Meet Anne. She’s “principal staff writer” at the public toilet called The Atlantic, but doesn’t know the difference between propaganda & history. Kinda like how she believes US claims of “upholding rules based order” while being the most egregious violator in the last 30 years
.of course Anne Applebum like most of her ilk (another example below) are extremely adept at mangling what others say, subtly manipulating speech to make it sound absurd. For example here’s “modern Ukraine” & who added what to it & when.
Notice the contradiction between what Putin said & what Einstein here editorialises it to the exact opposite. Mind you since you can see both in the same tweet, (🔴 the spin 🔵 what Putin said) you understand exactly how blatant the bullshitting is.
Also please remember this was “Ukraine” in 1654 at the beginning of the Russo-Polish war & Peryaslavl Council & treaty of Andrusovo. Essentially there was no “Ukraine” - what you call Ukraine today was ENTIRELY created by the Tsars & CommiTsars of Moscow. This doesn’t mean that
Modern Ukraine doesn’t or shouldn’t have sovereignty over its territory, or that Russian actions aren’t blatantly illegal. But spare me the “historical revisionism” + “Kievan Rus” bullshit. Ok?
Btw here’s a map of Kievan Rus overlaid on modern boundaries - remember it was called KIEVAN RUS - not KIEVAN UKRAINE. U-Krai-na (borderland or separated region) was used as a general description of the southern part of this area because it was a frontier against the tatars.
An area called malorossiya (litte Russia) by the poles. At this point you had the Zaporohian Sich - Cossacks - wild brutal beasts, who had to be wild given what they’re dealing with (Mongols & Turks). This tiny area (not Kiev) is the kernel of modern Ukrainian identity. The
breaking of the Rus identity into 3 (Russian, Belarusian & Ukrainian) is attributed to mongol rule and the externalisation of both wealth & control, breaking substance (but not entirely salience which was based on religion).

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Abhijit Iyer-Mitra

Abhijit Iyer-Mitra Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Iyervval

Feb 22
THREAD
1 Putin’s speech is a masterclass on history & realism, please read it in its entirety. I’m posting the link so you can read HIS words, not the spin by assorted western hourly rental “analysts”
en.kremlin.ru/events/preside…
2 first do these sounds like the words of an ethno-nationalist? He acknowledges the deep intermarriage & links between the two states. He states fact that these parts rejoined Russia starting 1654 variously from the Polish-Lithuanian commonwealth, Ottoman Empire & Golden Horde Image
3 Notice he says “history” - not “territory”. Again he states facts here - Modern Ukraine as we know it, was created ENTIRELY by the Romanovs & the USSR. Please ask any “analyst” to factually disprove who made these additions. The deep blue is Zaporozhian Hetmanate. ImageImageImage
Read 28 tweets
Feb 16
1 Introducing @SarahMaslinNir & @Nataliekitro, the latest Glavlit Commissars, whose #TruckersConvoy piece would do their NKVD handlers proud. notice how the military & L&O background of some organisers is constantly repeated to give the impression this is a military coup 🔴 ImageImageImageImage
2 next - notice how the word “occupation” is repeatedly used - the people are called protestors, or demonstrators but the action is constantly called occupation 🔵 this fits in neatly with Gorky’s dictum “hatred should be cultivated by an organic revulsion as far as the enemy is ImageImageImageImage
3 …concerned. Enemies must be seen as inferior. I believe profoundly the enemy is our inferior, & is a degenerate not only in the physical plane but also in the moral sense”. Obviously @nytimes editorial policy to refer to this as occupation while farmers protests were protests. Image
Read 9 tweets
Jan 19
THREAD

1 I hope people are watching and appreciating what @PMOIndia has done with Sri Lanka? Allowing them to stew in a self made Chinese debt trap? This is excellent policy. Let me explain why: Sri Lanka was trying to play India off against China. It was smart, but for india it
2 was a black hole. There was no way India could match up to china’s financial & infrastructure resources. So we stayed out and allowed the debt trap to work its course. Now when the Lankans are on the brink of collapse we’ve lent them an emergency credit line. This is a good
3 thing because for a much much much lesser cost to the Indian taxpayer, in one day, we’ve equalised or neutralised billions of dollars & years of effort that China has put into colonising Sri Lanka. This is not just excellent policy, it’s extremely smart & fiscally prudent
Read 4 tweets
Jan 7
1n All this talk of “security breach” is fine, but let’s see how badly the PM’s own security detail botched up consistently shall we? Watch this video first
2n security breach no1 - notice the PMs car is standing on the exposed side of an elevated highway. An elevation automatically exposes the target - and here the car should have been flanked by the escort vehicles on all sides. The concrete side barriers come only upto waist level
3 exposing the entire upper body, which is already vulnerable due to the glass (albeit bulletproof- still weaker than metal/Kevlar). Notice the the trees at the back? Now watch how the SPG will actually make this situation worse. The door is opened twice to enter the car giving
Read 7 tweets
Dec 28, 2021
A heavily armoured high performance car is a must for the leader of a nuclear armed state, esp one with a No First Use commitment. The leader has to be protected from conventional, nuclear, biological & chemical attacks & make a quick getaway. How were you ever a bureaucrat?
.2 This is because as the elected leader only he can launch the retaliatory strike. Take a comparison with the Russian and US domestically developed cars - the Russian Aurus cost 1300 crores+ to develop newsweek.com/vladimir-putin… not including per unit cost, from scratch while the
3 American one developed from an existing line of GM & Cadillac vehicles cost 125 crores in 2020 dollar with 2021 USD-INR conversion. web.archive.org/web/2016082609…. The UK Jaguar cost 4 crores+ per car not including the one off development costs (no public figures available). Similarly
Read 5 tweets
Dec 23, 2021
THREAD: 1 The conversion banning law is one more in a litany of stupid laws that “pro-hindu” crooks propagate to absolve themselves of responsibility. It is no different from the death penalty in lieu of good policing which is the only deterrent. Let’s examine why conversions
2 happen, shall we? As a Christian you are assured an “education” (as good as the atrocious Indian education system can get) with assured entry in schools and “good colleges” (Loyola in Madras or St Stephen’s in Delhi - they’re both garbage, what they do is provide “credentials”)
3 That is a powerful tool of social upliftment because you could be a villager but still rub shoulders with a creamy layer of society and get into the “old boys club” you could never dream of otherwise. Moreover wherever Christians go, they set up schools, hospitals, orphanages
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(