1/32 Brenton Tarrant's murder of Christchurch Muslims is infamous, but the massacre at Surafend is little-known. 103 years ago today, Anzacs killed between 40 and 120 Muslims in that Palestinian village.
2/32 By December 1918 the Great War was over. The troops camped outside Surafend were waiting to go home. Most of them were part of the Anzac Mounted Division, which had fought at Gallipoli, then captured Sinai & Palestine from the Ottoman Empire.
3/32 On the night of December the 9th a man entered the tent of NZ soldier Leslie Lowry. Lowry had been using his kitbag as a pillow. The intruder grabbed it & fled. Lowry chased the thief across the dunes that separated the Anzac camp from Surafend.
4/32 The thief turned & fired a pistol. Lowry died in a medical tent three hours later. The next morning Anzacs found Lowry's blood in the sand, & footprints that led from the stain towards Surafend.
5/32 Members of Lowry's Machine Gun Squadron, which had been serving alongside the Anzac Mounted Rifles, recruited NZers & Australians for a raid on the village. At seven o'clock that night about two hundred Anzacs entered Surafend. They carried bayonets & pick handles.
6/32 The massacre took half an hour. Surafend's old men, women, & children were held under guard in a field outside the village. They saw their homes burning, & heard their young men screaming & dying.
7/32 According to NZ soldier Ted Andrews the Muslims were castrated before they were killed. Some corpses were thrown down the village's well.
8/32 Australian Ted O'Brien was one of the killers. In a tape recording made in 1988, he said he & his comrades had 'had a good issue of rum' & 'done their blocks'. They 'all went for' the Arabs with 'the bayonet'.
9/32 After they'd destroyed Surafend, the Anzacs raided a nearby camp of nomadic Bedouin people. They burned the camp down. By nine o'clock they were back in their tents.
10/32 Six days after the massacre General Edmund Allenby, the overall commander of British Empire forces in the Middle East, ordered the Anzac Mounted Division to parade. He called them 'cowards & murderers'. But no Anzac was ever brought to justice.
11/32 In letters, diary entries, & memoirs, the men of the Mounted Division tried to justify what happened at Surafend. They characterised the village's inhabitants, & Arabs in general, as savages who stole & killed.
12/32 Arabs were accused of stealing from Anzac camps, & also of robbing from Anzac corpses. Ted O'Brien called Bedouin 'wicked'. For NZer Percy Doherty they were 'inhuman brutes'. NZer, Herbert Wilke called the inhabitants of Surafend 'thieves generally'.
13/32 But Anzacs were guilt of the behaviour they condemned Arabs for. Ted O'Brien said that he & his comrades often robbed Ottoman corpses. O'Brien described killing a badly wounded Turk so he could take the man's possessions. 'It was a rob the dead sort of business' he said.
14/33 Arabs had reason to resent the Anzacs' presence in their lands. During the fight for Sinai, Egyptians had been conscripted into work gangs, & forced to dig trenches & help build railways for the Anzacs.
15/32 The Anzacs had interned Sinai Bedouin. The nomads were taken prisoner, & marched to improvised prisons by the Suez canal. Sometimes the Anzacs did not bother with internment. O'Brien said that he would shoot Bedouins 'on sight'.
16/32 Brenton Tarrant's massacre in Christchurch was motivated by his racism & his Islamophobia. There is evidence that the Anzacs who attacked Surafend had the same attitudes as Tarrant.
17/32 John Milnes wrote a thesis for the University of Otago about the NZ members of the Anzac Mounted Division. Milnes said that 'virtually every letter, book & diary' he read during his research had 'some reference to the Arabs reflecting NZers' racial views'.
18/32 Many Anzacs were children or grandchildren of men who'd fought wars against the indigenous peoples of Australia & Aotearoa. Massacres had been part of these wars. Sometimes the Anzacs made explicit links between the Arabs they encountered & the indigenous people back home
19/32 In 1923 Henry Gullett published the official history of the Australian military campaigns in Sinai & Palestine. Gullett wrote that the Bedouin the Anzacs met were 'scarcely higher in civilisation than the Australian blacks'.
20/32 Gullett explained the Surafend massacre as frustrated reaction to native barbarism. Similar excuses had been made for the mass killings of Aboriginals during the Frontier Wars.
21/32 In 1919 some of the Anzacs who had raided Surafend were sent to Egypt to help suppress a revolution. Angry at Britain's refusal to give them independence, Egyptians had staged a general strike & attacked colonial forts.
22/32 The NZers' accounts of their work in Egypt make their racial attitudes obvious. In a letter home, Percy Doherty said that he had 'flogged several hundred' Egyptian 'niggers'. Ted Andrews described bayoneting a 'huge, coal-black native' in the leg as 'he turned to run'.
23/32 Some Anzac soldiers seem also to have hated Islam, & to have considered their struggle with the Ottoman Empire a holy war. After the Ottomans declared war on Britain Istanbul's leading cleric had issued a call to jihad, urging Muslims in British colonies to revolt.
24/32 In Devils on Horses, his 2007 book about the Middle East Anzacs, Terry Kinloch argues that Britain was seriously concerned about the possibility of Muslim uprisings, especially after the Ottoman victory at Gallipoli.
25/32 NZers had their own theological justification for the war. Many, including Prime Minister William Massey, were believers in the British Israelite version of Christianity, which taught that Anglo-Saxons were a lost tribe of Israel & that the British Empire was sacred
26/32 When Anzacs invaded Palestine & captured Jerusalem, belief in a holy war & divine guidance was bolstered. Terry Kinloch reports that a NZ officer stopped his column at the border of Palestine, & offered a prayer of thanks to god for letting him enter the holy land.
27/32 But Islamophobia had existed in NZ before the war. In 1857 Muslims in India's colonial army rebelled; in the 1880s Sudanese rose up against the British under the leadership of a messianic Sufi.
28/32 Pakeha NZers were shocked & frightened by these Muslim challenges to British hegemony; in their minds Islam became associated with subversion & savagery.
29/32 By the 1890s Indians, Syrians & Lebanese were making livings selling food & clothing out of carts in NZ. The Syrians & Lebanese came from the Ottoman Empire; some were Muslims.
30/32 The mobile salesmen were known as hawkers, & were regarded with suspicion by newspapers & politicians. The hawkers were accused of ripping off customers & spreading disease. In 1896 parliament passed an Undesirable Hawkers Protection Act.
31/32 In their letters home, the Middle East Anzacs often complained about the traders they encountered in places like Jerusalem. They portrayed these traders as devious & dirty. There is a parallel between the Anzacs' complaints & the charges made against hawkers in NZ.
32/32 Most NZers & Australians do not know about the Surafend massacre. Our fascists, though, are very aware of the event. For the likes of Brenton Tarrant, Surafend is an inspiration & a model.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/7 I don't like either the CCP or Solomons leader Manasseh Sogavare, but the outrage that the Australasian defence establishment is expressing over the Solomons' deal with China is troubling. My mind goes back to a war game NZ played in 2018.
2/7 The 2018 exercise was held with Vanuatu, & involved NZ forces landing on the island of Epi to end an imaginary breakdown in law & order there. Australian forces have held similar exercises in the Pacific.
3/7 I wonder whether the Australasian militaries have really been planning for an intervention to force regime change on an island nation that is behaving in ways that threaten Western interests. If that idea sounds far-fetched, consider events in Timor Leste in 2006.
1/4 There are now two European leaders pursuing policies that could lead to genocide. Besides Putin, we have Boris Johnson, who has announced an extraordinarily reckless scheme to send refugees in the UK to Rwanda. It's worth pondering some facts about that country.
2/4 Rwanda is one of the most crowded nations on earth, with 525 people for each square kilometre of its territory. Rwanda's 1994 genocide is explained as the result of hatred between its two main ethnic groups, Tutsi & Hutu, but it was also motivated by land shortages.
3/4 Rwanda's pygmy population, which posed no threat to Hutus, was decimated in the genocide. & in the district of Kamana, where only a single Tutsi lived, thousands of lives were taken. Land hunger motivated many killings.
1/9 Like Chris Trotter on the other side of the political spectrum, Nats pollster David Farrar is succumbing to hysterical extremism. In new blogposts Farrar has damned Rotorua's new electoral system as an attack on democracy unparalleled in NZ history, & warned of civil war.
2/9 Farrar's upset because Maori may be over-represented by the seats reserved for them on Rotorua's council. I don't know enough to comment on Rotorua's system, but I think Farrar would calm down if he knew about the way Maori were excluded for decades from NZ politics.
3/9 When settlers established a parliament in 1853, they contrived to exclude almost all Maori, the great majority of the population, from voting. Because they owned land collectively, Maori did not meet the wealth requirements for voters.
1/7 My wife is obsessed with blood. She spends a lot of her spare time discovering the genealogies of friends & acquaintances. Sometimes her work leads to teary reunions; sometimes, unfortunately, it causes trouble. I've urged her to take on the Clarionettes.
2/7 In 1900 200 socialists, followers of William Ranstead & his journal The Clarion, left the UK for NZ. On ships out they upset other passengers by refusing to join in prayers & rise for the national anthem. They apparently sang 'The Red Flag' instead of 'God Save the Queen'.
3/7 The Clarionettes landed in Canterbury, with the intention of scouting out land for a socialist commune. But as the search went on, migrants got jobs & entered mainstream society. Some of them helped formed NZ's Socialist Party.
1/10 Every Anzac Day Hamiltonians gather at the city's Memorial Park. But their gathering is an exercise in forgetfulness, as much as remembrance. Because the now-embarrassing early history of the Anzacs has been repressed, Memorial Park's intended function & meaning are lost.
2/10 Memorial Park was established after World War One, to remember the war & to provide a site for Anzac services. The city's leaders very deliberately located the park at the place on the Waikato River where the first white troops landed during the Waikato War.
3/10 The troops were delivered by a warship called the Rangiriri in 1864. Their job was to take control of the Maori kainga of Kirikiriroa & to establish fortifications. The town of Hamilton grew from this landing. Many of its early inhabitants were Australian soldier-settlers.
1/6 Auckland Council has produced a list of sites in the city where Anzac Day can be commemorated. As usual, tho, the council has neglected to name the historic but politically awkward memorials to the very first Anzacs, who fought in a racist war in NZ.
2/6 At St John's church in Drury an obelisk remembers the very first Anzacs to fall in battle. They were Australian volunteers who joined Pakeha & British in the invasion of the Waikato in 1863. The men buried at Drury died near Mauku, after an ambush by King Tawhiao's forces.
3/6 Australians played a vital role in the conquest of the Waikato. Colonial politicians & newspapers praised them. When Australians & NZers fought together in the Boer War & at Gallipoli, the 1863 campaign was cited as a precedent.