The three Pennsylvania police officers who killed 8-year-old Fanta Bility outside a high school football game in August have been charged with manslaughter.and reckless endangerment.
The first degree murder charges against two teenagers charged in the shooting have been dropped.
The officers, Devon Smith, Sean Dolan and Brian Devaney, fired a barrage of shots into the large crowd after they say they heard gunfire.
Blocks away two Black teenagers were engaged in an altercation, during which a gun was allegedly shot. nytimes.com/2022/01/18/us/…
There was never any question that it was one of the cop's guns that had killed Fanta, but the DA charged the two Black teenagers with first degree murder.
It was unclear how they could ever prove this charge since first degree murder requires intent. inquirer.com/news/angelo-fo…
The reason the two teenagers were charged tho is more obvious - they're Black teenagers.
Maybe more critical - the neighborhood in which this happened, Sharon Hill is 75% Black. The crowd at that football game was almost all Black.
Would those cops have fired indiscriminately into that crowd if the people were White?
The lives of everyone involved here were disposable to the police and the DA: the victims (people other than Fanta, including her sister, were shot and injured) and the teenage boys they charged with her murder.
And let's not get too excited. The cops in this case have been charged on the recommendation of a grand jury.
They haven't been indicted. They are out on unsecured bond. If they are prosecuted it will be by the same DA who charged two teenagers with first degree murder.
The DA muddied the waters by charging the teenagers first if this case does go to trial.
The charging of these cops now is barely a blip in the national media or on social media. The case was never high profile nationally. I won't be surprised when the charges are dismissed.
See this is one of the most astounding things about the case - it wasn't under a felony murder theory (which is usually second degree murder here). It was first degree intentional murder.
Ernest Thomas, Samuel Shepherd, Charles Greenlee and Walter Irvin were aged between 16 and 26 when Norma Padgett, a 17-year-old White woman, accused them of rape.
Samuel Shepherd and Walter Irvin were veterans of WW2 and had continued to wear their uniforms when they returned to the US.
(African American veterans were frequent targets for lynchings - a reminder their service did not affect their status at home.) npr.org/2018/09/20/649…
Black people are often excluded from jump because jury pools are usually drawn from lists of registered voters (felony disenfranchisement laws mean in some states as many as 10 to 20% of Black people can't vote) and DMV records (Black people have lower rates of car ownership).
This obviously affects people from more disadvantaged socioeconomic advantage regardless of race.
Yes homicides increased in 2020, compared to 2019. They did not double, nowhere near it. That's not surprising. We were in the middle of an unprecedented global pandemic.
A more relevant statistic: over the last 28 years, homicides in the Bronx have decreased 80%.
If you read my timeline you know how I feel about Kyle Rittenhouse, so please believe me when I tell you it does not matter legally that he "crossed state lines."
I represent people who live in other jurisdictions and are charged with crimes in NYC all the time, including serious felonies. It does not matter.
This is a state case.
Crossing state lines is one basis under which federal prosecutors get jurisdiction, but its limited to certain cases - like sex trafficking or conspiracy - it doesn't just mean you live in one state and go to another to commit a crime.
When video leaked of the in-custody death of Eric Lurry, the DA declined to charge the cops shown sticking a baton down his throat and slapping him before he became unconscious.
Now, the local police union has determined that Sergeant Esqueda leaking the video constitutes "conduct that is detrimental to the orderly operation of the Association" and is "so reprehensible" as to warrant removal from the organization. So he's out. shawlocal.com/the-herald-new…
Just because the judge in the Kyle Rittenhouse trial may in fact be a villain, do not allow the prosecutor to play the role of "tragic hero."
When Kyle Rittenhouse is acquitted, do not let the DA spin this like they fought the good fight cause they didn't.nytimes.com/2021/11/11/us/…
First, let's remember who we are dealing with. This is the Kenosha County DA's office.
The same DA's office who refused to bring charges against the police officer, Rusten Sheskey, who shot Jacob Blake in the back seven times, paralyzing him. apnews.com/article/kyle-r…
Jacob Blake is the whole reason this trial is happening and somehow the Kenosha County DA left him out of the equation.