In this whole thread, Bhai sahab khali right left centre insinuate kar rahe hain but ek point pe jo logical mistake hai uspar baar karna jaruri hai.
So here.
#AtheistMuslimOrHindu
There are for aspects to this question
From the point of view of .
1) Govt
2) Society
++
So here.
#AtheistMuslimOrHindu
There are for aspects to this question
From the point of view of .
1) Govt
2) Society
++
https://twitter.com/imismail11/status/1489880688425938945
++
3) religion
3a) cultural significance and involvement in practice
3b) talking about the religious knowledge and practices
4) Individual's choice
For the first two, religious identity is tied to you no matter what you avow
As far as state and society is concerned ++
3) religion
3a) cultural significance and involvement in practice
3b) talking about the religious knowledge and practices
4) Individual's choice
For the first two, religious identity is tied to you no matter what you avow
As far as state and society is concerned ++
++ you are a Muslim and face about similar disadvantages as any other Muslim (identity based), even if you keep shouting that you are Atheist
And Vice Versa
Hence in civil, social, political and other right based discourse
AN ATHEIST MUSLIM IS A MUSLIM
*
*There are nuances
++
And Vice Versa
Hence in civil, social, political and other right based discourse
AN ATHEIST MUSLIM IS A MUSLIM
*
*There are nuances
++
++
The last one is an individual choice. The person can choose to identify as a Hindu or Muslim or any other level of religious attitude
It's between him and God, and you or me aren't judges
If any religion actually appoints a judge, then they can decide, not you or me ++
The last one is an individual choice. The person can choose to identify as a Hindu or Muslim or any other level of religious attitude
It's between him and God, and you or me aren't judges
If any religion actually appoints a judge, then they can decide, not you or me ++
++
And that brings me to the third point, the most interesting one
Only in 3a) will it be logical or moral if you decide to exclude him from certain common practices or rituals if you don't deem him Hindu or Muslim
But as the power structure everywhere is lopsided.. ++
And that brings me to the third point, the most interesting one
Only in 3a) will it be logical or moral if you decide to exclude him from certain common practices or rituals if you don't deem him Hindu or Muslim
But as the power structure everywhere is lopsided.. ++
++ 3b gives a right to the individual to put forward his voice and plead his case if he thinks anything is being unfair.
And state can actually see , with empathy, justice and morality that decisions are made
Ex Sabrimala, Parsi Rights of inter faith marriage ++
And state can actually see , with empathy, justice and morality that decisions are made
Ex Sabrimala, Parsi Rights of inter faith marriage ++
++
Long story short, if you said that we are all praying together or celebrating Eid and he can't be included as he isn't Muslim, probably I would have seen some sense
But as far as civil, political and social rights are concerned
As far as how govt views are concerned ++
Long story short, if you said that we are all praying together or celebrating Eid and he can't be included as he isn't Muslim, probably I would have seen some sense
But as far as civil, political and social rights are concerned
As far as how govt views are concerned ++
++ any Indian Person with Muslim Name is at way bigger risk, cause of identity , than any other NRI ,no matter what they espouse
And hence must have a say, in fact bigger say
And hence must have a say, in fact bigger say
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
