The Cultural Tutor Profile picture
Jun 18, 2022 17 tweets 7 min read Read on X
The Danger of Minimalist Design

(& the death of detail)

A short thread...
Image
Image
This isn't an attack on capital M Minimalism, which is a conscious design movement.

Like the Minimalist music of the composer Philip Glass, which is frankly beautiful.
What I'm talking about is unconscious, small m minimalism.

Which has become the social default for seemingly every design choice, whether architectural or corporate or anything else.

It is a troubling phenomenon because of what minimalism represents: a lack of detail. ImageImage
Why does detail matter? Think of it as identity.

What gives the phone box on the left its distinctive character?

The details: colour, mouldings around the door, the ornamentation at the top.

The phone box on the right has no real detail, and no character. ImageImage
I'm not necessarily talking about beauty here.

I'm just talking about things having some discernible qualities & characteristics.

The bollard on the left is hardly "beautiful," but it *does* have some character.

The one on the right... it exists. That's all. ImageImage
Even benches have been minimalized! ImageImage
And doorbells too!

You would remember the one on the left. It adds charm & character to its location.

The one on the right... you wouldn't even notice it. ImageImage
How many large corporations have rebranded towards far more simplified logos?

This is a notorious recent example. Image
The thing with detail (and, therefore, identity) is that people have different tastes.

So, to some extent, it imposes something on a person.

Default minimalist designs strips all identity away from things.

It presents a neutral, clean-slate which imposes nothing.
So when small m minimalism has become the social default for everything from benches & bollards to skyscrapers & national assemblies....

We have a reduction ad absurdum of cultural aesthetics:

Somebody might not like a detail (read: character) so there can be no details. ImageImage
It is an IKEA Bookcase world.

(Nothing wrong with IKEA Bookcases necessarily, but when everything looks like one, well...) ImageImage
Please remember that I am not talking about a conscious minimalism here.

If you like to decorate your room in a minimalist fashion, that *isn't* a problem. It's none of mine or anybody else's business.

The problem is this social drift towards absolute simplification...
The worst crime of minimalist design is how it has stripped all colour away from things. ImageImage
Perhaps minimalist design is so prevalent because we no longer have anything to say.

You don't need me to explain what the Gothic cathedral says, for example.

But the skyscraper? It doesn't say anything, really. It's just... *there*. ImageImage
And suddenly everything, everywhere starts to look the same.

Absolute neutrality. No detail. No identity.

What does that say about us? Image
Anyway, I'm off to sit in the garden & listen to Bedřich Smetana's Má Vlast...
I'm enjoying the discussion this thread has generated so far!

And if you found it thought-provoking you may also like my free weekly newsletter, Areopagus.

Seven short lessons every Friday, including architecture, classical music, & art.

getrevue.co/profile/cultur…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with The Cultural Tutor

The Cultural Tutor Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @culturaltutor

May 5
Napoleon died 204 years ago today.

He rose from obscurity, joined a revolution, became an emperor, tried to conquer Europe, failed, spent his last days in exile — and changed the world forever.

This is the life of Napoleon, told in 19 paintings: Image
1. Bonaparte at the Pont d'Arcole by Antoine-Jean Gros (1796)

Napoleon's life during the French Revolution was complicated, but by the age of 24 he was already a General.

Here, aged just 27, he led the armies of the French Republic to victory in Italy — his star was rising. Image
2. The Battle of the Pyramids by François-Louis-Joseph Watteau (1799)

Two years later Napoleon oversaw the invasion of Egypt as part of an attempt to undermine British trade.

At the Battle of the Pyramids he led the French to a crushing victory over the Ottomans and Mamluks. Image
Read 20 tweets
Apr 27
It took 8 architects, 21 popes, and 120 years to build and finish St Peter's Basilica in Rome.

And, four centuries later, it's still the largest church in the world.

So here's a brief introduction to St Peter's... Image
The first impression anybody has when they see St Peter's Basilica in Rome, in real life or in a photo, is awe.

Because this is an immensely impressive building — it was and remains the world's largest church by volume.

Others are taller, but none are so vast. Image
The same is true of the inside — a cornucopia of art and architecture, of gold and bronze and marble and mosaic and sculpture.

And, again, it has proportions beyond gargantuan.

The baldachin alone (a kind of ornate canopy, below) is 30 metres tall. Image
Read 25 tweets
Apr 22
The Sistine Chapel is one of the world's greatest buildings, and it has the most famous ceiling in history.

But what is it, who built it, and what does "Sistine" even mean?

Well, here's the surprisingly controversial history of the Sistine Chapel... Image
Where did the Sistine Chapel get its name?

It was commissioned in 1473 by Pope Sixtus IV and completed nine years later.

His name in Italian was Sisto and the chapel was named after him, hence "Sistine" Chapel. Image
Where is the Sistine Chapel?

It's within the Apostolic Palace — the Pope's official residence — in the Vatican City.

But, for such a famous and important building, it isn't very noteworthy or impressive from the outside. Image
Read 25 tweets
Apr 18
This is Burg Hohenzollern in Germany, one of the world's most beautiful Medieval castles.

Except that it isn't a Medieval castle — trains had been invented before it was built.

And so Hohenzollern is a perfect introduction to Neo-Gothic Architecture... Image
If you want to understand Neo-Gothic Architecture then the best place to begin is with something like Hohenzollern.

It seems too good to be true — and that's because it is.

What you're looking at here isn't a Medieval castle; it's not even 200 years old. Image
There has been some kind of fortification on this hill, at the edge of the Swabian Alps, for over one thousand years.

An 11th century castle was destroyed and replaced in the 15th century, but that second castle soon fell into ruin. Image
Read 24 tweets
Apr 14
This painting has no brush strokes — it is made from over 2,000,000 individual dots of colour.

And although it looks like nothing more than a sunny afternoon in Paris, it has a much darker hidden meaning... Image
In the 1870s the Impressionists, led by Claude Monet, burst onto the French art scene.

Rather than painting classical themes in studios according to the principles of the Renaissance, as they had been taught in the Academy, the Impressionists took art outside... Image
And there they painted the world as they actually saw it, with all the changing light, shadow, blur, and movement of real life — rather than how they were "supposed" to see it.

And instead of the grand subjects of Academic art, they painted scenes from ordinary life. Image
Read 23 tweets
Apr 5
This is the Queen's Stepwell in Gujarat, India, built nearly 1,000 years ago.

It's incredible, but it isn't unique — India is filled with hundreds of stepwells just like it.

Here is the story of the world's most extraordinary underground architecture... Image
Water management was (and remains) one of the biggest challenges for any society.

When you have a large group of people living in one place you need to provide water for drinking, bathing, washing, irrigation, and more.

The only question is... how?
In India, between the 3rd and 5th centuries AD, a very special way of managing water emerged: stepwells, known variously as baoli, bawri, or vav.

They were a solution to the problem of water supply in regions without consistent rainfall. Image
Read 19 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(