So yes, let’s deal w/the insane access to weapons of war. But don’t say “it’s all about guns.” Because they used to hang us from trees in front of the courthouse.They have killed us w/swords in Manhattan, dragged us behind cars in Jasper, Tx. They have beaten us to death.
They have chased us into traffic in Howard Beach, and kneeled on our necks in Minneapolis. They’ve run us over with cars. The poison of white supremacy has been attached to every instrumentality of violence. And yes, guns are uniquely deadly, & we must address it urgently.
But so too is white supremacy. It is used to manipulate elections, to destroy public education, to deny disaster relief, to justify starving babies, to poison communities, to destroy empathy, to deny the truth, to steal land, & has the power to turn people into murderers.
So let’s all get to work - on addressing gun access for sure. But white ppl must address the spread of white supremacist ideology by politicians, in primetime on cable TV, on the internet, in schools, in your churches and homes. It is a threat to our lives, and to your humanity.
But white supremacy is also an existential threat to our democracy. It always has been.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Prince Edward’s County, VA closed the schools for five years rather than comply with Brown. Five. Years. 101 Members of Congress signed the Southern Manifesto vowing to resist Brown by all legal means. Perhaps I should start a thread showing that “public acceptance”…..
Here’s the public “accepting” Brown in Little Rock, Ark 3 years after the decision. Just white parents showing their acceptance by terrorizing a teenaged Elizabeth Eckford on her attempt to begin her first day of school at Central High School.
Here we are in 1960. White parents in Louisiana so “accepted” Brown that 6 year old Ruby Bridges needed to be escorted by federal officers to and from school.
In fact @DLeonhardt’s piece suffers from the same blindspot as much of the school closure convos. Yes, remote learning negatively affected learning for many children. But closures were also to protect teachers. Who are people. Many are vulnerable to COVID or live w/ppl who are.
So comparing COVID rates among students is only part of the story. You’d need have to data on COVID infection rates & deaths among Black & Brown communities in states w closures contrasted with those that opened. Children are one factor in the school ecosystem. Not the only.
As an explanation this fails and even mystifyingly avoids the obvious. It’s no surprise that unions would prioritize protecting their workers - teachers. The Dem/Rep analysis does little here except as a proxy for the more holistic considerations on closures compelled by unions.
It is important that those w/power & influence who insisted that those of us who have been ringing the alarm - long before Trump - were alarmist need to openly acknowledge & apologize for their errors. B/c to do so will create space for a truly different analysis & approach.
You can’t just catastrophically misdiagnose American politics, law, & foreign policy, tamp down the voices of those who accurately recognized the danger & then mildly adjust your analysis as our democracy unravels. Ask yourself, why did you get it wrong? What are your blindspots?
Do you have the courage to learn from those differently positioned to see this country more clearly? Because your lack of humility, your effort to offer spackle & paint where a full restructure is needed will slow down the urgency we need in this moment.
@ezraklein Thanks for the continuation if your thoughts here @ezralevin. You will get no push back from me on the flaws of thinking about Twitter as “the public square.” It was not perfect. But something quite promising has been the ongoing struggles & demands for equity on Twitter.
@ezraklein@ezralevin Black & Latino ppl, Muslim voices, women, LGBTQIA ppl have had to fight to use our voices, to obtain attn & respect for our insights, & to fight for protection from threats, violence & stalking when we speak.
@ezraklein@ezralevin The demand for content moderation & the early alarm sounded by Black women on Twitter about threats of violence actually created a negotiation over the boundaries of legit discourse on this space. That actually has been the quality most promising to the “public square” concept.
.@ezraklein this is a deeply inadequate assessment of what has been twitter’s value. I had only been on the platform a short while when, on a Sat afternoon, I saw the rising anger & intense response to the killing of a young Black man whose body lay in the streets for hours.
The young man’s name was Mike Brown & he had been killed by a police ofcr in Ferguson, MO. By Sun. night we activated a team at @NAACP_LDF. It wasn’t untilTues that MSM outlets carried the story. Over wks activists, protesters & attys connected in real time on what was happening.
I saw the murder of Walter Scott on this platform. I saw also a copy of the incident report submitted by the ofcr that was at odds w that video. Same for the arrest of Freddie Gray. Same for the conduct of law enforcement in violently attacking protesters.
Given the response to my tweet yesterday abt @nhannahjones’ gripping response to Chris Wallace’s insistence that while our country was engaged in racial oppression it wasn’t ordinary young men from the heartland, let me recommend a few books:
Start with @readwarren67’s powerful memoir The Lyncher in Me, about his journey upon discovering the role of his grandfather in the 1920 lynching of 3 Black men in Duluth, MN. warren-read.com/works/books/th… @JamesFallows has just posted a thread about this lynching.
Spend time w/Cynthia Carr’s Our Town: A Heartland Lynching, A Haunted Town, & the Hidden History of White America. penguinrandomhouse.com/books/24382/ou… - an exploration of secrets & truth in the author’s hometown of Marion, Indiana where a terrible, well-documented lynching occurred in 1930.