In very simple terms for Nancy somebody who receives exogenous testosterone is getting a boost, because their body is processing and benefitting from extra testosterone that their body didn’t produce. This is understood to be why it is effective as a doping agent.
Whether one can compare the performance of an athlete who has been given exogenous testosterone to take them up to the equivalent testosterone levels of an athlete with high endogenous testosterone remains to be seen.
Such a comparison is potentially problematic, because the athlete given exogenous testosterone is getting a boost, whereas the athlete with high endogenous testosterone is not. High levels of endogenous testosterone are what their physiology is accustomed to.
Androgens such as testosterone are understood to the primary driver for protein cell synthesis in the XY phenotype. In the XX phenotype, the equivalent primary driver is understood to be growth hormone, produced in the liver.
Protein cell synthesis is understood to be the process whereby the human body produces new red blood cells, muscles and ligament tissue.
As testosterone is the primary driver for protein cell synthesis in the XY phenotype, it is understood that somewhere between six and ten times the amount of testosterone is required by the XY phenotype compared to the XX phenotype to enable this process.
If you reduce endogenous T to below what an athlete is accustomed to, there is a concern that protein cell synthesis could be affected. In some phenotypes, this affect can be more pronounced than others.
Transgender female athletes
The Oxford Dictionary refers to a transgender person ‘whose sense of personal identity and gender does not correspond with their birth sex’. This definition encompasses both pre-operation and post-operation trans people.
6 Australian Trans woman were recognised as Australian GLBTIQ Trailblazers during the 2018 Gold Coast Commonwealth Games.
The Trans woman were included as 6 of 24 in a landmark exhibition which recognised and celebrated the work of LGBTI groups & orgs in the 53 countries that make up the Commonwealth, to raise the visibility of LGBTI people and their lives during the Commonwealth Games and beyond.
The Australian GLBTIQ Trailblazers were selected as being a first in their field.
Tucker, Hilton etc cite Q angle, lung size, bone density & height in XX women – confer a performance advantage for XY trans women, but there is NO support in the literature that these factors confer any such advantage.
The Q angle – defined as the angle between a line drawn from the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS) to the center of the Patella & a second line from the Patella to the Tibial Tubercle & has often been assumed to play a role in generating power during acceleration
and efficiency of a running stride. However, under investigation there appears to be no performance advantage conferred in sport as a result of Q angle, further increased risk of injury attributed to Q angle can be entirely removed with training
Violence towards people because of their race, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, sex or religion makes me wonder, How long it will be before one’s identity isn’t a risk factor for violence?
Racism, homophobia, transphobia etc is not just sticks & stones. The emotional pain created by experiences of racism, homophobia. Transphobia look very similar to the patterns of brain activity caused by physical pain.
In this sense, suggesting that we can choose whether racism, homophobia, transphobia etc affects us is like saying that people can decide whether a slap across the face is painful or not.
RIP Uncle Gerald. You were such a kind man & friend I so appreciated our chats and telling me to keep going even though you were suffering. You were like that to so many people❤️
Such a sad loss & such a great role model in the community as a custodian of the Mutawintji National Park. My thoughts are with your family, friends and the community. Fly high Uncle ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Blanket banning trans woman from playing rugby on the basis of risk outcomes of a group level aggregate of physical characteristics that any given individual in this group may demonstrably not possess individually cannot be considered reasonable, proportionate or justified.
This is before we consider the uncomfortable fact that none, zero, zip of the evidence presented by World Rugby involves empirical research of trans women rugby players actually playing rugby or in fact any sport. There were no injuries reported & zero elite trans players.
There is clear evidence that increasing the acceptable period of testosterone suppression further reduces parameters thought to be associated with “meaningful” performance advantage in trans women (which would clearly be more reasonable than banning all trans women).
What this means is under the current blanket T rules we could have trans women with natural T levels below 5 or 10 nmol/L even prior to HRT & they could have been elite athletes in the male category.