvised prisons by the Suez canal. Sometimes the Anzacs did not bother with internment. O'Brien said that he would shoot Bedouins 'on sight'. Image
16/32 Brenton Tarrant's massacre in Christchurch was motivated by his racism & his Islamophobia. There is evidence that the Anzacs who attacked Surafend had the same attitudes as Tarrant.
17/32 John Milnes wrote a thesis for the University of Otago about the NZ members of the Anzac Mounted Division. Milnes said that 'virtually every letter, book & diary' he read during his research had 'some reference to the Arabs reflecting NZers' racial views'.
18/32 Many Anzacs were children or grandchildren of men who'd fought wars against the indigenous peoples of Australia & Aotearoa. Massacres had been part of these wars. Sometimes the Anzacs made explicit links between the Arabs they encountered & the indigenous people back home Image
19/32 In 1923 Henry Gullett published the official history of the Australian military campaigns in Sinai & Palestine. Gullett wrote that the Bedouin the Anzacs met were 'scarcely higher in civilisation than the Australian blacks'.
20/32 Gullett explained the Surafend massacre as frustrated reaction to native barbarism. Similar excuses had been made for the mass killings of Aboriginals during the Frontier Wars.
21/32 In 1919 some of the Anzacs who had raided Surafend were sent to Egypt to help suppress a revolution. Angry at Britain's refusal to give them independence, Egyptians had staged a general strike & attacked colonial forts.
22/32 The NZers' accounts of their work in Egypt make their racial attitudes obvious. In a letter home, Percy Doherty said that he had 'flogged several hundred' Egyptian 'niggers'. Ted Andrews described bayoneting a 'huge, coal-black native' in the leg as 'he turned to run'. Image
23/32 Some Anzac soldiers seem also to have hated Islam, & to have considered their struggle with the Ottoman Empire a holy war. After the Ottomans declared war on Britain Istanbul's leading cleric had issued a call to jihad, urging Muslims in British colonies to revolt.
24/32 In Devils on Horses, his 2007 book about the Middle East Anzacs, Terry Kinloch argues that Britain was seriously concerned about the possibility of Muslim uprisings, especially after the Ottoman victory at Gallipoli. Image
25/32 NZers had their own theological justification for the war. Many, including Prime Minister William Massey, were believers in the British Israelite version of Christianity, which taught that Anglo-Saxons were a lost tribe of Israel & that the British Empire was sacred Image
26/32 When Anzacs invaded Palestine & captured Jerusalem, belief in a holy war & divine guidance was bolstered. Terry Kinloch reports that a NZ officer stopped his column at the border of Palestine, & offered a prayer of thanks to god for letting him enter the holy land.
27/32 But Islamophobia had existed in NZ before the war. In 1857 Muslims in India's colonial army rebelled; in the 1880s Sudanese rose up against the British under the leadership of a messianic Sufi. Image
28/32 Pakeha NZers were shocked & frightened by these Muslim challenges to British hegemony; in their minds Islam became associated with subversion & savagery. Image
29/32 By the 1890s Indians, Syrians & Lebanese were making livings selling food & clothing out of carts in NZ. The Syrians & Lebanese came from the Ottoman Empire; some were Muslims. Image
30/32 The mobile salesmen were known as hawkers, & were regarded with suspicion by newspapers & politicians. The hawkers were accused of ripping off customers & spreading disease. In 1896 parliament passed an Undesirable Hawkers Protection Act.
31/32 In their letters home, the Middle East Anzacs often complained about the traders they encountered in places like Jerusalem. They portrayed these traders as devious & dirty. There is a parallel between the Anzacs' complaints & the charges made against hawkers in NZ. Image
32/32 Most NZers & Australians do not know about the Surafend massacre. Our fascists, though, are very aware of the event. For the likes of Brenton Tarrant, Surafend is an inspiration & a model.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Scott Hamilton RTM

Scott Hamilton RTM Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SikotiHamiltonR

Dec 27, 2024
1/7 MAGA is melting down as the movement's lumpenproletarian base rages against tech bros' talk about American mediocrity & the superiority of migrant workers. I'm reminded of a story Tongan-based American sociologist Maikolo Horowitz told me about Trumpism. Image
2/7 Horowitz grew up in NYC's Trotskyist community; Allen Ginsberg was a playmate. Later he hung out with Warhol & Lou Reed & turned down a job managing the Velvets. He was too busy helping run legendary protest group Students for a Democratic Society. Image
3/7 He's spent most of the last 30 years in Tonga, & collaborated for many years with its great educationalist & philosopher Futa Helu. Horowitz used a memory of his SDS youth to illuminate the frustration & resentment that fuel MAGA. Image
Read 10 tweets
Nov 17, 2024
22/30 No one familiar with the history of Aotearoa in the 1840s could take the bill's claims seriously. One only has to read William Colenso's notes of the discussions in Waitangi to see the absurdity of the idea that Maori surrendered all claims to sovereignty in 1840. Image
23/30 No chief talked about giving up sovereignty. Rangatira talked obsessively about the chaos & land loss caused by Pakeha settlers in the north, & the need for Hobson to control his people. But Act's bill is not about history. It is about psychology. Image
24/30 By pretending that Maori entered into a mystical union with two thousand Pakeha settlers in 1840 Act has created a sort of origin myth & psychic balm for Pakeha conservatives still unwilling to face the fact of Maori difference, & still in denial about colonialism. Image
Read 17 tweets
Nov 17, 2024
1/30 Te Pati Maori's haka in parliament has been greeted with disgust, anger, & fear by many conservative Pakeha. Like Act's Treaty Principles Bill, this response to the haka is the expression of a massive, long-brewing identity crisis. Image
2/30 Since the 19thC Pakeha have shown an intense ambivalence towards Maori culture. Lacking a culture unique to these islands, we have alternately suppressed and appropriated Maoritanga. Image
3/30 During the wars of the 1860s Maori culture was dangerous. Wharenui were burned & wahi tapu systematically desecrated. By the end of the century, tho, Pakeha were turning to Maoritanga as they tried to define themselves. Image
Read 22 tweets
Sep 10, 2024
1/4 Act could help settle the debate about the Treaty of Waitangi by republishing & circulating this little book by William Colenso, which contains his detailed notes on the speeches Maori chiefs made at Waitangi in 1840. But the debate wouldn't be settled the way Act wants. Image
2/4 Act claims the chiefs inexplicably ceded their sovereignty to a handful of Brits at Waitangi, but anyone who reads Colenso's notes will notice that the chiefs never mention doing that. Nearly all the korero focuses on the problems caused by settlers in the north. Image
3/4 Riotous behaviour by some settlers & the alienation of land are themes. It is very hard indeed to read Colenso's notes & not feel that the pro-Treaty chiefs wanted to empower Hobson to govern the settlers, not the rest of Aotearoa. That's why many Pakeha disliked the Treaty. Image
Read 11 tweets
Aug 15, 2024
1/60 Martin Phillipps contained multitudes. He leaves an oeuvre that is vast & varied, & that can be interpreted in various ways. I see him as someone who extended & updated a distinctively Pakeha cultural tradition. Image
2/60 Like the music of Douglas Lilburn, the poems of Ruth Dallas, Charles Brasch & Allen Curnow, & the paintings of Bill Sutton & Rita Angus, many of Phillipps' best songs are powerful responses to the land & seascapes of southern NZ. Image
3/60 I'm not arguing that Phillipps was necessarily directly influenced by the names I've mentioned. He didn't need to be. He responds to the same landscape, is part of the same history, and dealt with the same dilemmas. Image
Read 55 tweets
Aug 5, 2024
1/3 Sean Plunket is promoting a 15 year old who gave a speech about Oswald Spengler's theory of the decline of the West. Since neither Plunket nor the kid seem to have bothered to read Spengler they won't be aware how silly they look. Spengler has some very bad news for them.
2/5 Plunket & his young protege are culture warriors, who think Western societies have been rotted by immigration & liberalism & transgender-friendly bathrooms & so on. They think a good dose of red steak conservatism can fix things. Spengler would shake his head in despair. Image
3/5 Spengler was one of many would-be prophets who emerged in the chaos of post-WW1 Germany to try to explain the collapse of its army & empire & the perceived crisis of modernity. His diagnosis was extremely gloomy. He argued all civilisations have the same basic course. Image
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(