To me, the problem with the idea any intervention can take the web back to its "idealist origins" is that most of humanity and its various institutions and other units of organization are not "idealist". So social and power dynamics will always win. @mims wsj.com/articles/jack-…
We may pray that less platform centralization will reduce some of the externalities of the model we have now, but that's mostly faith- religion for some- driven by memories of a time when most people and organizations weren't online.
Don't take this as negativity on web3 per se- but it's not just the protocol that's broken. It's that we rebuilt all of the structural problems we have in the real world and then some on the web, with almost zero protections for those harmed.
I'm not convinced we are working hard enough to avoid doing that again. Instead it's mostly gold rush behavior again, Valley mentality trying to reassert itself as potentially a net positive. What we really need is laws.
Such a good kicker, by the way, @mims. That last line...
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Last week a deadly tornado hit an Amazon warehouse in Edwardsville, Illinois. The tragedy points to the ongoing plight of all Amazon workers, and puts a particular focus on the contract and gig workers who have fewer workplace protections, writes @denrsch: techpolicy.press/amazon-workers…
@denrsch "A substantial percentage of the workers at Edwardsville and in many other Amazon facilities– particularly at the peak of the holiday season– are contractors, which means they have fewer workplace protections." techpolicy.press/amazon-workers…
"The contract for gig work typically looks more like a 'terms and service' agreement than an agreement between an employer seeking a stable relationship with a healthy team and a worker." techpolicy.press/amazon-workers…
"On Nov. 9, two days after The Associated Press called the race for Mr. Biden, crisis meetings were underway at Trump campaign headquarters in Arlington, Va." The comms strategy was set.
"... it’s significant that Meta, Facebook’s parent company, recently wrote to the Los Angeles Police Department demanding that its officers cease the use of Facebook for surveillance and signaling stronger measures in the future." techpolicy.press/meta-fires-a-w…
"Meta’s letter to the LAPD affirmed that the use of fake accounts violates its terms of service. The company also demanded more generally that the LAPD cease collection of data for surveillance purposes." techpolicy.press/meta-fires-a-w…
"...we believe that the consequence of color-blindness is a set of political policies that threaten democratic inclusion." techpolicy.press/the-need-for-r…
"Adapting this race-conscious standard for content moderation would require platforms to pay extra scrutiny to content that has the potential for disproportionate harms to racial and ethnic groups based on historical and structural forms of discrimination and power in the US."