Welcome to another week and this one is all about the Federal Budget, which will be handed down tomorrow night. Let’s have a quick look at what we can expect from the Coalition government in this one...
1. Self-congratulation: expect the Coalition to take credit for just about every good piece of data the economy has to offer. (They can’t, and shouldn’t, but they will anyway.)
2. Deflection: Anything bad going on will be attributed to the pandemic, recent flooding, and the Russian invasion of Ukraine. It won’t be that we weren’t prepared for those things; didn’t respond well; or that things weren’t great beforehand.
3. Grand promises: the economic indicators into the future will all be magically better than ever before, and, despite never eventuating we’ll act as though this time they will. Wgaes growth! Low interest rates! Falling unemployment! GDP growth! All coming, we promise!
4. Tax cuts and economic growth: All that good news means we can spend big and still cut taxes, even more. Stage 3 tax-cuts will be re-announced; the LMIO will be extended; one off bribes - ‘payments’ - as well...
… and we’ll be asked to ignore the fact, once more, that tax cuts for high income earners do not lead to greater economic growth, more jobs, or wages growth. It will be presented as a law of nature, though.
5. You get a car park! And you get a car park! EVERYBODY GETS A CAR PARK!
Well, maybe not a car park per se, but there’ll be a lot of money going to fund community projects in marginal seats. And I mean *a lot*. The government has set aside at least $16bn for buying votes.
6. Women’s business: In the midst of a lot of gaslighting about how much the Coalition has done for women, there’ll be a plethora of announcements aimed to sound like a lot but really represent a pittance. Last year $250-odd million went to issues specific to women.
7. Re-announcements: It can be difficult to recognise it real time, but a lot of what gets announced will sound familiar - because it is. The Coalition has a habit of re-announcing things they’ve already announced; sometimes three or four times.
Take for example last week’s announcement of funding for endometriosis research - it was announced in 2019, 2020, and skipped in 2021 to set up another ‘Big Announcement’ tomorrow...
8. Small potatoes: speaking of a pittance, instead of investing the $$billions needed to seriously tackle our carbon emissions, expect a lot of piss and dribble instead. A few million here; a few million there. Enough to tick off the item from a list, but not achieve much.
9. No interest group left behind: there’s an election coming, so you can guarantee there’ll be something for everyone, although the big money will go - rest assured - where we’d list like it: fossil fuels and the military.
10. Wild Card: The government will announce funding for a Federal Integrity Commission. Not because they have any intention of delivering one, but so that no-one can say they aren’t.
11. (I missed one): Long Time Frames: announcements that wrap 10 years worth of funding up into a single number, making it seem much bigger than it is. Infrastructure, Aged Care being two examples. This Budget covers a few years at most; the rest are lies.
12. Record spending! (Sorry, but I can't leave this one off...) Expect the Treasurer to claim credit for record levels of expenditure on items that are indexed to inflation or paid per capita on a growing population.
And finally (really this time) a PSA: Do Not Use 'Mr Speaker' as the basis for a drinking game.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Before I get onto the next article, I want to take a moment to talk about Tuesday’s Federal Budget. It is almost certainly going to be a big spending budget. Leaked snippets indicate that it’ll also include some rather useful forward estimates for GDP growth, wages & inflation...
The Coalition’s Budgets since 2013 have included the following three forecasts every time:
* strong GDP growth
* stronger wages growth
* stable inflation.
In other words, a growing economy, rising real wages, and rising standards of living...
This has turned out to be untrue every. Single. Time.
The reason they do it is that it allows them to also forecast a reduction in the deficit - maybe even a budget surplus - at some future point.
It’s like saying: I can spend more now because I’ve been promised a pay rise.
Taylor’s office spent $1 billion on ‘sham’ carbon projects
[The reason I’m going to harp on about this is because next week’s Budget will contain more money for shit projects.]
"Analysis by a former chair of the government’s carbon pricing integrity committee shows almost all the money spent on emissions reduction has gone to projects that did not contribute to reductions."
[Minister Taylor is just one of a number of cabinet members who don’t seem to know how to do the basics of their portfolio. Whether it’s Colbeck not caring about the Aged, or Joyce not grasping infrastructure, they’ll all of a type.]
One of the things that should be obvious is that action on climate change is a mainstream, central issue - the need for action, and the nature of that action, and the speed of that action - should be a discussion that brings us together in common cause...
Instead, it used by the political parties - primarily the Coalition and the Greens - as a political tool to create division. You can see the centrist forces backing climate action within the many Voices of independent candidates. Life-long, small l liberals who want action.
These people aren’t being spoken to by the larger parties. They’re being called radicals by the coalition; and not activist enough by the Greens. Labor is silent for fear of getting caught in the cross-fire.
"Following revelations the Morrison government pressured AGL to sack its last chief executive, energy companies have increasingly isolated Angus Taylor.”
"This is a story about trust. More specifically, it is a story about just how little trust the major energy companies have for Angus Taylor and the rest of the Morrison government."
We’ve had a few important pieces of economic data released recently and it’s worth just walking through them:
* GDP growth is up, with economic activity increasing by 3.4% in the Dec quarter;
* CPI increased by 1.3% in the Dec Quarter;
* Wages grew by 0.7% in the Dec quarter
* Company profits rose 2% (nearly triple the growth in wages)
* Property prices grew 22% nationally in 2021
* The ASX increased in value 13.6%
* The average rent in Australia increased 7.6%
Despite relatively low unemployment (4.2%) wage earners and renters in Australia went backwards in 2021. Rents rose; prices rose; and wages didn't come close to keeping pace.
But company profits did. And house prices did. And the sharemarket did.
OK, so let’s take a quick look at today’s CPI figures, and they’re not great numbers. But first, some context around the CPI, why it's of interest, and what today's numbers mean (and don't mean but will try to be blamed on anyway)...
1. Let's start with some context. CPI - Consumer Price Index - is an economic measure that gives us some sense for how quickly prices are going up. The ABS looks at a 'basket' of standard household goods* and tracks their price on a regular basis.
CPI jumps around somewhat, and it can be distorted by the movements of specific goods in response to global events. These can have short-term influences over CPI, which the ABS tends to smooth out of the index. There are methodological questions about what's in that 'basket'...