Vinamra Profile picture
Feb 5 8 tweets 2 min read
In this whole thread, Bhai sahab khali right left centre insinuate kar rahe hain but ek point pe jo logical mistake hai uspar baar karna jaruri hai.

So here.

#AtheistMuslimOrHindu

There are for aspects to this question

From the point of view of .
1) Govt
2) Society

++
++
3) religion
3a) cultural significance and involvement in practice
3b) talking about the religious knowledge and practices

4) Individual's choice

For the first two, religious identity is tied to you no matter what you avow

As far as state and society is concerned ++
++ you are a Muslim and face about similar disadvantages as any other Muslim (identity based), even if you keep shouting that you are Atheist
And Vice Versa

Hence in civil, social, political and other right based discourse

AN ATHEIST MUSLIM IS A MUSLIM
*
*There are nuances
++
++

The last one is an individual choice. The person can choose to identify as a Hindu or Muslim or any other level of religious attitude

It's between him and God, and you or me aren't judges

If any religion actually appoints a judge, then they can decide, not you or me ++
++

And that brings me to the third point, the most interesting one

Only in 3a) will it be logical or moral if you decide to exclude him from certain common practices or rituals if you don't deem him Hindu or Muslim

But as the power structure everywhere is lopsided.. ++
++ 3b gives a right to the individual to put forward his voice and plead his case if he thinks anything is being unfair.

And state can actually see , with empathy, justice and morality that decisions are made

Ex Sabrimala, Parsi Rights of inter faith marriage ++
++

Long story short, if you said that we are all praying together or celebrating Eid and he can't be included as he isn't Muslim, probably I would have seen some sense

But as far as civil, political and social rights are concerned

As far as how govt views are concerned ++
++ any Indian Person with Muslim Name is at way bigger risk, cause of identity , than any other NRI ,no matter what they espouse

And hence must have a say, in fact bigger say

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Vinamra

Vinamra Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Duneemperorpaul

Feb 7
#BhaiKeJhooth
Lie ) She accused MS of being Harrasser?

Truth) She said that MS let the guy who harrassed her speak AND DIDN'T REMOVE HIM. IN FACT HE TURNED BACK AND ASKED HER ABOUT NASEERUDDIN SHAH

This behaviour is called

ENABLING THR HARRASSER

She felt that they enabled++
++

Lie) How can you throw MS host under the bus. There were tweets against her

Truth)The MS made someone feel that he enabled the harrasser. They were well within their right to feel so. The tweets on MS were made by a lot on Twitter

YOU CHOSE TO PUNISH THAT GIRL

DELIBERATELY
Lie) MS doesn't harass people?

Truth) That's a strawman. Cause that isn't even accusation

HE ENABLED

Lie) Abuses can't be tolerated

Truth) The current cohost used TH0T which is a slang for calling a woman WH0R€

He is Co host currently
Read 50 tweets
Feb 7
Good Morning @girlpilot_

You have once again made it #WomenOfTheDay

It is extra special

As now bhai has decided to threaten you

Bhai ne #Sullideals and #Bullibai se inspiration le hi liya 💪

Publically intimidate karna chahte hain so that women don't speak

Koi na

++ ImageImageImage
++

The women in his follower list are silent
Koi na

But do notice that all likes are from men

#menaretrash

Men se yaad aaya

@Insaafkadost - Do include this in your islamic viewpoint space about how women are to be treated

@deccandodger : Abe Galibaaz really 😑
In that space badh chadh ke bura bhala kaha gya

Brumby ko

Which is Australian Feral Horse

And baki log bhi the

@midhatkidwai bhai, @underdated bhai etc

But inn bhaisahab ka shauk khali #Women par rehta hai

Mardon ko ye privilege dete hain

#BroCode
Read 6 tweets
Feb 5
#NRI like this entity are the worst

Instead of acting as a true ally to Indian Muslims, they want to test their "Muslimness"

Cause they don't pay the price

A Saib puts himself on the line when he goes to protests

This thing here, doesn't

Hence he can throw Indians to 🐕
++ Image
++
An #UmarKhalid will suffer in jail

While they will park their NRI posterior on sofa watching Rugby

In their own nations they are non entity

So they act as saviour here

While throwing the "Indian Muslims" Under the 🚍, by ironically calling them "Saviour"

++ Image
Not just in India, apparantly their perceived "Whiteness" makes them eligible to judge the Muslims of entire Subcontinent

It's their certificate that will matter

While they are watching Rugby

++ Image
Read 11 tweets
Nov 22, 2021
#FreeKaGyaan
#LogicalFallacies

The common fallacies used by people during arguments

Also known as Propagandists ki Rozi Roti 👇

(All Graphical Display has been taken from

Don't be fooled! yourlogicalfallacyis.com

Do check them out for more details and brilliant merchandise)
1) "Modiji Ne Kiya Hai to kuch Soch Samajh ke Kiya Hoga"

Matlab kisi ko authority maan lo, fir wo jo bole usko sahi bolo

Used frequently by religious people ki falana book mein, ya falana story mein likha hai to sahi hi hoga

Do notice that its about non-proof based authority Image
2) "Arre uska argument kya sun na, wo to khud kal daaru pee ke pada hua tha . Bakwas hi kar raha hoga "

Or

"Wo Congressi, Pappu, Aapiya, Libra@ndu, Sickular, hai"

Matlab bhai argument se jeet nahin sakte to personal character pe attack karo

Used frequently against women Image
Read 15 tweets
Nov 20, 2021
Space Rules :
1) Host Dictates

2) Language Civil

3) You don't get to disrupt again and again and still continue

4) Read the Damn Room

5) You want to talk serious, great, go to some serious room or wait for one

6) Humor is political

8) Be crisp

9) Time is limited
10) Respect others time. Your last point isn't going to change the world

11) It's selfish when you know you have spoken earlier and yet like a total A$$ you keep jumping in forcefully while others wait (For Serious Discussions)

12) Don't ask to FB or why we're you blocked
13) You aren't being cute by shouting

14) There's limit to tolerance

15) You are knowledged. Great. Write a PhD paper. Don't come to show off Stick to topic, Talk within limit

16) History is relevant but don't show your knowledge by starting from big bang

17) Host Dictates
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

:(