The so called patriots from Bollywood have lot to answer actually for the sins of their father, grandfather or great grandfathers.
We can start with Kaifi azmi, father of Shabana Azmi. He wrote poems celebrating the creation of Pakistan. #Naseer#ShabanaAzmi
Kaifi Azmi was a proponent of partition and wrote a poem just before Partition " अगली ईद पाकिस्तान में" (Next Eid in Pakistan). What a pity, went and came back within few days. Stayed here and now his children give us gyan on how much their parents loved india, didn't go
IPTA (Indian People's Theatre Association) was & remains the cultural front of Communist Party . Check Shabana Azmi and she is an active proponent of IPTA. It was under the communist ideology that Writers like Kaifi and even Shahir Ludhianvi supported created of pakistan..
Shahir in fact lived in Pakistan for about 6-7 months and pleaded with Indian govt to allow him back and lived here. Though people like Kaifi, Shahir and Naser's father (another muslim league member) were writing poems and giving speeches in favour of 'New Medina'
Javed Akhtar's Great grandfather Maulana Fazle Haq Khairabadi, gave a Fatwa to capture and bring down Hanuman gari temple in 1855.. British actually saved the temple.
Khairabadi instigated others to die for Jihad, he himself led a lavish luxurious life and never even saw a battlefield.Muslims tried to forcibly take the temple were killed by Hindus & kharabadi issued a Jihad call against British. For which he was captured and sent to Kala pani
He kept on pleading loyalty to British post 1857 and blamed some other Khairabadi. Jaan hisar Akhtar's father (Javed's) grandfather pleaded and British relented in exchange of loyalty.
Now come to Naseeruddin Shah's family. His great grandfather Jan-Fishan Khan, supported the british in 1857, got a Jagir in Sardhana and pension of 1000. his father, Aley Mohd shah, was a Muslim league member, Behraich. UP. Voted for Pakistan , wanted to open a restaurant in Eng
Just didn't go anywhere .. stayed here and now he gives gyan to us about the deep love his family has for India. True that he is not answerable for his father but he can't invoke his father as well for staying here. Muslims of UP/Maha/TN/Kerala/Bihar voted for Pakistan..
They just didn't go. Now take another case of Majruh Sultanpuri. He too wrote poems on greatness of Pakistan and stayed put here..
Javed Akhtar's grandfather : Hindus are wretched beasts..
Very few of these scumbags including their leadership left for Pakistan.. Even those who left kept a part of family in India & few more like Raja Mahmudabad came back in old age to claim property in UP (Case ongoing). He funded Jinnah (His mama).
This case was finally settled and @narendramodi govt amended the enemy property act to save the property. Congress was all set to give them the property.
The term Ideology of Pakistan was first used in 1971 by Major General Sher Ali khan Patuadi Yahya khans information minister.
Do you know who is this Pataudi? Yes Uncle of Saif Ali Khan Patuadi.. Why did saif's grandfather stay here? Property was too huge here
Saif's great uncle Mjr Gn. Isfandyar Ali Khan Pataudi was Deputy Director of ISI. Another great great uncle Mjr Gn. Sher Ali Pataudi was Chief of General Staff in Pak army, another great uncle Shehryar Ali Patuadi was PCB chairman.
It was a well thought out stay
Idea was to infiltrate the politics and make changes conducive to pakistan and capture from within and some were simply too lazy to go..
People who wanted Pakistan, UP/ Bihar/ Maha/ TN, Kerala,MP didnt go and who didn't want Punjab and NWFP (pathans) got it.
Muslims of Hyderabad anyway thought that they will have a separate country and Nawab gave 150cr to pakistan in 1947 for helping them.. put it in a bank in London.. Owaisi's father was a Razakar.. now he gives gyan on how much he loves India
Coming to Shahrukh khan .. Nice guy no doubt but his mother was adopted by Shah Nawaz Khan an officer in INA was a Minister under Lal B Shastri during the 1965 war, while his son Mahmud was fighting for Flag of Pakistan as a commissioned Officer.
Nothing to add on Dilip kumar's love for Pakistan here. Only Salman is one who refused to campaign and appear for donations for Imran Khan's hospital saying, "I will do it only if you help my country establish a hospital.."
Imran refused and so did Salman
Baaki aadhe se jyada to kothon par tabalchi the...aaj gyan pelte hain
Syed Hossain Imam from Bihar, M. Mohd. Ismail from Madras, etc..to name a few of the host of Muslim League leaders,stayed back in India
The Raja of Mahamudabad, Begum Aizaz Rasul, Raja of Pirpur, Maulana Hasrat Mohani, etc. from U.P didn't go and their descendants give gyan here
Though they had created Pak as the homeland for the Indian Muslims..not an iota of justification for such leaders being allowed. Congress abandoned the true nationalist Muslims, the Khudai Khidmatgars led by the Frontier Gandhi in name of geo-political realities.
Thes people wanted to wub negotiate with the world power for future of Indian Muslims and also about Future of Islam.Sub continent muslims were always at the forefront of the Middle East politics during WWI crumbling of the Caliphate.The sense of loss was recognized by Churchill
Ironically, Latifi,who was one of the architects of pak and a passionate supporter of Pakistan’s creation, did not move to new country. Yes same Rampur of Azam Khan fame,launched a agitation by setting on fire Govt buildings demanding accession of the Rampur State to Pak
Hafizur Rahman (of Jamiat-ul-ulema-e-Hind) etc. at the Lucknow conference of Mussalman.i.Hind'l (Dec. 1947)..League leaders of Rampur. In 1947 they had no idea India wud grow strong as 1 nation.Nehru must be commended.1 of the motive also was to hv a Muslim head of state
and that is the reason these people smartly stayed back to undermine and conquer by having muslim PM overtime.
You know the biggest crook who wrote the manifesto of muslim league (used by Jinnah in 1945-46), ideologue of Pakistan continued to practice in Mumbai high court and never went to Pakistan..
How was he even allowed to stay in this country and practice. His contribution to Pakistan is even greater than Iqbal’s yet he never went. I did a thread on him
I keep on asking, if you were so invested in creating a homeland for Muslims in Pakistan and wrote manifesto, ideological reasons and merging it with spiritual messages of Iqbal and Jinnah quotes you, yet you don’t go but stay in land you hate and want to get rid of?
I don’t see coincidence in all this, I see a sinister motive.. As Sardar Patel said in Kolkata 1949, “till yesterday you wanted Pakistan, voted for it and now you claim to love india, how do I believe you..?”
By the way Latiffi, the ideologue of Pakistan, lived in a flat given by Khushwant Singh’s father in 50’s and then found his place. Died in Delhi, never went to Pakistan after creating it.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The Barbarian's defining trait is his belief that he can enjoy the benefits of civilization without contributing to their maintenance. He consumes what has been painstakingly developed over generations but doesn't understand the effort & discipline required to create these goods.
He finds discipline irrational and resents the presence of priests and soldiers, not comprehending their roles in maintaining civilization. The Barbarian is characterized by his inability to create; he can obscure and destroy, but he cannot sustain.
This has always been true of every Barbarian during the decline or threat to any civilization.
We observe the Barbarian without fear during long periods of peace. We find his irreverence amusing & refreshing, as he challenges our established beliefs & certainties, & we laugh.
In his book My Experiences in Manipur and the Naga Hills, the Late Major-General Sir James Johnstone has written about the massive migration of Kukis into the sparsely-populated hill tracts of Manipur beginning from the year 1845 onwards.../1
The enormity of their migration can be gauged from the fact that during the period 1851-52, a huge chunk of 8000 Kukis had moved into the Zeme Naga-inhabited areas of the North Cachar hills of Assam.../2
By the year 1860, a Kuki colony of 1,356 inhabitants had come up in seven villages of this region in Assam. In 1866, 500 Kuki immigrants from Manipur had settled down in North Cachar../3
Sherbir have been kind to put the text about India being a union of states. What he has missed is the context. Laws and statues are always qualified to be implemented in certain circumstances or context, leaving a room for using reason, rationale.
So here is the context../1
The federation is a Union,because it is indestructible. Though the country & people may be divided into different States for convenience of administration, the country is one integrated whole,its people a single people, living under a single imperium derived from a single source.
- Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly.
Operative word dear Sherbir are "divided into different states for Convenience of administration...".
Also,other than Junagarh wherein people voted to be part of India, ppl simply had no agency.
Union can reorganise states at will..
Supreme court is changing constitution without parliamentary approvals. Want to sit on appointment of statutory and constitutional bodies just like themselves.
I have no hopes of any pushback from @PMOIndia@narendramodi on this blatant stealing of parliamentary privilege.
May be @narendramodi ji can invoke some courage reading this
“Within limits no judge and no Supreme Court can make itself a third chamber. No Supreme Court and no judiciary can stand in judgment over the sovereign will of Parliament".
--Pt Nehru (In Constituent Assembly)
I have zero hopes. We are truly a banana republic wherein will of the people is trampled everyday as elected representatives ( in their chicanery, guilt or ignorance) don't measure upto what is required of them by law laid down
This whole argument is a newly manufactured recently by Madani and gang.
a. Over 99% of muslims voted for Pakistan in 1946
b. They forfeited any right to live in India
c. Oldest book in the world is Rigveda as the whole world accepts that. It mentions no Adam or Muslims.
These crooks are scared about coming tsunami of muslim women leaving islam in droves. so will many educated rational, learned muslims who are ashamed of crazy needs of even reporting a rape-needs 4 witness to prove rape.. halala & what not..Think of daughter raped and her father
These crooks and rascals voted for pakistan yet stayed in India. Congress allowed even Latifi (Ideologue of Muslim league) to stay in India post partition. he stayed at home of Khuswant singh.
All this bull crap of Adam and all is copied from old testament..Rigveda has none
Which part of North India does this gentleman live in but our family came down from Jammu to fight alongside them against Abdali.
Nation needs protection , thus a standing army that needs to be paid. How do you pay for it now? Taxation.. Chauth was mere 25% while we pay 34% now.
Most of North Indian rulers had given up fighting mughals save for Mewar, were happy to enjoy life under protection. Obviously they felt bad for having to pay Chauth, in order to sustain an army, to Maratha empire as they had made peace with mughals..
Refuse a tax now? Try it.
Most of these Rajas were happy to serve the British interests post Marathas as they had lost zeal to fight. Simply collected taxes, paid share to British, enjoyed life in wine and shikar.
Brahmin Peshwa descendents had Zero wealth despite fighting for Bharat for a century.