A lot of hot takes out there about why young people get involved in crime...
Over the last decade I've served a diverse range of rangatahi (both rich and poor), many who've gotten on the "wrong side of the law".
Here's some things I've learnt...
1.There are no "bad kids" out there, only hurt ones. No matter how tough, scary, big, or bad, a young person may seem to you, when you take time to listen and hear what's going on under the surface the reality is a child who is hurting and really just asking to be seen.
2. Rich or poor, when YP feel disconnected from their whānau and community, ostracised and othered, they are more likely to become involved in crime. This disconnection can happen as a result of communities scape goating YP and expecting little of them (currently occurring atm)
... it also occurs when YP don't have adults outside their parents that are involved and invested in them. For young people to thrive, it's important they feel that they belong, they matter, and they have people that care about them.
3. Disability (specifically FASD), and lack of specialized support for whānau and young people with disabilities has been a factor for lot of the YP I have served. The failure to support these YP and their whānau, often leaves whānau struggling, and YP vulnerable.
Support for young people and whānau w/FASD is a huge gap, and it is this lack of support that sees way to many yp with FASD end up involved in crime, or experiencing homelessness. Again a reminder that punishment as prevention is a far to simplistic "solution".
4. Mental health and again lack of support for young people and whānau going through depression, anxiety, and other complex MH challenges, is often also a factor. If we fail to provide people with support to manage the complexity of their lives, they will find ways to survive.
It might sound weird to you, but I've met so many young people that got involved in burgs and car jacking as a way to cope with the anxiety and depression they were experiencing.
It might not seem rationale to you, but when a person is suffering and finds a strategy that can ease the pain, they'll use that strategy. For some young people, taking risks, stealing cars, doing a burg, it becomes one of those strategies.
5. Addiction is often another factor here. Now, it's important to note, that when our young people are using alcohol or other drugs, often again this is a survival mechanism. When a YP is in pain, when they're experiencing mental illness, when they lack the support...
...and resources to cope and heal from these things, they find ways to survive. Often alcohol and other drugs end up filling the void.
6. Poverty, homelessness and desperation also plays a role for those young people from lower socioeconomic communities. We're talking about YP who have nothing, who are struggling to survive, and who have been abandoned by the state and rejected by our communities.
Sound bite solutions like harsher punishment and more police don't work because they fail to respond what is actually going on beneath all this stuff. We cannot punish our way out of any of this. If we are serious about prevention, than we need to get serious about ensuring....
...everyone has the #Right2Housing, that everyone has #LiveableIncomes, that holistic health, disability, and mental health services are available to our whānau. We need to invest in our people, our communities, and provide aroha and manaaki to those who are suffering.
If you want to have a "lockem up and throw away the key" attitude go for it. But, know that it doesn't make our communities safer, it doesn't prevent crime, it actually exacerbates the harm within our community.
The Gospel is political, but its not Nationalistic. Those who wish to tie our faith to the expansion and supremacy of the state miss the point the Divine is making on the cross.
The politics of Jesus are the politics of Love. Love for neighbor, love for self, love for enemy... To pick up the sword in the name of Christ is to deny both name and message
Jesus has no need of a Christian nation. Let's not waste our time on trying to legislate our morality.
Instead let us join the Divine in solidarity with those who suffer, the poor, the oppressed. Let us give ourselves over to Dreaming the Dream. To Divine Imagination.
The idea that somehow homeless whānau stealing Kai is about entitlement and lack of consequences fails to grasp the issue...
Let's put this in context. We have whānau, suffering from such extreme poverty that they are living on our streets. Many of these whānau are mentally unwell, have disabilities, and have exp significant truama in their lives. Materially they have little to nothing.
Accessing the benefit is also not that easy when ur sleeping rough. From the moment u walk in the door there are barriers, homeless whānau often report exp discrimination and that they don't get the support they need. Simple things like having a bank acc can become a barrier...
"Moving a problem along, doesn't solve the problem." @_chloeswarbrick
About 4 yrs ago the business association in a community I was serving in decided that it wanted to do something about the rough sleeping whānau in our hood
There were some real challenges being exp, w/begging on the streets, pple suffering from complex MH/Addiction , extreme poverty and whānau who had no where else but the street to call home
The business association wanted us and the police to move the whānau on. Of course we knew this wouldn't solve the issue. We had whānau suffering from poverty and homelessness, that was the problem that needed addressing.
This morning I had coffee with a bro who I know from way back whose living on the streets atm.
He shared with me some of what he's dealing with and we discussed how he's going in his recovery. It's been rough, and my heart broke as he shared with me a familiar story.
A story of how a system which is intended to help him, creates hoop after hoop for him to jump through, expects so much of him, let gives him so little.
A story of struggle, of fighting to change his circumstances, only to be pulled down again by the shackles of poverty and addiction that seem someàhow designed to keep him in "his place".
There's a open letter to @_chloeswarbrick@phil_goff doing the rounds on redit regarding some of the challenges we're exp in the inner city due to the extreme levels of poverty, social exclusion, and truama our whānau are exp-ing. I'm not going to link to the letter but...
... there are a couple of points I want to address.
1) more police and tougher punishment won't make our city safer. The root of these issues are truama and a lack of access to our ppls basic human rights. Punishment does not bring healing, it simply causes more harm
2. If we're serious abt addressing the challenges our city is exp than we need 2 get serious about providing whānau w/housing, a liveable income, access to MH/health services, support tht meets their needs Poverty is the underlying issue, eradicate it, and we'll make some prgrss