A Mareva hearing in potential class-action lawsuit over the Ottawa protests is about to begin, concerning plaintiff's request to freeze donations to Freedom Convoy 2022 and others, that is: to keep the cash and crypto from being dispersed before the case is heard.
Presiding: Justice Calum MacLeod.
For plaintiffs: Monique Jilesen and Paul Champ.
For (some of the) respondents: Norman Groot.
For the Ontario attorney general: Melissa Adams.
For the TD Bank: Geoff Hall and Leah Ostler.
Proposed escrow agent: Bobby Kofman.
It appears that protest organizer Pat King (currently in custody at OCDC) is not represented at the hearing. Groot is representing the named defendants on behalf of Keith Wilson.
Jilesen says she and Groot are close to a resolution to the Mareva matter, with respect to defendants Garah, St. Louis, Dichter: crypto currency assets and e-transfer assets would be transferred into escrow set up by bankruptcy trustee firm after today's hearing.
Then, per this yet-to-be-final agreement, they would return in a week to discuss extending the Mareva order. (Mareva is an asset freezing order.)
Adams for Ontario AG says there is an overlap between this Mareva and AG's order on freezing assets. Says AG has no issue with putting the crypto and other assets into escrow. But says there could be ongoing criminal investigations, warns AG could seek to vary Mareva order.
[This is interesting, as it suggests AG is also going after the money via criminal investigations.]
Hall for TD Bank notes a potential overlap, too. Doesn't object to proposed escrow.
Groot says Garah/St. Louis/Dichter are willing to move the assets, cash and crypto, into escrow, but would then ask that the Mareva order on them be lifted. Notes that TD Bank could speak to account of Tamara Lich (also in custody at OCDC).
Court will reconvene on March 9 at 2 pm to discuss whether Mareva order will be continued.
Hearing will break for 30 minutes to finalize the agreement to continue the Mareva until March 9 and move the assets into escrow. Back at 11 am.
Back from break. The parties have reached an agreement on moving donated funds and crypto into escrow, Mareva order extended until March 9 with variance to permit to transfer to escrow agent.
The agreement will allow escrow agent to change passwords for the crypto accounts. Will include e-transfers to Adopt-a-Trucker and a bunch of other assets. Crypto currency will remain as crypto.
Disclosure requirements for banks and financial institutions will continue (this is potentially broader than the assets listed in the Mareva order schedule).
[What we haven't heard yet is an estimate of the size of the assets covered by the Mareva order.]
Groot says there are still outstanding issues about the corporate respondent "Freedom" -- the Canada corporation set up by protesters -- and assets controlled by Tamara Lich.
Groot says the respondents may have issues will extending the Mareva injunction beyond March 9.
J. MacLeod reminds everyone this is all about a civil claim and not a criminal matter, "an entirely different animal" than other proceedings ongoing.
Hearing wraps up. Expect Justice MacLeod to endorse the agreement on extending Mareva and transfers to escrow later today. -30-
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
There will be a Mareva hearing tomorrow at 10 am in the potential class-action lawsuit over Ottawa protest (Li et. al v. Barber et. al.) regarding the temporary injunction freezing defendants’ crypto and other assets. (I’m off tomorrow but will live tweet cause I’m a dork.)
A temporary Mareva injunction was granted on a ex parte application. So this will test if it holds up. This is part of litigation led by Ottawa lawyer Paul Champ but the Mareva injunction is being handled by commercial litigation firm Lenczner Slaight.
Why this matters: the names plaintiffs represent a potential class that includes Ottawa residents, businesses and employees. They seek $300+ million from protest organizers, truckers and defendant classes. Freezing the cash is key so there's something to pursue in court.
Afternoon session in Pat King bail case getting under way again. Justice of the Peace Andrew Seymour re-iterates warning that live streaming is an offence that could result in fines or jail time.
J. Seymour now addressing the Crown application to re-open the hearing to introduce new evidence about King's ownership of a firearm.
"These go beyond what I consider non-controversial issues," he says. But allows there is very limited case law on re-opening bail hearings, because it rarely comes up and they are heard quickly.
Court is in session. Justice of the Peace Andrew Seymour to deliver a decision on protest organizer Pat King's bail application. (No, I can't share a Zoom link because the room gets overloaded.)
Enter, screen left: Pat King takes his seat in the defendant box. Same outfit. Grey sweatshirt, camo hunting jacket, blue surgical mask.
J-P Seymour says there had been a request from media to audio record the proceedings (but not for broadcast) in place of handwritten notes. Crown has no objection; neither does defence counsel Cal Rosemond. So ordered.
Okay, I'm back in after multiple attempts. Crown Moiz Karimjee is continuing his cross of proposed surety Kerry Komix, asking about Facebook post in which she is listed as creator of a crypto donation platform "Tokens for Truckers."
Komix maintains she doesn't understand crypto. Karimjee says she was a partner in the fundraising, in order to avoid the government's reach on the money.
Komix says the fundraiser was to help truckers who lost work and needed money. (This was a Feb. 13 FB post advertising the crypto fundraiser.) "It was for a good thing. That's all I know," she says.
Pat King bail matter getting under way now. Crown is the same as Lich, Moiz Karimjee. This is before Justice of the Peace Andrew Seymour. Waiting for defence counsel to join virtually.
(Justice of the Peace Andrew Seymour is a former Ottawa Citizen crime reporter.)
Court will recess until 10 am to allow counsel Cal Rosemont (sp?) from Toronto to communicate with King.
Tamara Lich bail hearing getting under way now, not 9:30 am as previously thought. Expect a decision on bail shortly. Defence has asked for $5,000; Crown want her held until trial.
Lich is the court, wearing a blue surgical mask and a black coat.
Justice Bourgeois is reading her decision on bail, summarizing the claim that Lich is one of the leaders of the protests that were also called an "occupation," supported by her comments at the press conference with Brian Peckford.