Touching piece. It's sad but vaccines and masking have become anchored to a culture war where people feel glee about misfortune of their political opponents. It has made everyone cruel and blind to the scientific truth... 1/6
Cloth masking never had good data. We didn't run proper studies in high income nations. We didn't run any good studies in kids. And now we are escalating to higher quality masks precisely in a moment when they serve less societal purpose, than pre vaccine, where they held value
Vaccines are tremendous good. They save lives. They work very well in older people to lower the risk of death.
But diminishing vaccine effectiveness against mild infection subverts the need for mandates. And pushing boosters in the young is misguided
People on both sides of the political spectrum lean into absolutes. And thus sensible middle ground is not possible. Everyone thinks the other side politicizes the topic. But they do themselves. Sad to see.
Meanwhile, science is on life support. We run the serious risk of having a split in science, and having two sets of scientific facts to support the two political parties. That would be a catastrophic result. But each day we dig in deeper that way.
Although a lifelong progressive, and Bernie fan, I follow the science above all else. And on many covid issues It's the other side that's in the right. Particularly when it comes to children and the restrictions they face. Progressive policy ironically hurting kids. Sad
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Censoring misinformation is removing a tumor with a sword, not a scalpel
You are definitely going to cut a lot of healthy tissue-- debate
And you might not like the outcome
Oh and the people wielding the sword have no idea what they're doing, have seldom published sci papers.
Even more rarely have they engaged in a scientific field that is subject to significant debate and controversy over a prolonged period of time. Without that perspective they have no idea the bounds of legitimate debate.
This is how you reply to the Rogan episodes with a scalpel. Not a sword. Acknowledging what was true. And what wasn't. It's called dialogue
Yes! Vax booster mandates are just like seat belts. In 3 months in 1984, for anyone who didn't buckle up 100%, they were fired from their place of employment and not allowed to work again in that sector. Enforcement was absolute...
Also people who had seat belts already (natural immunity) That didn't count. You had to install the special new seat belt. And you only had a few months to do it.
Oh, and we initially believed that seat belts would protect other people. But then very quickly we learned that there was a new variant and they only protect the wearer, but that didn't stop us.