It’s Holocaust Memorial Day. This year, I’m thinking of a woman called Sulamita Szapiro. Here she is as a student. We weren’t related and I don’t even know much about her, but I’m pretty sure that remembering her still falls to me. This is a thread about why.
Sulamita was born in Warsaw. Her father was a teacher, and she went on to be one, too. I think she was also a writer, maybe a journalist or a poet. I think this because somebody with her name wrote for Nasz Przegląd, aPolish-Jewish newspaper. I think it was her, but who knows?
I do know, though, that when war broke out she had only one living relative. That was her brother Nuiniek, a lawyer, married to Andzia. Here they are:
Yad Vashem, the Holocaust database, tells us that he’d go on to die in the Otwock ghetto. She’d be gassed in Treblinka. So I guess, for the reasons this thread explains, it’s my job to remember them, too.
I also know that Sulamita had a boyfriend, an engineer. When the Nazis invaded in 1939 she was seven months pregnant, although they were unmarried. Perhaps it’s wrong for me to feel that suggests a bohemian outlook, but that’s what I imagine, because you latch on to what you can.
They married the next day, and fled to Lviv, in the half of Poland now occupied by Russia. Here they sheltered in what would become the ghetto, along with tens of thousands of Jewish refugees. Their baby - a daughter - was born here.
Eventually, of course, the Nazis would take Lviv, too, and the liquidation of the ghetto would be horrific. In my understanding, almost nobody from it would survive. Sulamita and her little family were already gone by then, though, deported by the Russians to a gulag in Siberia.
I don't know much about this period. Sulamita's boyfriend - now her husband - was put to work as a woodcutter, and was hurt by a log. I don’t know what Sulamita did. I doubt it was pleasant. Maybe she was lucky, and a teacher there, too?
In 1941 Russia changed sides, the gulag was opened. Like many other stranded Jews, Sulamita and her little family went South West, to escape via the Middle East. A horrible journey, thousands of miles. Contemporary accounts talk of bodies falling from cargo trains, “like sticks”.
This story doesn’t end well. Sulamita only made it as far as Karmine, in what is now Uzbekistan. Here, I believe, she died of typhus. So did her child, at the age of two. I do not know, and will probably never know, where they were buried, or even if they were.
I don’t even know for sure that this is really what happened. Perhaps the child was thrown from a train, or given to a villager, or lost in a crush, and death was easier to explain. We know these things happened, more often than anybody will say. You have to consider it.
I do know, though, what happened to the now widowed, now childless engineer who had started the war as her boyfriend. He kept going. He crossed the Caspian Sea to Tehran, travelled through Iraq and collapsed in hospital in Palestine. Then he joined the RAF, and came to the UK.
He was my grandfather. Jozef. Here he is after the war in Rio, with the only survivor from his own family, his brother Leon. He’d go on to meet my lovely grandmother, a Polish exile pianist, and they’d have my mum. He died when I was three. I am now one of six living descendants.
Sulamita, though, has no living descendents. No family survived. Until I learned of her existence a couple of years ago, there was not one person in the world left to remember her name. Nor to know the name to that child, who my grandfather wouldn’t speak of at all.
To repeat, nobody alive knows more about these people than I do. And I know almost nothing. It's in living memory, but there is nobody to remember. This is what genocide means. This is what the Holocaust means. It’s a story of eradication. It wasn’t thwarted. It worked very well.
So, that’s why today I’m thinking of Sulamita, because otherwise nobody will. Here she is again. Maybe you’ll think of her, too. Thanks for reading.
Wow. I can't even begin to reply to all the responses to this thread. But I have read them all and truly appreciated them all, too. Thank you. I'm so glad I posted all that.
I'm of the view that every country should recognise a Palestinian state, because its meaningless to talk of a two-state solution without that. Although today will be a good test of how many people actually understand the politics and implications of that.
The moment you do so, for example, you distinguish a Palestinian state from the Israeli state. Stateless people cease to be stateless. Which means the narrative around occupation, apartheid etc fundamentally changes, too. Implicitly, you're acknowledging that the Palestinian...
... state would have borders. Which means, by defintion, the Israeli state would, too. What then of "from the river to the sea" etc? What of the idea of one bi-national state across the whole region? These become harder to advocate, because you've just recognised an alternative..
Nothing from the Covid inquiry is surprising. Shocking, maybe. But everybody knew it was a joke shitshow government at the time, because it was the Boris Johnson government, and only joke shitshow politicians would serve in it. I wrote this in April 2020, when Covid first hit.
I don't think any government could have done Covid well. But so much of the dysfunction of the last few years comes down to the basic lie of Brexit: this fiction that there were competent, cautious, responsible, credible people on both sides. There simply weren't. Virtually...
...every competent minister in the May government had been a Remainer, and the Johnsonites made a point of driving them out. So by the time Johnson got in, it was a mix of buffoons, tricksters and charlatans. People who were no good, or people prepared to straight up talk balls..
There's such an enormous disparity of feeling about what this chant means. You'd think that this, at least, would be resolvable. But I'm struck by the number of quote tweets here that seem to think Simon's interpretation is melodramatic or paranoid...
To be clear, many - possibly most -Jews understand this as calling for the eradication of Israel. You might not. They do. Further, they think that the eradication of Israel would lead to widespread slaughter, as per October 7th. Again, you might not. Again, they do. Finally...
... they do not see it as compatible with a desire for a two-state solution. Literally, they see it as the opposite. You might feel that is mistaken, but even if it is -and I don't think it is - it is not paranoid, or shrill to have that interpretation. Which, in turn, makes ...
I'm not an economist, and I tend not to write on economics for fear of missing the obvious and sounding a moron. (No, doesn't stop me in other fields, etc.) But help me out, because this has been bothering me for a few months. (1/?)
Central banks put up interest rates to drive down inflation. That's the orthodoxy. Inflation = too much money chasing too few goods. Understood.
Except right now, that's not what inflation is. There is not too much money. Is there? Instead our inflation is the result of hugely increased costs in everything, largely for imported reasons. Power, food, materials, etc.
The blue tick fuss is almost too perfect. It's not trivial. It's an exact illustration of populist political trends over the past decade or so.
Basically, it's a resentful revolt against a real elite. That's not a value judgement. Old blue ticks were elitist. Of course they were. That was literally the point.
The system was chaotic and flawed, but they basically said "this person/thing is notable enough for it to matter if they are impersonated."
All the Braverman photos show her visiting the building site of Kigali's Bwiza Riverside Estate, as if it were being built specifically to our house asylum seekers....
It isn't. It was being built anyway. It's just a Kigali housing project. And they wouldn't get to live there anyway until after they'd opted to stay and become resident. So the whole thing is just her going "THIS IS WHAT A HOUSE LOOKS LIKE." Super.
I should say, the Home Office has been in touch to say this isn't true. I'm not taking it down because... er, I think it is? Attached is the first report of this development. newtimes.co.rw/article/193511…