Jamie Scott Profile picture
Feb 10, 2022 29 tweets 9 min read Read on X
📌 325/235: The Best Formation in Football? [Thread]
Most of the top teams utilise a variant of the 325/235 formation in possession. This thread will explore why teams use the 235/235 formation, and why it is optimal in the fast-paced, hyper-technical/physical modern game - where the margins are fine.
Simply broken down, the 235/325 is ideal in possession, because the team has occupation of all five lateral zones, which is conducive of good spacing and balance, while maintaining overloads and security in deep central areas.
The interplay between risk and reward, or ‘‘expansive’’ play and solidity, can be characterised by the demands of different players in different phases. In build-up, focus on retaining possession, establishing control, and maintaining a strong rest defence is paramount.
In attacking phases, things become more complex, but generally the aim is to create space/an option to progress through, and ultimately access the dangerous areas to create from routinely; ideally in a methodical/reproducible manner.
As Field of Green present (link:().

Top teams need to account for all phases of the game - while very top teams can manipulate the phases of the game. The 235/325 dynamics are conducive of establishing this manipulation.
The 235/325 offers the best of both worlds: tight control with an eye on rest defence and avoiding being exploited in defensive transition, without losing vertical dynamics, width + depth to break down deep blocks and generating those fabled artificial attacking transitions.
If we look at Manchester City, they have these dynamics nailed down perfectly. Their back two are complemented by the inverting fullbacks alongside Rodri in the midfield. They establish control so easily in this mode.
Rodri’s ability to occupy the central space and dominate physically tends to open space for City to progress using the fullbacks. Establishing Control? Check. Rest Defence? Check. Dynamics to Progress Play? Check.
Chelsea act similarly: their 3-2 is so compact, with technical ability to match. They’re very hard to press and the prospective threat of their width + depth forces teams to sit off and relinquish any modicum of control in Chelsea’s build-up.
(Note – Werner + the technical/physical quality of James/Chilwell helps the vertical dynamics – when Chelsea lost these players to injury/poor form, teams became more comfortable against Chelsea)
Liverpool are less similar than Chelsea to City, in the regard that they place less emphasis on total control from build-up, but the prospective threat of Salah, Mane (and often) Jota running the channels helps their cause in establishing the front five.
So the 235/325 is great at establishing control. But what dynamics make is such a threat in the final third? So many teams shunt their fullbacks into advanced areas and invert their wingers (to make a five), but struggle – appearing stagnant, easy to defend against.
The key, is manipulating the opposition. The opposition will always prioritise defending central areas. Pep had success in destroying teams repeatedly using KDB/Silva as free #8s and exploiting the half-spaces – but teams are savvy now.
In a similar vein, teams know not to give Salah or Mane time/space to run into when coming off the flank. Or giving the likes of Mount/Havertz/Lukaku the space to operate in as the nominal front three. 442 blocks are common and reasonably effective game-to-game.
Fullbacks/wingbacks/wingers receiving in the correct manner can be just as conducive of creating that reproducible threat going forwards, and the 235/325 offers the opportunity to reap the benefits of these dynamics.
Utilising the fact that teams will first focus on central security, City/Chelsea/Liverpool manipulate opposition blocks. City will load up to three players between the lines to pin opposition blocks to a narrow berth – Chelsea are similar. Liverpool invert Salah/Mane.
This allows these teams to access their wide players in areas of danger. For Liverpool, this is generally accessing Trent Alexander Arnold as the spare man – whether that’s due to Henderson/Elliot overlapping or otherwise.
As we can see from Yash’s (@Odriozolite's) brilliant visualisation, Trent adds the most Expected Threat for Liverpool.



This is primarily done from the half-space or deep wide space – Trent’s distribution is immense and he’s Liverpool’s primary danger.
But again, it is worth noting that Trent can only be Liverpool’s primary danger because the space created for him is a downstream benefit of Liverpool’s 235 system. Salah/Mane inverting generates the opportunity to create space.
Chelsea and City operate slightly differently. The aim of their progression is often to access the lone wide player in a favourable scenario. As City use non-inverted wingers, and Chelsea use wingbacks, these can be viewed as similar.
Chelsea use their narrow front three and compact 3-2 structure to open space out wide. This allows James/Chilwell to receive in movement – an underestimated facet. These wingbacks have time/space to execute their actions upon overlapping.
Similarly, City often use Foden on the left and Sterling on the right. Because of the nature of the front three pinning the opposition block and the 2-3 offering the central superiority, Foden/Sterling can receive with space to gain momentum in their dribbles.
Receiving with space is so important. A common limitation with wingers who have a tendency to invert is they can receive at less favourable angles, thus, can often be tightly marked by opposition fullbacks, thus, stagnating attacks ().
Foden/Sterling’s 1v1 abilities down the line force the opposition defenders to anticipate the threat and pay attention to defending down the line. This in turn generates space for Cancelo in the half space, where he has been a massive threat this season.
To back up this notion, here is an example of Cancelo's technical execution from such a zone, alongside another excerpt of @Odriozolite's Expected Threat visualisation.
Chelsea, although seemingly most potent through their wingbacks, actually have Mount as their individual with the highest expected threat. Again, the half spaces are a threatening location for Mount, who is a beneficiary of the width + depth of Chilwell/James.
As a final point, it is also worth noting that the 325/235 is also conducive of effective counter-pressing for offensive benefit – be it through generating artificial attacking transition-like scenarios, or merely overloading (rest defence) near the ball.
So, to conclude, the 235/325 is a very potent formation which allows teams to establish dominance in most phases of the game, by manipulating the dynamics of each phase using their individual team’s principles.
Any feedback is more than welcome!
(reply/DM - I’m happy to discuss)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jamie Scott

Jamie Scott Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JamiescottUV

Aug 15, 2023
📌⚽ Are Inverted Fullbacks Ineffective?

Analysing the Role of Inverted Fullbacks in the EPL this Weekend: [Thread]
Manchester United:
- Shaw - ineffective when inverted: 4/10
- Wan Bissaka - offered verticality from underlaps and created chances (plus the goal): 8/10 Image
Spurs:
- Udogie - inversion left Son isolated at times: 5/10
- Emerson Royal - scored, and gave rise to Skipp and Kulusevski's balance on the right wing: 6/10 Image
Read 6 tweets
Aug 2, 2023
Erik Ten Hag is revolutionising the way Manchester United play football. This isn’t without difficulty however – Ten Hag’s approach is risky and requires substantial change. This thread explores the topic of personnel and risk vs reward when considering ETH's principles. [Thread] Image
There are three key facets to consider in this discussion:
- The risky nature of Ten Hag’s principles
- The quality and implementation of coaching
- The players: in terms of individual profiles and team make-up
Further, some parameters to consider when evaluating the relative success/failure of Ten Hag’s approach:
- Time it takes to implement principles
- Limiting factors (player quality & profiles, execution of principles, luck)
- What is to be considered a success
Read 24 tweets
May 8, 2023
📌 How Erik ten Hag's Manchester United struggled against West Ham's mid-block - and what this means for the players and Ten Hag's principles of play [thread]. Image
Manchester United and West Ham lined up as such: ImageImage
West Ham sat in a 442 mid-block and looked to attack United in transitions - building attacks through hold up play and direct dribbling, before subsequent set-pieces.

United were matched player for player in build-up and progression, and struggled for inspiration. Image
Read 13 tweets
May 16, 2022
📌 Using Data to Identify Areas Where Erik ten Hag Can Improve Manchester United [thread]: Image
Before looking at areas at United that Erik ten Hag can improve at United, it could be worth reviewing the principles of play Ten Hag has implemented as a coach at Ajax recently:
Figure 1. Opposition Pressures in the Attacking Third and Opposition Pressure Success Percentage.

In other words – how often is a team pressed high up the pitch (in their defensive third), and how well can they cope with it? Image
Read 33 tweets
May 3, 2022
“The worst thing in football is doubt”

This is 100% true. Players who doubt, don’t have confidence or clarity. They’re susceptible to possession loss, they slow down play, they’re less likely to execute actions well.

For me, there are three main aspects to achieving clarity: Image
1) understanding of system and principles

2) understanding of what you’re going to do

3) coaching/instructions from teammates

Ultimately, a system or coaching in that vein (#1) alleviates the prerogative of a player to make a decision in each given circumstance (#2).
To achieve absolute clarity and confidence in your actions, in any given state of the game (with time on the ball or under pressure, when you have multiple options or when you have no options), you need that overarching set of principles.
Read 5 tweets
Apr 6, 2022
📌 The Titanic Battle Between Pep Guardiola and Diego Simeone [mini-thread]:
Atleti began in a 532 block, with City implementing their usual build-up strategies. Advantage City; over 90 minutes they would most likely have broken this block down; the progression angles are favourable and they had ultimate control in build-up. Image
City were able to build in their regular manner. They had an advantage over the front two, and could access most of the players in the progression chain easily, accessing their wingers.
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(