This alliance is frankly negligible. The wider organised elements of the western left have no interest in confronting these elements from within. The vast majority are not only willing to ignore the campists, many are more than happy to continue to organise alongside their allies
Speaking from experience, even people I have known for a decade on the left can’t be bothered to disinvite full blown war crimes revisionists as podcast guests, people I know disagree on these topics in private.
In public thought it’s all fart noises, shitposts and pretending that these people either don’t exist or exist so far on the peripheries that nobody considers them relevant. 5 minutes later they’ll retweet someone whose main sidegig is calling dead Syrian kids crisis actors.
Ask yourself why unrepentant Bosnian genocide revisionist Noam Chomsky is still the left’s favourite academic and get back to me when you have an answer. I wish this broad left anti-tankie coalition existed, but as I said, in organised left spaces, that alliance is negligible.
In Britain at least, it’s *near impossible* to find an explicitly left wing media organisation that hasn’t at least dabbled in a little light revisionism over the last decade. Corbynism went even further by promoting a handful of these cranks to senior political roles.
That’s not to say the right wing press is any better, but in a discussion about left wing war crimes apologism, let’s be totally frank, there are almost no clean hands on the far left, and most of those with clean hands do next to nothing to confront their allies on these issues.
Anyway here’s the cofounder of Novara Media publicly defending Max Blumenthal’s Uighur genocide revisionism. How does this continue to happen if the western left is building an alliance against this? Nobody is speaking out against this, let’s be honest.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Every couple months Tony Blair trends on Twitter after saying something that isn’t even remotely wrong or controversial and the whole site just erupts with “shut up Tony we don’t want to hear anything from you”
Don’t get me wrong I’m very much in the “Blair is bad and should please stop doing so many interviews” camp but I don’t quite see the point in the constant rage, particularly when he’s saying something the vast majority of people criticising him agree with 🤷🏽♂️
I remember he said something pretty sensible about the vaccines once and people dragged him for like 48 hours and then 2 weeks later SAGE agreed with him and everyone just memory holed it like they always do.
He wrote a blog complaining about liberal media, that's all he ever does. That's all they ever do. Often while half the people they complain about spend a significant amount of their wages on humanitarian efforts & use their platform for political pressure
Liberal media figures aren't perfect and certainly aren't free from criticism, but many of them have actually been on the ground in the places these bloggers would never even bother to visit. Many of them are involved in serious aid efforts outside of their careers.
Witnessing human suffering on that scale first hand changes you forever, none of us walk away from this without lasting and permanent damage. Most of us owe our lives to a local fixer at least once in our career. Believe me, we never forget that.
Here is how Britain’s head of state marked the funeral of the man she had been married to for 73 years. It might not seem immediately obvious in the reaction to news that the Prime Minister was throwing parties at Number 10 during that period, but I have a feeling this matters.
It’s one rule for them, and another for everyone else. This government is not only inhumane, incompetent and corrupt, they are also laughing at you while doing all this. They aren’t even laughing behind your back, they are doing it in your face.
When this photo was taken, it sent a powerful message to the country. We were all in this together. In reality, the government were breaking their own laws and then laughing about it. Many of you couldn’t even attend funerals of loved ones. You are right to be angry.
This is a common tactic, because “actually our critics are the racist ones” was the one of the most common responses to Labour’s antisemitism crisis. When it could no longer be denied by reasonable people, this was the only option left for these cranks to assert authority.
I was repeatedly subjected to vile Islamophobic harassment by pro-Corbyn trolls throughout 2015-2019. If I hadn’t blocked over 20,000 accounts over those years I would likely still be subjected to it on a daily basis.
They weren’t just satisfied smearing me as racist, they wanted people to believe I was an Islamist fundamentalist and a terrorist. This eventually culminated with me receiving a phone call from British anti-terrorism police.
As I understand it, Stop The War Coalition held a pro-Beijing rally in London yesterday at which attendants physically assaulted counter protestors, there seems to be no wider coverage of this on the wider British left today, but it seems like a significant & alarming development
Also highly alarming that former shadow chancellor John McDonnell was a listed speaker at this event, given that Diane Abbott has already had to issue an apology for appearing on an online panel hosted by this pro-CCP front.
They will never understand how badly they lost and will always blame everyone else for their own failures. They won’t even accept culpability for the racism that was exposed by a statutory investigation into their control of the party.
Corbynites can never move on because they can live in a fantasy world in which they never have to acknowledge how humiliatingly unpopular & divisive their leader was. Always easier to blame your opponents than concede you were wrong, but it’s a mass delusion nevertheless.
Zarb-Cousin won’t ever show you stuff like this because he’s a moral coward but the public have very clear feelings on the man and that has precisely nothing to do with “the Labour right”. This is their own failure.