Tristan S. Rapp Profile picture
Feb 6, 2022 7 tweets 4 min read Read on X
Deep Time, if pondered, produces a profound sense of temporal vertigo unlike anything. When we speak of events 20, 30, 40.000 years ago, the numbers scarcely register.

A man, gazing out from a hill 40kya, would have still *30.000 years* to go before even the end of the Ice Age. Image
Consider the stories we tell set in the "far future". Most of these take place only as far as the 3rd or 4th millenniums. Even such works as Warhammer 40k, set in an almost incomprehensibly distant future, is closer to the present than the first modern humans to enter Europe. ImageImageImage
We popularly envision "cave men", or even a more nuanced notion of "Palaeolithic people" as essentially one culture, one way of life. Yet even within the Lascaux caverns, the distance in time between the first & last paintings was maybe 100x that between Rembrandt and Picasso. Image
The dizzying truth is that we cannot grasp & classify the ancient past. Not really. We can make vague groupings of styles of flint technology, but even these frequently span temporal intervals many times that of Caesar and Napoleon. ImageImage
There is no use in talking even of such things as "life in Doggerland" - there was a Doggerland almost coated in glaciers, when only a small plain of tundra lay bare in the south, and a Doggerland of rich steppe, and a Doggerland of marsh and forest. 100 landscapes, 1000 cultures Image
There were people 28,000 years ago who found scraps of artifacts and walls of paintings almost as ancient and foreign to them as they are to us. There were cultures that rose and fell in spans of centuries that factor in modern studies only as the decimal-points of dates. ImageImageImage
I sometimes visualise this vertigo by thinking of Google Maps and the satellite view. Then I try to picture the same landscape as it must have looked 6000 years ago - no towns, no roads, no fields, no divisions, no borders. The same hills & shores, yet... nothing visibly human. ImageImage

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tristan S. Rapp

Tristan S. Rapp Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Hieraaetus

Oct 30
As we approach the 31st, gentle plenary reminders that:

1. The festival of All Saints Day was celebrated for over a century prior to it being moved (in the West) to the 1st of November
2. This move had nothing to do with Sámhain, and began on the continent decades before Ireland Image
3. While Sámhain is attested as a festival in pre-Christian Ireland, there is no evidence of special associations with the dead during the pagan period.
4. Most Halloween traditions, be it costuming, trick-or-treating, even divination, probably stem from England, not Ireland. Image
Image
5. Most specific customs cannot be traced back further than the High Middle Ages or even the Early Modern Period. There is little-to-no evidence linking them to *anything* in Late Antiquity, pagan, Christian or otherwise. Image
Read 5 tweets
Aug 28
Why is it that "primitive horticulturalists" - i.e. peoples such as the Dani of Papua or the Yanomami or Pirahã of South America - seem to tend towards a sort of "atheistic supernaturalism," believing in a world of invisible, often malicious spirits, but without any higher, organising powers, whilst both more sophisticated cultures *and* more primitive hunter-gathers seem to tend towards theistic cosmologies?

What happens in the jungle vegetable gardens?Image
Image
This is a genuinely strange phenomenon - there is a remarkable coalescence between the "style" of cosmology found among Papuans, Amazonians and certain Congolese tribes, all extremely distantly related but united by a common climate and lifestyle. Yet this "vegetable garden spirituality," though highly consistent among similar rainforest-dwelling Neolithics, is markedly aberrant compared to what we see both among true hunter-gatherers and more complex societies.Image
"Hunter-gatherer-grade cultures," from the various Aboriginal tribes to the San Bushmen, the Hadza and various North American peoples tend to have "higher-level" theistic cosmologies, i.e. cosmologies with clear mono- or polytheistic figures exercising demiurgic functions, though (usually) less strongly developed than in complex, urban societies.Image
Image
Read 6 tweets
Aug 28
The area of what was once Gaul went through a truly remarkable process of ethnogenesis in the period between 1-600 AD.

From a barely romanized, still essentially Iron Age Celtic culture to Christian, Germanized Gallo-Romans, all the while retaining mostly the same ancestry. Image
Image
Most people probably don't realize - I certainly didn't, originally - that the Gaulish language was still widely spoken throughout Gallia at the time of the Frankish conquest. It was the *Franks*, ironically, who completed the "Romanization" process. Image
This sort of thing is not too uncommon, actually - you have an initial tension between a colonized and a colonizer group, which may persist for generations until a *third* group conquers both, thus relativizing and diminishing the original conflict and hastening assimilation.
Read 5 tweets
May 6
A striking takeaway of the last 10 years of the aDNA revolution - from the Indo-Europeans, to the Bantu, to the Swahili, to the Japanese - is that you might sooner trust a toddler to pick out a 50-meter target with a revolver than an archaeologist to identify an ancient migration Image
Image
It should be self-evident that we cannot simply derive from this a reverse principle, and conclude that wherever contemporary archaeologists denied a purported migration, it really did take place - yet the scope of the discrediting is remarkable.
What are we to make of as-yet unresolved fine-grained questions, such as the Dorian invasion, the Hebrew conquest of Canaan or other traditional narratives long contested by the now-dubious consensus? Again, we cannot simply default to the inverse conclusion, but one wonders. Image
Image
Read 5 tweets
Apr 7
"Real, unembellished history" according to quite a number of historians seems to consist largely of ppl sitting around, munching bread and porridge, between periodic bursts of fighting over miscellaneous economic factors. Image
>Knight is recorded as composing a poem to persuade his captor lord to free him:
"Bet that happened lol"
>King gives a stirring speech before battle:
"Sure that happened"
>Viking is heads out to Constantinople, motivated by a dream:
"Definitely not embellished mhm" Image
Never underestimate a dusty historian's ability to regard as improbable literally any display of human spontaneity, whimsy or unconditioned willpower.
Read 4 tweets
Mar 3
This is only half true. Rwanda is a cohesive, fairly well-run and (by regional standards) prosperous and stable country. The Congo, it is true, is essentially not a real state, hence why the massive size disparity between it and Rwanda confers no military advantage.
It is an interesting quirk of the global export of the nation state system that we aren't really able to account for "unorganized regions" anymore. With the exception of Antarctica, every plot of land *must* be attached to a specific polity with a government and a flag.
This works well enough in some parts of the world, but it obviously fails elsewhere, where the reality on the ground simply fails to match the internationally recognised construct. The Darién Gap is only "part" of Panama and Colombia in the most tenuously nominal sense. Image
Image
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(