"As we contemplate a Russian invasion of Ukraine, let us begin from the people who are most concerned, the Ukrainians, and with what they have to lose." snyder.substack.com/p/king-of-ukra…
Part 3 of "King of Ukraine" – "In the early twentieth century, both Poland and Ukraine were realms of the imagination, neighbors divided not so much by lines on maps as by class resentments." snyder.substack.com/p/king-of-ukra…
Part 4: By 1918 Kyiv had long been a colony of other powers. Mongol riders watered their horses in the Dnipro; Polish kings notched the city's golden gates with their swords. Cossacks rallied to take the city but an alliance w/ Moscow proved their undoing snyder.substack.com/p/king-of-ukra…
Part 5 of "King of Ukraine": Wilhelm lived "a life in which he was either undercover or on magazine covers, of alternating secrecy and celebrity." snyder.substack.com/p/king-of-ukra…
Part 6: This "history is particular, but the lesson is general. To be born in a time and place is not to join a national destiny. Independence must be declared again and again, generation after generation, individual by individual." snyder.substack.com/p/king-of-ukra…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/7. Right-wing justices postulate Trump's "immunity." The objection is that this makes him a king. Not so. It's much worse.
2/7. A king can be subject to law. Even George III was subject to law. The American Revolution was justified by the notion that he had overstepped the law.
3/7. This discussion of immunity is something else. The justices are not discussing any constitutional system at all, including a constitutional monarchy.
Biden and NYT. The problem with this very helpful report is that it implicitly reinforces the two-sides-to-each-story framing that is the underlying problem. 1/4
The real story is democracy, and the real question for NYT and everyone else is whether that framing is dominant. Some great reporting there, but general failure on the framing. 2/4
As a citizen, I couldn't care less who in the White House and who in the NYT has hurt feelings. I do care about who is doing their job well. The Biden administration, with mistakes of course, has done that. 3/4
1/3. Respect for the 101 Republicans who voted their conscience on Ukraine aid despite all the propaganda and pressure.
2/3. Pride in the 210 Democrats who voted yes (without a single no vote) on aid to Ukraine.
3/3. Appreciation for all the Members (@jamie_raskin, @jasmineforus, my own Rep. @rosadelauro, so many others) who could see and articulate Ukraine as an issue of justice.
3/6. Russian propagandists say they expect Johnson's visit to Trump this weekend to kill Ukraine aid once again. We shall see. There's a new nervous vibe here.