Why Beauty Matters

(and how it has been destroyed by "usability")

A short thread...
I want to make clear that this thread *isn't* about returning to the past.

This is strictly about the future.

But we shouldn't simply accept things because "that's the way there are."

The past teaches us that we can do better.
Why does beauty matter?

That sounds like a superfluous question, but in the 21st century it has become a vital one.

Before I try & give you an explanation, however, I think we should define beauty.
Beauty isn't just ornamentation for the sake of it.

That is garishness. That is luxury. That is vanity.

This is *not* beauty:
But compare these two train station bridges.

Both ordinary, everyday things.

One is beautiful, & the other is not.
Beauty is that aesthetic quality which elevates ordinary things into something more meaningful.

It is what gives us - humans - something more than just a material, automated, machine-like existence.
A great example is the bathroom.

Ostensibly a place of supreme utility and nothing else. A personal waste management facility, basically...

Really?
Another good example is something as simple as door-handles.

They don't need to be dripping with gold. But even the slightest detail or character can work wonders.
There is no single aesthetic standard.

That's why there are beautiful things in every country around the world, and why they all look different.

And that's how it ought to be. Why would we want everything to look the same?
And when beauty dies, everything *does* start to look the same. Usability has no identity.

Cities around the world once looked totally different. Now they are becoming identical.
But don't just take my word for the importance of beauty. Where do tourists go?

Rome, Paris, Venice, Kyoto, Istanbul...

What do those cities all have in common?
Why do people get married in *nice* buildings rather than, say, warehouses?

That's a serious question.

Whether churches, country houses, hotels, or town halls, people seem to prefer a - dare I say it - beautiful location.
And when people actually do get married in warehouses....

They choose beautiful warehouses with aesthetic character!
Why do people decorate their homes? Another genuine question.

The human yearning for beauty - not luxury, but aesthetic character - is undeniable.

So why have things become so ugly? Usability has become the priority.
A vitally important point is that beauty and utility are NOT mutually exclusive.

The Roman architect Vitruvius believed that every building should have three qualities:
-strength
-usefulness
-beauty

If that was possible 2000 years ago, why not now?
Things *should* be useful, no less than they should be beautiful.

But neither should be allowed to take precedence at the cost of the other.

The elevator on the left is both, but the one on the right isn't...
What's the danger of a world without beauty?

If everything is simply functional, simply useful, then life becomes a mere conveyor belt.

It turns humans into machines of consumption, labour, & reproduction.

Aren't we more than that?
It's also a conversation with future generations.

All over the world, our ancestors have left behind works of art & architecture for us to enjoy, admire, and use.

What do we want to leave for future generations? Buildings that need knocking down in 50 years, or something more?
As for the causes - that's another thread.

In previous threads people have mentioned capitalism, economics, the loss of religious faith etc.

No doubt the causes are multiple & compound

But the first step is recognising the problem.
Some will raise the objection that beauty costs money...

It's a question of priority, not cost. And, therefore, it is a choice - conscious or unconscious - every time.

This boiler-plate new building at Durham University, England, cost £40 million.
Did it *have* to look this way?

Or could the view that a beautiful building can inspire students have been factored in?

The trade-off might have been to make it a little smaller. But that might just be a worthy trade-off.
Second - even when beauty *does* cost more... what price is too high for a society whose architecture and design doesn't treat people like machines?

Or one in which most new schools look like prisons?! Is cutting costs really *that* important?
I think that's enough for now.

How can beauty come back to life?

Meanwhile I'm going to take a walk and listen to Dvořák's 6th symphony...
I went for a lovely long walk.

Glad to see that this thread has got people talking!

And if you liked it, then my newsletter Areopagus may also be of interest to you.

I share seven short lessons every Friday. They include art, architecture, and history.

getrevue.co/profile/cultur…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with The Cultural Tutor

The Cultural Tutor Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @culturaltutor

Jun 24
Six weeks ago I quit my job and set myself a challenge.

Start a Twitter account. Share the things I care deeply about for at least 30 days. See what happens.

And today I've hit 100k followers. Thank you. To all of you. Truly 🙏

But this is just the beginning:
My dream was to share the things you've always wanted to learn about, in a way which is understandable but doesn't lose the depth.

To me this would be "a beautiful education."

And it's resonated with people. This has been a remarkable adventure so far.
Now I want to do it full-time & bring you even more. Not only on Twitter but elsewhere.

I'd love to create as much free content as I can. A beautiful education for all.

But I'm not just going to ask for donations. I want to provide something of quality in return.
Read 14 tweets
Jun 22
Have you ever walked through a park or forest and realised you don't know what all the different trees are called?

Well here's how to recognise 13 common trees:

(and get more in touch with the natural world)
1. Birch

Medium sized trees with a few different species, but the best way to recognise a birch is by its bark.

It is often covered in "lenticels" (the horizontal lines in the image) and comes off in thin, papery strips.
2. Dogwood

A beautiful flowering tree which can be recognised by its bark, which looks like alligator skin, its smooth oval leaves, and the famous clusters of white flowers.
Read 16 tweets
Jun 21
To new followers, welcome 🙏

Here's 12 of my previous threads to give you some idea of what to expect from me:

(plus a beautiful painting by Ivan Aivazovsky) The Ninth Wave by Ivan Aivazovsky (1850)
1. Classical Music

Classical music is beautiful, fascinating, and more important than ever.

I talk about it often.

This was my beginner's guide:

2. History

I like to dig out the interesting historical details you don't necessarily find in textbooks.

Like a 12th century Medieval university curriculum:

Read 19 tweets
Jun 21
OUT NOW - and completely free.

An Introduction to Western Civilisation

Short excerpts from 120 vital works of history, literature, philosophy, and more.
This book is a free resource for all those who either don't where to start or don't have the time to read all the classics.

I hope you find it interesting, useful, & beautiful.

Here's the download link:
sheehanquirke.com/iwc

Now let's look at what's included...
There are eight sections:

-History
-Literature
-Philosophy & Theology
-Politics & Political Philosophy
-Art, Architecture, Astronomy, & Geography
-Law
-Speeches & Rhetoric
-Military History & Theory

And here's what's included in each section:
Read 15 tweets
Jun 20
Nine more Crusades in 9 Tweets: The Battle of Grunwald by Jan Matejko (1878)
1. Crusade Against Roger II of Sicily (1127-1135)

A shamelessly political crusade in which there was no actual fighting.

Roger II supported the antipope, Anacletus. So Pope Innocent II preached a crusade against him.

It laid the foundations for later political crusades.
2. Wendish Crusade (1147)

The Wends were pagans who lived in northeast Germany & Poland, and whose lands were rich with resources.

With the blessing of Pope Eugenius III, the Holy Roman Empire invaded, took control, and exacted tribute.

But the Wends took a while to convert...
Read 11 tweets
Jun 20
How to write & give a speech like Cicero:

(the greatest orator of the Roman Republic)
Writing & giving speeches isn't easy. It never has been.

But being able to speak persuasively is a vital life skill.

So who better to look to than Cicero (106 - 43 B.C.), regarded as one of - if not the - greatest speaker in history.
In Cicero's first treatise on rhetoric, De Inventione, he outlines the five stages of creating & delivering a speech.

They are relatively simple and still apply to this day, whether at work, over a drink, or in the House of Commons.

But why can we trust Cicero?
Read 20 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(