Today's decision sharply restricting EPA's ability to regulate greenhouse gases from power plants is fascinating.
First, two small but epic tidbits:
1. US power plants & energy companies achieved the GHG reductions EPA wanted *without the plan ever being put into law*!
—>
2/ Yes: The energy market in the US, the push for lower emitting sources & renewables — all that together reduced greenhouse gases by more than what the EPA was trying to achieve — and the Supreme Court never let EPA's plan go into effect.
What's that mean?
—>
3/ It means that the regulatory effort the EPA was trying to put into place couldn't have been particularly radical or disruptive — because the market leaped ahead of EPA and did it.
(It doesn't mean the plan wasn't necessary. More on that in a bit.)
Standards for pollution — and also for information companies must release, how stock markets function.
This is 'the administrative state.'
Congress makes laws. The 'alphabet agencies' implement them.
3/ The EPA — for instance — takes months to study problems, issue rules with all kinds of scientific detail — and then take comment and revise those rules.
With scientists & input, EPA takes years to refine Congress's instruction.
“Just because you jump across a state line doesn’t mean your home state doesn’t have jurisdiction,” said Peter Breen, sr. counsel for the Thomas More Society. “It’s not a free abortion card when you drive across the state line.”
• Where you can travel as a free American in the US.
• What you can do while traveling outside anti-abortion states.
If GA has a 70 mph speed limit & FL has a 60 mph speed limit, FL CANNOT charge speeding for driving 70 in GA.
3/ DC has strict gun laws. Virginia does not. DC can’t charge residents with gun law violations for using guns in Virginia — in ways that would be illegal in DC.
Republicans seem to be leaving behind their passion for individual liberty.
I'm live-streaming Wellesley College commencement this morning, because we have a family friend graduating.
The speaker: Nergis Mavalvala.
Nergis is Dean of Science at MIT.
BS from Wellesley.
PhD from MIT.
All that is amazing enough:
Not many people end up as a dean at MIT.
2/ But here's the thing:
Nergis Mavalvala — an astrophysicist professor of physics, a brilliant pioneering researcher & wonderfully accessible mentor — Nergis comes from a family where neither Mom or Dad went to college.
From no college to PhD dean at MIT in one leap.
3/ In her talk this morning, Nergis told the assembled Wellesley class of 2022 that she grew up in Karachi, Pakistan.
Two of her key teachers as a young girl:
The owner of a bike repair shop, who taught her to fix her own bike (she couldn't afford to pay for repairs).
2/ These are first-hand accounts from parents who were outside the school in Uvalde.
Just mind-boggling. Frantic parents urging police — for 20, 30 min — to go in & take out the shooter. Heavily armed police decided instead to restrain the parents.