Short 🧵I have met online and IRL some of the kindest, most empathetic, thoughtful women through the campaign to protect women’s sex-based rights. For a @scotgov minister to suggest they are akin to racists and anti-semites is reprehensible
The minister has blocked me so I can’t address her directly, however I hope the FM @NicolaSturgeon will remind her of her duty to the electorate. As a minister, Slater must show respect for all, not just those people she chooses to side with. See point 1 of ministerial code
Slater also accused women’s groups of being funded by US hard-right groups. A claim that has no basis and is made in a deliberate effort to defame legitimate campaigners. Has she read the 7 principles of public life that underpins the ministerial code? Honesty is fundamental
I hold out no hope that Slater will apologise for her defamatory remarks, but I hope @NicolaSturgeon will on her behalf. If she doesn’t, she sends a clear signal to the women of Scotland that she, like her junior minister, believes the majority of us are bigots #RespectMyX
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🧵In advance of the @scotgov statement about gender reform and self-ID on Thursday, here’s 4 comment pieces from Scotland’s national press over last 4 days
First up is @joannaccherry whose defence of women’s rights is legendary
@holyroodmandy editor of Holyrood magazine. Her incisive writing on this issue has exposed the intellectual, political and legal hole at the heart of self-ID holyrood.com/editors-column…
🧵I am no lawyer, but @ianssmart is. A damn fine one and former President of Law Society of Scotland. He wrote an article a few days ago which sets out his informed opinion that reform of the GRA is outwith the legal competence of the Scottish parliament ianssmart.blogspot.com
Let me summarise: Under the 2004 GRA Act, a gender recognition certificate means that for all purposes, a person's acquired gender is their new legal sex. A man becomes a woman, legally (and vice versa of course)
As Ian says in his blog, "a woman is a matter of law, someone born a woman, or possessed of a gender recognition under the 2004 Act"
Words matter. They contain power. The power to heal, to hurt, to change the world, for better or worse. By describing young women as "self-identifying" YWCA Scotland is saying the being female is a choice
That young women can self-identify out of their biological sex, the defining factor of women's oppression as Hadley Freeman wrote in her brilliant essay recently unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-…
YWCA Scotland says it is "a feminist organisation and part of a worldwide movement of women leading change". Its vision is "a world where the voices of women are heard, respected and celebrated". So why is it undermining feminism by asserting that being female is a choice?
Thread: Yesterday MP Mhairi Black said in parliament: “People often think that we have male and female, but the truth is that 1-2% of the global population is born intersex, which means they present characteristics of both sexes..."
She is wrong to use the political term "intersex" when describing people with different sexual development (DSD) and to say that they "present with characteristics of both sexes. People with DSD are not "between" sexes they are male or female.
Conditions range from hyopsadias, where the opening of the urethra is not located at the tip of the penis to Turner Syndrome in girls where one of the X chromosomes is missing or partially missing causing a range of medical/development challenges
In a piece in New Statesman, journalist Marie Le Conte argues that gender critical feminists have been ‘radicalised’ in a similar way to QAnon believers and other extremists.
Quite apart from the extremely offensive analogy, she - and other women who share her view - completely misunderstand, or deliberately ignore, what gender critical feminists are arguing. Perhaps it will help if we look - yet again - at the root cause of this culture war
Feminism is based on the inarguable fact that women and girls across the world are oppressed because of their biological sex; the form that oppression takes depends on the culture of the society a woman lives in, FGM in Sudan, abortion ban in Texas…
A major children’s charity in Scotland, who vision is that all children should have “an equal chance to flourish” says that children as young as 12 should be allowed to change their legal sex without a period of reflection. See @thetimesscot
Children in Scotland also argue that there is no need for parental consent for a 12-year-old child to change their legal sex
This is beyond reckless.
📌A young person is not deemed mature enough to consent to sexual relationship until they are 16; how can that same child be considered mature enough to change their legal sex at 12.