We don’t deserve someone so thoughtful and considering in the SEC, but I’m grateful @HesterPeirce is there. More and more, I’ve been thinking that “carbon accounting” as it exists and is evolving, is a dead end for reversing climate change. There’s far too much ambiguity.
Q: How much carbon would be removed if all Fortune 500 companies offset their entire Scope 1, 2, and 3 footprint?
A: Not anywhere close to enough.
We have to think bigger than corporate carbon offsetting! There are 1.5 TRILLION tonnes up there that we need to remove from the atmosphere. The govt has a hammer (disclosure mandates), and so everything looks like a nail. But for us nimble #ReFi startups, we can be more creative
We need to gamify carbon removal. Build positive feedback loops so that as profits increase, more carbon gets removed. This is exactly what @Stepnofficial is doing with @nori
I wish the carbon removal startups who are working on accounting solutions well, but we’re playing a different game. Helping corporates get more ESG friendly isn’t good enough. That barely scratches the surface. We need carbon removal (payments) integrated into *everything.*
That’s the only way we’ll ever get to a future where we’re removing 75-100 billion tonnes every year. This SEC disclosure mandate is nonsense and is going to make it even more difficult to reverse climate change. @HesterPeirce’s statement lays out all the problems with it.
If you want to work on something that actually has a chance at *scaling* climate change reversal, come check out the @nori careers page. We have a lot of roles open! nori.com/careers
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This by @neel_dhan is the best I've seen at characterizing the actual problems in carbon removal/offset industry. All these web3 offset marketplaces are making the mistake of assuming this is a demand-side liquidity problem. There is not enough supply! 1/
Carbon credits should not be traded. Period. They should be retired immediately upon first sale. Immediate retirement ensures the financial incentives are driven towards the people removing the CO2, not rent-seeking middleman brokers.
2/
If your favorite web3 offset marketplace is focused on the trading of the credits, then they're doing this wrong. The hard part is not the transacting. The hard part is ensuring the underly carbon assets ACTUALLY REMOVE CARBON FROM THE AIR. That's the point of this right?