Why history will remember 'counter-disinformation' as the West's greatest strategic blunder:
Instead of doing the opposite of the Kremlin, western states and compliant media have been playing Putin at his own game, and on his own terms, for the best part of two decades...
Instead of building trust with publics and audiences, they alienated and polarised them. Instead of making it easier for Russian audiences to see through Putin's propaganda, they made it easier for Putin to discredit western media in their eyes...
Instead of arms length supporting genuinely independent, plural and critical journalism they gave money to outlets that behave like and are (for all intents and purposes) state media...
Instead of observing the most sacred rules of democracy like not using state funds to discredit political opposition (#IntegrityInitiative), and not 'sexing up' evidence to justify an offensive war, and not subjecting whistleblowers to torture, they did all of that and more...
And for all their Ivy league and Oxbridge training, they missed the most basic, obvious universal maxim:
The only way to win an information war is not to fight it.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
If you want to understand the phenomenon of media amnesia and how respectable, liberal news outlets can become swept up in war-time propaganda, compare and contrast these two articles from @guardian 18 months apart...
The first reports on Facebook's hosting of "Neo Nazi network with UK links" and @CCDHate's warning that Azov - a "neo-nazi extremist movement" - is recruiting far-right activists in the UK to fight in the Ukraine conflict...
The second, published 13 March this year, describes Azov as one of the "volunteer brigades that fought the separatists in the 2014 war", that simply "had far right affiliations", and has "since been folded into the Ukrainian national guard"... theguardian.com/world/2022/mar…
In 2020 I shared an article from @thenation, one of the oldest and most respected weekly news magazine in the US. The article raised questions about the @OPCW's official report into the alleged chemical weapons attack in Douma, Syria...
These questions were not invented by the journalist. They were based on concerns raised by two senior OPCW officials themselves involved in the investigation...
At no point did either the article, or my original tweet, imply a defence of the Russians or Assad regime, or claim that they were not responsible for a chemical weapons attack...
THREAD on what drives the hatred and vitriol of these men.
Most of them came of age in the 1990s, a time when there was virtually no challenge to western hegemony; when habitual harassment of women was just banter..
when there were no existential threats of climate change or pandemics; when the full, devastating global impact of austerity economics was yet to be realised...
when promises of 'change' by liberal politicians - along with 'facts' reported by the mainstream media - were still widely believed.
This brief neoliberal utopian order lasted until around the early 2000s...
Of course, politicians have always played fast and loose with the truth. But there's something about the scale, depth and sheer brazenness of political lying today, and the degree to which it is tolerated or even amplified by a largely compliant press...
I wonder whether this is the real cause of our failing democracy. Instead we're continually told that the greatest threat to democratic life comes from new technology and foreign enemies - major algorithms, Russian bots, etc. Of course all of these things pose serious risks...
But the reach and impact of rampant falsehoods pumped out by a Prime Minister, Leader of the Opposition, major corporations and media institutions dwarfs anything that blows up in social media bubbles...
It's interesting that in amongst the usual spewage of hate bile that right-wing and centrist extremists love to heap on socialist Jews, is the reference to 'kapos'; a derogatory term used to describe Jews who collaborated with the Nazis...
One of the great and tragic ironies is that the majority of Jews who were on the front lines of the ghetto uprisings, who confronted and fought the Nazi collaborators, who embodied the spirit and tradition of Jewish resistance, were almost entirely socialists...
It's a double irony that they were also ardent Zionists, who believed passionately in equality and cooperation between Jews and Arabs, a mutual right to self-determination or a binational state with equal rights for all...
A thread on why @UKLabour's ever more brazen targeting of left wing Jews reflects one of the most appalling bi-products of the anti-Corbyn movement: the normalisation of a particularly insidious form of antisemitism...
There are of course some Jews on the left who have downplayed or ignored the very real problem of antisemitism within the Labour movement. This was wrong, even if the extent of the problem was indeed exaggerated by others for political gain...
But this futile and damaging debate about the 'scale' of the problem overshadowed a disturbing trend that has been roundly ignored even by left wing commentators with mainstream platforms...