The client had a drug addiction. He shoplifted to get drugs. He was in horrible physical pain because he was dying, but the ADA was completely unsympathetic.
I remember the judge saying there was "nothing he could do" in these circumstances, even tho he had complete discretion.
Our client was only in jail in the first place because he had shoplifted and the ADA had charged that case as a felony burglary. He had a substantial record for drug and petty theft cases. He couldn't afford bail.
Today in NY that case would not be eligible for bail.
I think of all the people who yell and pontificate about bail reform, while the reality is the people who have benefited from it are people like my client (altho let's be clear many people like him remain imprisoned despite the reforms).
Maybe the media could tell these stories.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Of course almost 2,000 of them call in sick or are AWOL every day, so that reduces their numbers, but that still leaves a ratio of 1 corrections officer per incarcerated person, four times the national average. thecity.nyc/2021/7/11/2257…
Rikers guards have left housing units with almost no staff, have left their posts and watched as people have died by suicide to justify their campaign to get the city to employ more guards. nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-c…
It's an unpopular opinion, but I believe the judge presiding over the federal trial of the three men who killed Ahmaud Arbery should have honored the government's and McMichaels plea deal.
Not because I think proving that the defendants were motivated by racism isn't important.
In fact I think it's vital. The state trial whitewashed that those men lynched Ahmaud Arbery. Maybe that was necessary to gain a conviction. States' failure to secure convictions in these cases are one of the reasons federal civil rights cases are brought. vox.com/22801394/racis…
My feelings are rooted in a few things.
1. Knowing that the men would have had to admit that they killed Ahmaud because of racism if they pleaded guilty. That's powerful. If they are convicted at trial they won't because they will appeal.
Pulling people over for tinted windows is a form of "broken windows" policing that targets Black drivers - see observations by @GangiFromProp and @MarshallProj .
Moreover, like most traffic stops (and indeed police pursuits for serious crimes) there are far better alternatives - police here had Mr. Aristhee's plates.
in other cases that are not traffic stops there are usually cameras that allow police to follow up.