We are Amazon's #1 drinkware supplier. In 2022 we will sell over 4 million tumblers and water bottles.
Over the past few years, we have spent over $10 million on Amazon ads.
This month our budget went to $0.
A thread about our change of heart with Amazon Advertising:
For years we spent 8% of revenue on advertising. This is a standard practice for sellers, it bought top placement, the lift in sales was noticeable and ACOS was below 30%.
It seemed like this was driving our business forward… but we were wrong.
Advertising profitability was inflated by ads not driving sales. In other words, organic customers were using ads to shop when they were going to purchase anyway.
1/ We have sold over $200,000,000 on Amazon over the past 6 years.
The most interesting part? We've done about half of that volume as a marketplace seller (3p) and half as a direct vendor (1p).
People will ask me the difference between the two options. This is what I tell them:
2.1/ Pricing - Retail Changes
Marketplace - Sellers have an advantage because they control an item's retail price. This helps when launching products.
Vendor - Amazon controls retails and it is challenging to move retails up. Price changes take planning and consistency.
2.2/ Price Scraping
Marketplace - Not a big issue, sellers may lose the buy box retails aren’t competitive.
Vendor - Amazon price matches other online retailers. This causes issues with Amazon's Profitability. One way or another, the vendor ends up paying for this.